Went for a couple slices for lunch. Definitely not the worst pizza I’ve ever had but far from the best. Especially considering the $5 tag per cheese slice and how many other good pizza places there are in NYC, definitely wouldn’t rush to go here again. Even if waiting for a train in Moynihan Hall, would recommend walking 5 minutes to one of the many other pizza places in the area where, at the very least, you will get the same quality for a better price. More about the price being high than the food itself.

This pizza was quite a bit better than I expected it to be, given its location in the Moynihan Hall. I had a pesto artichoke slice specifically, but they had a decent selection of other pies too. It’s a nice thin crust with a very good flavor; perfect for a quick snack. Will definitely return.

Joey LoFaro

In town from DC for work, for train station pie it's great. Usually you get over commercialized crap in a station, this was not that got a slice of Pepperoni and the pesto as recommended as the "best slice" by the staff. Only complaint was it might have been sitting a bit cause the crust was semi stale but overall flavorful, crispy and tender. Maybe Im starved for these crust basics coming from DC but I was satisfied not the best NY slice I have had but one of the best station/airport meals for the price I have had.

Ellen

Crispy, hot cheese slice for $5.

+3

Sahana Dinesh

Honestly it was super tasty for a train hall. It’s around 5$ for a slice, which is a little steep but I really liked the slice I got! I got the pesto artichoke and the mushroom ricotta and both of those were so good! Vodka pizza was kinda mid. Def recommend if you have a long wait in penn and want a quick bite. They also have lots of vegetarian options. Overall: 4/5 stars from me!!

Brad Loncar

Got to be the cheapest value bite in the train station. My square slice was a little lighter than I like, but it was still pretty good.

Kishi Malhotra

If You’re looking to grab a GOOD hot slice just before board, this place is it…. Surprised at the reviews because the Pizza is served Hot (temperature) and is absolutely delicious. Had a slice of Cheese Pizza and another one with Vodka Sauce. Thin crust and DELISH !!! Plenty of place to sit as this is the Food Hall and so many other choices to eat at.. Service was quick and fast. They DO NOT carry mainstream sodas and the price was a ‘Can’ of ‘artisinal’ water is rather high.. The ambience is absolutely terrific. It was a Thursday night and the bar nearby had a DJ playing nice music… Most definitely coming back here again if passing thru…

Eric San José

Nice friendly staff. Pizza is always good. More expensive than at their other locations due to it being in Penn Station. Credit cards are accepted. Clean facilities. Close to the restrooms and to all trains. We will definitely be going back.

Sagar Solanki

Ngl, I was a bit disappointed at how thin the pizza slices were but the taste was real nice. Crust is a gamble as it can be either undercooked or crisper than a cracker. Still not bad if you're interested in a quick slice.

Leslie Kossar

I have been eating NY pizza my whole life- I work across the street from Moynihan and went in to grab a quick lunch. Saw Sauce pizza and thought I would try it. Wow- their “square slice” is a poofy bread with a layer of melted cheese over the top. No crunch to the bread, no real taste and the cheese just peels off the top. Despite being disappointed that I had spent $7 on this slice- I am horrified that visitors to NY via Moynahan Train station will think this is representative of nyc.

Mike Muscatello

Ordered a calzone. Came without sauce. Ok. Went and asked for sauce got a small container (about a third of normal) of cold sauce. Guess I am not used to NY calzone? Dry and awful.

Haris Rehman

READ THIS BEFORE YOU GO!!!! So if you’re reading this review you are A either about to get pizza here or B disappointed in how bad it is. I’ve had a long day exciting and I wanted some pizza (this is my first time in NYC) and I saw this pizza place and said “hey let’s try New York pizza” I stumbled upon this area and bought 2 slices of pizza which were both overcooked and terrible then I got a soda to wash out the taste and it tasted horrible so I got another flavor and it was……horrible If I were you I would just go to the Mexican place next to it.