Buffalo Bill's Brewery

Karan Bhansali

Buffalo Bill's is an excellent brewery to visit if you are in the Hayward area. There is ample public parking behind Buffalo Bill's which makes this place very accessible. They have a large menu with a wide variety of appetizers, sandwiches, pizza, beer, wine & non-alcoholic beverages. We ordered the Veggie Pizza, Nachos, Pretzel & Mac and Cheese - all the items were well cooked and had good flavor.

Mike Nolan

Buffalo Bill's is back and better than ever! The food, beer & service is all very, very good! Sat outside with our dog, had a nice, cozy setup and when it got chilly, they turned on the heaters and made it very comfortable for all of us! Can't wait to try everything else on the menu!

Don Frasco

Lots of free parking spaces are available. Lots of indoor and outdoor seating. Make reservations for big groups. Great place to enjoy craft beer and watch sports. Must try their Tasmanian and Stout beers. Their fish and chips were humongous and crispy.

Vicky T

Talk about having something unique on the menu and making a great impression. Well here at Buffalo Bill's they have these potato chips that I really enjoyed. Food is great and they have a beer brewery in the restaurant. Unfortunately I couldn't drink since I was on my way to work -next time tho. The service great and prices are decent.

Becca Gomez Farrell

Happy to see that Buffalo Bill's Brewery really is basically the same with its new owners! There may be a couple ingredient editions here and there changed, and I'm sure we'll see new menu items on occasion, but I was delighted to see so many old favorites and the same great beers. Can't wait until my throat issues are calmed enough for a pumpkin stout! Pictured: Very creamy Devil's Mac with a nice chili kick and carne pizza with ALL THE MEAT.

Corey Strock

Had a great Pizza and a tasty beer. Came in there w/ a friend and 5 kids and everybody left happy. I had an all meat pizza that had Pastrami on it, which is not normally on Pizza, though it probably should be :) I also had a Strawberry Doppelweizen beer that was flavorful and didn't betray the fact that it had an 8.8% alcohol percentage lol. My daughter ended up with the Kobe Sliders and she enjoyed them well enough, I tried them myself and thought they were pretty good. The price was pretty reasonable, and I left with a 6 pack of a Strawberry Blonde and a 22 of a Black Pumpkin Stout. I'm going to stop in here again, I'm pretty sure.

Jonathan Monte

Even though this is a brewery it has a very family friendly atmosphere. The food is really good, the service is awesome, and the atmosphere is superior. I highly recommended to get the sweat potato frys! UPDATE: everything above still applies with the new owner (Summer 2023). We were thrilled to see that they had a dessert menu. That includes cheesecake chocolate cake slices and even creme brulee!! The menu was plentiful and robust. I was only slightly disappointed that they were missing the taz sauce on the side for the bacon onion burger along with its tasty special mayonnaise they had. But even with that small disappointment, I'm still planning on coming back to this establishment regularly! Hopefully they'll add those sauces back on request. Accommodating for dogs are available outside!

Outdoor space was awesome for us and our pup. Food was good and tasty and so was the beer. Service was prompt and the vibe was nice. Fair warning though, park your car out front where you can keep an eye on it. While we were there, some cars got broken into out back. Management was proactive in making sure the patrons that got hit were helped ASAP. Definitely give them props there.

Excellent service I came to eat with my husband here for many years and although they have changed owners they have always had an excellent service, if there’s something and you’re not happy with your order they always look for a way to make you feel good like you’re at home. Excellent place 😉 to enjoy with friends or family.

Jordan Michael

My partner and I come here weekly because we live close, and it is always a source of joy and good vibes for us. Great food, good beer, and reasonable prices make this place a can't miss in the Hayward downtown area.

M B

Outdoor space was awesome for us and our pup. Food was good and tasty and so was the beer. Service was prompt and the vibe was nice. Fair warning though, park your car out front where you can keep an eye on it. While we were there, some cars got broken into out back. Management was proactive in making sure the patrons that got hit were helped ASAP. Definitely give them props there.

