Caddy's Madeira Beach

I thought it was a fantastic authentic Italian restaurant. The antipasto salad was amazing, with roasted peppers, roasted garlic, meats, cheeses, olives, roasted eggplant, etc. It was beautiful. The pizza was very good and there was happy hour as well. This has to be the best pizza place in Clearwater area.

Great Italian made food! We were looking a different menu more in the real italian side and have been tired of the pizza and so and so italian food in Texas. This is it. Great stromboli, loved the canoli, great hawaiian pizza and margherita pizza. The waitresses are awesome and Miguel is a great cook! We went there twice and once We travel again to St Petersburg will be coming back. Thank you for the great food and great service.

Best pizza I ever had...I highly recommended... definitely will be there again..

Stayed at Sunset Beach for a staycation and found this gem on UberEats. We ordered pizza twice in as many days and it was soooo good. I’ll be driving here just for the pizza now. So nice to have someone in the area that KNOWS how to make a great pie! Outstanding!

First time I came here I was blown away. Came back almost a year later to double check. Sure enough this place is still great. Order a gourmet pizza I truly believe its the best pizza in Florida!! Brushetta and Tiramisu are always excellent. Service is a little lacking but not bad enough to dock a star. A must try if you are in the area!!

This experience was delightful. The food was flavorful and just really good. Our server was also very friendly and helpful. Definitely a 10/10 experience.

Best Northern Italian restaurant in St.Pete beach area. The owner is very personable and attentive. The food is outstanding we came back 3 times in the week that we were there.

We picked up a few pizzas for carryout. We weren't disappointed, they were great. We'll definitely visit again to dine in. The staff was very nice and accommodating and a nice atmosphere to dine.

Some of the best Italian food on the planet. The owners are both in the kitchen! Amazing flavor and great service!

Ate here because of the need for gf food and found on find me gluten free app. The gf pizza was not cross contaminated and my meat pie was on point. Sorry I can’t remember our servers name but she served my wife so hopefully she can remember this picture as her patrons that night. She even got hot butter for my pizza and paper plates for our hotel leftovers. Thanks a bunch.

If you're looking for a delicious meal I will suggest the rost pork. I don't know what's the name for the plate but I have to tell you it was delicious we try a little bit of everything lasagna was good the pizza was excellent and the spaghetti 🍝 😋 where really good. Looking forward to come back. Thanks.

Tuttorosso is a great neighborhood spot for delicious Italian food. The pizzas are flavorful, the pasta tastes homemade, and the service is always friendly. They offer both indoor and outdoor seating, giving you a nice, relaxed beach-town vibe.

Authentic Italian Pizza Perfection This Italian pizza spot is an absolute gem! The pizzas are bursting with flavor—crispy, thin crusts with perfectly balanced toppings and rich, tangy tomato sauce. You can taste the quality in every bite. The pizza is next-level delicious. The cozy, rustic atmosphere and friendly staff make it feel like a slice of Italy right in town. A must-visit for any pizza lover!

Loved it Excellent Pizza incredible spaghetti Bologneses ( meat ragou sauce) cooked at perfection 👌 👍 one of the best Tiramissu I have ever had . Excellent service 👏 👍 👌

Best lasagna I’ve ever had in my life. Friendly waiter. I’ll be back. Can’t wait to try the pizza.

Great place. The food was very good. Except for the pasta fagioli, it was underwhelming. No flavor. All of the other food was great. Good pizza and good appetizers. The dessert was awesome:pistachio cake, chocolate cake, and canolli were all a must-have. Stopped back to get dessert. Should have come here for dinner also. Thank you, Philip, for your great service.

This place is amazing.. as soon as you walk in, it smells so good... the eggplant parm and lasagna were delicious... the staff were very accommodating and friendly

This place is awesome! Delicious, authentic Italian food in a quaint atmosphere. The hostess was so nice, she made us feel like she invited us into her home for dinner. Wish we could take this dining experience back home to New York with us! Not to worry, we will be back. Thank you for your hospitality and delicious food!

This place was excellent 👌 the pizza was phenomenal and for 22 dollars you can feed a whole family. The waitresses were attentive and you could tell everyone took pride in their work and restaurant. Wish we would have found this place sooner in our vaca !

Amazing food and amazing service. Called ahead time to make a reservation for 11. Great restaurant. 10/10 will come back next time Im down here! Julio was our server. Amazing guy and made it a great services!

Honestly don’t review on Google too much but I love this place. I’ve lived on the beach my whole life and just now found out about it and I can’t believe how amazing it is. I’ve gotten pizza from take out section every time and it’s always a 10/10. Good service, good food, no complaints!!

We were having a family gathering that included a boat outing and wanted to come back and have dinner without the fuss of cooking. We have several people with dietary restrictions so I went in the day before to place the order which included regular and gluten-free pasta dishes as well as regular and gluten-free pizzas. From that moment on, Deborah was on it! The customer service was excellent and it was such a treat to come back from being on the water, pick up the food and enjoy a delicious dinner. All the food was hot and packaged perfectly for takeout and serving at home. We have also previously dined in with both small and large groups, with similar great experiences! Highly recommend!!

Wonderful casual setting, quaint outdoor patio The pizza was authentic and delicious!! Quality ingredients for dough to topping! Great value for what you spend. Love the casual setting, where you can sit and chill....

