Fannie Lux

I Love this spot for tacos, close to home great food and service, second time coming to this place would definitely recommend for family & friends! ♥️

+1

Gabby Nyirjesy

Really great food and staff is so friendly. The nachos and Al pastor tacos were amazing. Best Al pastor tacos I have found on the UWS. The corn tortillas were the perfect consistency and flavor. My husband got the carnitas enchiladas with morita sauce and also loved his meal. They also have a great happy hour deal with $9 margs on Saturday 8pm-close

Diana “D”

The restaurant was open and clean. The waitress was super friendly. The food was delicious. My mom had the grilled salmon, which can with plenty of vegetables, and I had the shrimp quesadillas. The presentation of both dishes was pretty. Not to me tion the Red Sangria, YUMMY!!!! I will definitely return and recommend my friends.

+3

G Frye

Pico De Gallo is one of the best Mexican restaurants I’ve been to in the Upper West Side! The chicken fajita and beef enchilada were amazing! The service was very friendly! We had a wonderful experience there and will bring our families and friends back to try some more dishes! I highly recommend Pico De Gallo to my friends who crave for Mexican food.

+7

Beom Lee

Such a lovely patio on the back of restaurant. Did you know when you order guac, they make it fresh infront of you on a guac cart? I would definitely recommend it. ceviche was quite tasteful with a hint of spice and I really enjoyed birria tacos and squid(or octopus) taco. It was such a good experience and I look forward to visit here again near future.

+4

Eileen

Best Mexican my family and I have ever had! This restaurant is amazing, the service was top-notch, the guacamole is made at your table and the food is downright delicious. The chicken mole tacos were the best I ever had. The restaurant and bathrooms are very clean

Flourish & Enjoy Life

My first time coming here. Was accommodated while entering. Ordered a quesadilla and margarita. It was delicious and the drink was good. There is even a bar section in the restaurant. Good place to eat with friends and family. The happy hours are Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday from 4Pm to 7pm. Thursday all night from 4Pm to close. The service and waiter was excellent. Will definitely return. Happy Eating!

+7

We chose this restaurant to have dinner because the reviews were good. We are glad we went because the food was good. The atmosphere wasn’t too busy, which was nice and low music was playing. We had a steak burrito, loaded nachos and steak fajitas. The dishes were flavorful and a generous amount for me to even take some home. We would recommend this restaurant to others.

Guacamole NYC As a native upper West sider, I was surprised I’ve never stumbled inside this place. I don’t know, for some weird reason the outside never attracted me. Perhaps that’s why I never ventured inside. Boy, was I ever wrong to doubt. First off the vibe is inside is awesome. There is plenty of space to eat, staff was friendly, music is relaxing but not too loud, and they have a backyard!!! I have to admit, the three enchiladas were decent enough. I’ve never been a fan of the tortillas being dipped in salsa for too long as they can become soggy. The melted cheese or the mole sauce shouldn’t soak the enchiladas. While the tortilla seemed to be too wet, the flavor won on this one. The meal was balanced with well with rice and beans. To top it off I had a tamarind margarita. Yum yum! Definitely recommend this place. I hear from colleagues that the drinks are something special. From experience my drink had a good kick to it. Go try them out.

Jay Mandel

We recently visited Pico de Gallo and had an overall enjoyable experience. The nachos were fantastic—crispy, fresh chips loaded with flavorful salsa, guacamole, and just the right amount of spice. The portion was generous and perfect for sharing. I also loved the tacos, and the rice was a standout side dish—perfectly cooked and seasoned. Plus, the $5 happy hour beer special was a great deal, especially on a Friday evening at 7 PM. However, one issue left a sour taste in my mouth. My son asked for a small amount of lettuce and tomato on his taco—a topping that’s typically included on most tacos. To my surprise, when I got the bill, I noticed an upcharge for this addition. I’ve attached a picture to this review to show just how minimal the portion of lettuce and tomato actually was. Even if they charged $1, it’s hard to justify the cost for such a tiny amount. This small but petty move overshadowed what would have been an otherwise 100% positive review. Business is about being transparent and honest with your customers, and this felt unnecessarily nickel-and-dime. Such practices can leave a lasting impression—and not the good kind. A little generosity and goodwill go a long way in ensuring customers leave feeling valued, not frustrated. If Pico de Gallo addresses this, it would easily become one of my go-to spots. Until then, I hope management takes this feedback as an opportunity to focus on customer experience over minor upcharges.

+2

Sebastian Morris

We stopped in here on Easter Sunday for a casual brunch. Everything tasted great ESPECIALLY the guacamole - so well seasoned. I had a breakfast burrito with chorizo which had a great salsa verde with it served on top. The frozen margaritas were also great - not too sweet like most other places. Best of all was our server. I wish I remembered her name to give her a shout out. She was really sweet. I would definitely come back here!

+2

Bridget Coolick

The food here was very fresh and really tasty. I recommend the homemade corn tortillas - they were fantastic! I had the vegetable quesadilla and it was packed with fresh veggies and seasoned well. Margaritas were refreshing and perfectly balanced, not too sweet. The only reason I'm not giving five stars is because our table was seated and we waited 20-25 minutes with no one coming over to ask if we wanted anything. My friend had to get up and get someone's attention, and even then it took a few more minutes for someone to take our drink and appetizer orders.

+2

Zakeenah Smith

The guacamole was fresh they make it in front of you and ask you how you want it so it was very good. We ordered salsa but of the 3 they brought out they all tasted terrible. Our server was very nice and accommodating. I had the skirt steak and tostones, the steak was good and the tostones were fried well but they were a little sweet and I didn't like that. The star of this restaurant is the passion fruit margaria I got it frozen and liked it a lot.

+20