HH Happy hour T-F 3-6p & Mon 2pm-close $5-12 food wings sliders fries ribs $20pizza&beer deal. Enjoy the window seat tables to look out onto B St as patrons walk by, or patio. Ok service. One of the few sit down restaurants to enjoy right on B St to enjoy an evening in that area, some open air seating, window seats, real brewery. ▪︎ Gorgonzola salad delish, unsure about addition of sundried tomatoes flavor wise, but enjoyed their satisfying umami bite/texture on the salad which I tried as meatless. $18 or $26 with chicken seems like a premium entree price though. ▪︎ Poppers are uniquely wrapped in a pastry dough & so filling, shareable with 3+ ppl, be ready but soft and yummy heavy of course but less greasy than other renditions I'll say. ▪︎ Pork shortribs got 4 on HH deal, dry rub seems to have chili powder, not too saucy, not too classic of bbq flavor but flavored up & meaty, looked like a regular pork rib cut. Coleslaw wasn't so cold, it was a bit creamy & may need some tang/vinegar. May try dish next time. ▪︎ 8 chicken wings lemon pepper dry rub were tasty, perhaps salty made us thirsty, would like more lemon zest & coarse pepper with perhaps less salt. The celery carrot salad was enjoyable with it. ▪︎ We'll be back for a B St vibe evening. 3rd Thurs nights in summer the city puts on a fest live band and stage right out front of Buffalo, we started at Bills early then pursued the street fest.

Its a cool place. Tons of free parking. The menu is well put together with pairings to the beer in mind. The only reason I'm taking 1 star off is because 2 of the 4 things we ordered were wrong. The burger was undercooked My Nachos had sour cream when I ordered it with no sour cream and it had a bunch of it, the cheese was not melted and came out luke warm. The fires were pretty good and the wings were on point. Maybe the kitchen just had a rough day or the timing was off.

We enjoyed ourselves thoroughly on a really busy Saturday night. Those waffle sweet potato fries are the business! The stuffed jalapeños were (uge). The fried pickles could be sliced in half if You ask me, but the flavor was great. That barbecue sauce for the perfectly cooked wings was wonderfully seasoned.

I've lived in Silicon Valley for 18 years, on weekends we usually go out to spend a night in another city on the bay. We chose Hayward because I wanted to see the Japanese park that I had been told would be full of hummingbirds at that time. It was not the case. Then we went to lunch to B Street in downtown, there are several options. We liked the terrace in the sun, we sat down and ordered a BLT Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted wheat with fries, a Half and Half (half of any sandwich with half of any soup or salad) despite the great variety of beers, we ask for water because we don't drink alcohol. The service was fast and attentive. I highly recommend this place for a bite and drink with friends.

Sara F. S.

HH Happy hour T-F 3-6p & Mon 2pm-close $5-12 food wings sliders fries ribs $20pizza&beer deal. Enjoy the window seat tables to look out onto B St as patrons walk by, or patio. Ok service. One of the few sit down restaurants to enjoy right on B St to enjoy an evening in that area, some open air seating, window seats, real brewery. ▪︎ Gorgonzola salad delish, unsure about addition of sundried tomatoes flavor wise, but enjoyed their satisfying umami bite/texture on the salad which I tried as meatless. $18 or $26 with chicken seems like a premium entree price though. ▪︎ Poppers are uniquely wrapped in a pastry dough & so filling, shareable with 3+ ppl, be ready but soft and yummy heavy of course but less greasy than other renditions I'll say. ▪︎ Pork shortribs got 4 on HH deal, dry rub seems to have chili powder, not too saucy, not too classic of bbq flavor but flavored up & meaty, looked like a regular pork rib cut. Coleslaw wasn't so cold, it was a bit creamy & may need some tang/vinegar. May try dish next time. ▪︎ 8 chicken wings lemon pepper dry rub were tasty, perhaps salty made us thirsty, would like more lemon zest & coarse pepper with perhaps less salt. The celery carrot salad was enjoyable with it. ▪︎ We'll be back for a B St vibe evening. 3rd Thurs nights in summer the city puts on a fest live band and stage right out front of Buffalo, we started at Bills early then pursued the street fest.

Jaymes Peddie

Its a cool place. Tons of free parking. The menu is well put together with pairings to the beer in mind. The only reason I'm taking 1 star off is because 2 of the 4 things we ordered were wrong. The burger was undercooked My Nachos had sour cream when I ordered it with no sour cream and it had a bunch of it, the cheese was not melted and came out luke warm. The fires were pretty good and the wings were on point. Maybe the kitchen just had a rough day or the timing was off.

Da roll West Ton

We enjoyed ourselves thoroughly on a really busy Saturday night. Those waffle sweet potato fries are the business! The stuffed jalapeños were (uge). The fried pickles could be sliced in half if You ask me, but the flavor was great. That barbecue sauce for the perfectly cooked wings was wonderfully seasoned.

Cris Fleming

I've lived in Silicon Valley for 18 years, on weekends we usually go out to spend a night in another city on the bay. We chose Hayward because I wanted to see the Japanese park that I had been told would be full of hummingbirds at that time. It was not the case. Then we went to lunch to B Street in downtown, there are several options. We liked the terrace in the sun, we sat down and ordered a BLT Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted wheat with fries, a Half and Half (half of any sandwich with half of any soup or salad) despite the great variety of beers, we ask for water because we don't drink alcohol. The service was fast and attentive. I highly recommend this place for a bite and drink with friends.