Arranged a catering menu over the phone from Canada for a office group in St Pete Beach and it was so easy and seamless , staff so helpful with the menu, made sure I ordered enough (without overdoing it) which I truly appreciated. Everything was ready on time as promised , food was hot and amazing! They even offered to supply the cutlery plates and napkins! Highly recommend them! And I will certainly order from then again and again.

We had 14 of us 6 adults and 8 kids! The waitress was great! The food was delish! The food came out quick! The whole staff was amazing! Would definitely go back!!

One of the best spots on St Pete Beach! Super friendly service and the food is amazing. Probably the best buffalo chicken pizza on the beach and all the Italian food is good, traditional comfort food. Had the Ossobuco tonight and it was exceptionally tender. Highly recommend dinner here while you're in St Pete Beach.

Excellent Italian food. Warm welcome, funny attentive server. Osso Buco was outstanding. Meat fell off the bone- tender and flavorful. Eggplant Rollatini was a nice size portion with plenty left for the next day, good robust flavor. Penne with clams was delicious also, nice tiny clams and not chewy. We will go again.

We had lunch here this afternoon and the food was outstanding! Everything we ordered was fresh and delicious! We had cheese pizza, the white pizza, the Sicilian pizza, garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, and eggplant appetizer. Everything was absolutely amazing, hot and made to order! There was only one waiter working the entire restaurant and he seemed stretched quite thin. He was trying to take our order, bus tables, bring out food, take other peoples orders. He did a great job, but definitely could’ve used a hand. We will definitely come back here again when visiting the area!

Food was great. Only reason why it’s not a five star experience is because the wines served are different from what you order from the menu. Happens every time. Should consider updating their options on the menu. Would come back for the food without a doubt though.

The portion is big and that's including the pizza. The pizza dough is a bit too salty for me, but to some, maybe just right. Overall, good service and food is good. They even have their own wine!!!

Great local Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Best pizza in St. Pete! Made to order and fresh ingredients. Nice menu selections and daily specials too. Wine, beer & liqour to complement your meal. Italian deserts and other Italian/Sicilian specialties too! Classic Italian trattoria atmosphere!

Cute atmosphere — definitely gives cozy Italian vibes. The waitress was a little… hard to read? Not rude, just had kind of an indifferent energy. But the food made up for it! I had the cannelloni with pasta and marinara, and it was delicious — cheesy, rich, and full of flavor. Portions were generous too. Great spot if you’re craving hearty Italian comfort food.

Very good food. Eggplant Parmesan is good. VERY noisy! Kids were screaming, but even without the kids, it would have been noisy. Caution: the other salad dressings are good, but the blue cheese is just a single serving packet.

Veal was spoiled, very sour. Eggplant Parmesan only had 3 small slices. Salad had absolutely no flavor with the creamy house Italian dressing. I didn't enjoy. I did like the baby octopus and garlic bread. Would not return.

First time here and we came in around 6:30 on a Friday night with no reservation and the lady was able to seat us. It was very busy and very noisy hard to talk with my table. We ended up getting two different kinds of pizzas and the sauce was delicious and I found the crust on certain slices to be quite soggy on the rustica with sausage. The margarita pizza crust was too overcooked for me and a little burnt in areas. The pasta that people were getting next to me looked very delicious I'll have to try it.,

This place used to be so good 5 years ago. It has gone downhill a little bit. The food was a little bit bland. No fresh mozzarella for my pasta. The owner used to be the chef. Not sure if he is anymore. It's not terrible, it's just not the beautiful secret it used to be.

Ordered lasagna and a sausage sandwich with peppers and onions. The lasagna was made with good quality ingredients and it just didn't taste that good. Tasted like it was made with liver. The flavor was off. The cheeses and sauce was top notch. The beef ...... I don't know what to say about that. It was edible. Tasty ingredients wrapped around, not sure what happened. A bit disappointed in the lasagna. The sausage sandwich needs to be revamped or taken off the menu. Pathetic tasting sausage. Frozen sausage. Johnsonville flavor. Not a good sausage and theY sliced it up instead of leaving whole. TOTALLY DISAPPOINTED WITH THE SAUSAGE SANDWICH. DISGUSTING! Salad was good. Decent greens.

If you’re from New England area and want pizza I do not recommend, then again it’s hard to find good pizza down south. Very thin and sloppy messy slices. Kids pasta was awful “red sauce” 👎 greeted very well at the front door and very nice but can’t say my family of 4 enjoyed.

Absolutely do not waste your time ordering any side dishes such as “garlic” bread or “garlic” knots. Took one look at the “garlic” bread that I ordered and it was the most disgusting thing I have ever seen in my life. Immediately had to tell them to just throw it away.. Could tell it would have been inedible. Ordered garlic knots as a substitution which I did pay for because they looked good in the display case. When I received the “garlic” knots, I ate one, they are dry and unseasoned. No butter, garlic or flavor whatsoever. The only thing that looks decent is the pizza which I am hesitant to try now.

I waited 30minutes just to be served a display pizza on there window, that they stuck in to there over for 1 minute. Not fresh & cold 100% terrible service. Sorry but I’m just explaining my experience for a first time & last time customer.