Ken Hallock

Never heard of this place, but was told they were best wings in town, and double dipped. I'd never heard of that before, so I had to try. Bonus, not far from my house. It's a small cozy place, there was a wait for a table so we sat at the bar. Sat next to a woman who was buying 100 wings to take home to SC! She said they were the best too, and whenever she is back in town to visit, she comes and takes some home. I was really excited now. The beer selection is minimal, only 4 on tap, the rest was bottled domestic beer. The bar tender/server was really friendly and answered all our questions. On recommendation, we ordered double dipped Cajun/honey mustard, the rest med buffalo with a side of fries. It took a minute, but not too long. Let me tell you, when she brought them out I was amazed, I have never gotten wing anywhere in Buffalo where there was steam pouring off the wings, those things were so hot, temp wise, we had to wait to eat them. They were big and juicy and perfectly cooked. The fries were also hot and crispy. I will definitely be coming back here this will be my regular wing spot, bonus they are close by and the price was reasonable.

R T R

Wings were great..pizza logs too. Beef on weck not so much...

+1

EJ Maisonneuve

Best wings and blue cheese I have ever had! The place was packed at 6 pm on a Tuesday which I think says a lot about the quality. The staff was super helpful and friendly as well.

Elisa M

In town for a quick visit and I asked our hotel front desk for some recommendations. Elmo's was one of them and I am so glad we came. The wings were absolutely delicious 😋 another patron recommended double dip mild and Cajun and all I can say is I wish I lived closer. Must stop if you are in the neighborhood

A M

Very unique technique for preparing wings! The double -dipped method with some griling in between makes for an added depth of flavor. At first I was put off about there not being many flavors to choose from. Once the waitress explained that I could mix-and-match each layer of the sauce, I loved being able to "customize" my wings. Ended up with a hot honey mustard that was fantastic! I look forward to my next visit, to see what other great flavor combinations we find.

Blaine Laird

Had the double dip wings. Picked Cajun and BBQ as my two flavors. The wings were top-notch. The wings were almost fall off the bone, and the skin was crispy. They had a deep smoky flavor that I loved. The blue cheese was very good as well. I will go for these wings anytime I'm in Buffalo.

One of the best places for wings. I suggest Cajun with hot, Cajun with honey mustard and Cajun with bbq double dip! Always amazing wings! The bartender, I believe Rebecca, is wonderful. She is so funny and loves when you sit at a table instead of the bar! 😉😂

Mohammad Albayed

Great wings, but it took an hour to get my food during the Bills game. I get that it was busy, but they should be better prepared for big events. Still, the wings were tasty and worth the wait!

Chris L

I’ve been here 3 times, I went for the wings. 1 time they were the best wings I’ve had maybe ever and the other 2 times they were a 6.5 at best. They just didn’t cook them long enough. I ordered them x-crispy and they weren’t even regular crispy. Needed another 2+ minutes. Prices weren’t cheap and not worth risking it a 4th time.

Albert “No Onions” Ruggiero

We got 4 different kinds of double dipped wings. The Cajun mixed with the honey mustard was the clear winner then there was medium hot/honey mustard, double honey mustard and double mild. First off, I want to say that i love the flavor of frying a wing and then grilling it. There’s a place where im from that does that really well. On some of these songs, the grill flavor shined through and on others you couldn’t even taste it. The blue cheese was fantastic and easily my favorite thing there. Loved dipping the French fries into it. Anyway, if you do the double dip, make sure to do Cajun/honey mustard.

Matt A

I dont get the hype. How this place consistently lands on Best wings lists is beyond me. Order 3 different types of wings each one was dry and over cooked. The bar is nice doesn't feel crowded even when packed. Service wasn't bad. Not a bad place for a drink, but better choices for food in my opinion

Nick Carter

Ordered 20 wings and fries to dine in. The wings taste like charcoal, dehydrated mummy, carbon element, Sahara desert. Look how small the wings are compared with the dipping cup. I don't know if this is Elmo's style or just overcooked, pretty disappointed. Told the waitress about this and got a response "OK".

Elizabeth Z

One and done. Would not recommend. We went here for dinner last Friday and ordered wings and “Melissa fries.” We tried three kinds of wings — Cajun, BBQ, and Medium. The Cajun wings were actually pretty good, but the medium ones were not medium at all. They were basically tasteless and had an overwhelming vinegar flavor. The BBQ wings were the worst — so overcooked and charred that they were black and bitter. The burnt flavor made them really hard to eat. The “Melissa fries” were described like chili cheese fries, but they were a big disappointment. The fries were soggy, the chili had no real flavor (just beans and meat), and the cheese was thick, heavy, and bland. Overall, it was just gross and unappetizing. This place was recommended by a coworker who loves wings, but I honestly don’t understand the appeal. Definitely a one and done for us — I wouldn’t recommend the food at all.