Nick Felker

We came here after dinner. They don't have flights but do have an assorted variety of beers on tap. I got two and neither stood out as unique but we had a decent time here.

Went in a few weeks ago for lunch on a Saturday and it was ok. The staff was good, service was good,and some of the food was good. We ordered the jalapeño poppers and we both enjoyed them, I liked how they were made with phyllo dough vs the normal fried style. The disappointment came with the burger, it was overcooked (more med then med-rare) and the pretzel bun was cold and not toasted. My buddies burger came out to his liking, so maybe it was a fluke as they were busy, but never the less it was my experience.

Brian Holliday

Went in a few weeks ago for lunch on a Saturday and it was ok. The staff was good, service was good,and some of the food was good. We ordered the jalapeño poppers and we both enjoyed them, I liked how they were made with phyllo dough vs the normal fried style. The disappointment came with the burger, it was overcooked (more med then med-rare) and the pretzel bun was cold and not toasted. My buddies burger came out to his liking, so maybe it was a fluke as they were busy, but never the less it was my experience.

CA

We went in for dinner. I ordered a salad that was supposed to have pecans. We received our orders, and I noticed my salad instead had walnuts, which I’m allergic to. Our server offered to remake it w/o nuts. When we received the second salad we again found a walnut fragment in it. I appreciated that both the server and manager were responsive. They were apologetic and comped my salad. They also communicated that they were going to talk to the kitchen and update the menu. I’m docking stars for the lax food safety handling. Thankfully I caught the issue both times.

“Devil mac and cheese” description says creamy and has chili was missing both 2/10 “Taz pizza” was looking forward to the pizza sauce only to find that they only put about 2% sauce waiters didn’t ask if we were happy so we decided to leave and asked for our check and boxes which took 20 minutes. Worsts experience so far not recommended

Fifo_Eats

“Devil mac and cheese” description says creamy and has chili was missing both 2/10 “Taz pizza” was looking forward to the pizza sauce only to find that they only put about 2% sauce waiters didn’t ask if we were happy so we decided to leave and asked for our check and boxes which took 20 minutes. Worsts experience so far not recommended

Very disappointing experience for a group of 12 trying to celebrate our child’s birthday. The server was very un-accommodating for our group, making it complicated to order for the group, inflexible around payment options, and overall making us feel unwelcome. We tried to order a special dessert for the kids, but the server didn’t take the order, didn’t follow up to confirm what we wanted, and then just brought the check… we never got the dessert, and overall it was a super disappointing experience. Don’t recommend for groups.

Great potential, lack of management! This place could be a great opportunity but it’s lacking leadership. I was not greeted, never asked how my food was or how the house beer tasted, in fact I had to get up and walk to the end of the bar to retrieve my own silverware, all while the cook, definitely not a chef, poured a beer and took it to the manager “or owner” so I hope your happy, hope your beer was cold and you got to relax because the paying customers who dine in never once got a thank you, how are you or have a great day. You could have got up and greeted the 5 people keeping your business running but nope, you decided to sit and chill with your buddy. SAD, you can do better!

Disappointing experience overall. For a brewery, the beer was surprisingly underwhelming, slightly warm and noticeably flat, which was a huge letdown and honestly the biggest miss. The jalapeño poppers were decent, but nowhere near worth the price. The food across the board felt more like fast-food or TV-dinner quality while being priced like a top-tier restaurant. $22 for a burger or sandwich and $8 just to add chicken to nachos is pretty outrageous for what you get. I expected much better quality and value, especially given the brewery setting. Unfortunately, it didn’t live up to the hype.

Ty Balaguy

Great potential, lack of management! This place could be a great opportunity but it’s lacking leadership. I was not greeted, never asked how my food was or how the house beer tasted, in fact I had to get up and walk to the end of the bar to retrieve my own silverware, all while the cook, definitely not a chef, poured a beer and took it to the manager “or owner” so I hope your happy, hope your beer was cold and you got to relax because the paying customers who dine in never once got a thank you, how are you or have a great day. You could have got up and greeted the 5 people keeping your business running but nope, you decided to sit and chill with your buddy. SAD, you can do better!

I M

Disappointing experience overall. For a brewery, the beer was surprisingly underwhelming, slightly warm and noticeably flat, which was a huge letdown and honestly the biggest miss. The jalapeño poppers were decent, but nowhere near worth the price. The food across the board felt more like fast-food or TV-dinner quality while being priced like a top-tier restaurant. $22 for a burger or sandwich and $8 just to add chicken to nachos is pretty outrageous for what you get. I expected much better quality and value, especially given the brewery setting. Unfortunately, it didn’t live up to the hype.