So today I tried and for the first time; Pelham Pizzas well known Lentil Soup. This Italian will tell you that it is likely the best lentil soup to be found anywhere. Truly home made. You can tell by the seasoning and the cuts of the ingredients. Time went into making this soup that’s for sure. Well like everything else they prepare and cook this soup is fabulous. When you see 8-10 people busy working in a place like this you rest assured you will have a terrific dining experience. Quick slice or sit down meal. You’re getting the good stuff!

Most times I take out the Dev in several occasions where I have eaten in and tried some of there dinner plates.I particularly love this spaghetti and meatballs.And I like their chicken pot also like some of their soup. Staff is always friendly and the atmosphere is farea.Residents priearly is the heck of word neighborhood.Store something overhang out with some.It's a good place to go spend your time when you're money and get good food. Oh by the way they have a wide variety of pizza's. Nice menu while tasting pizzas.Time to go there and see for yourself.You will be a return Customer.., Enjoy!

I stopped in for Dinner and although the counter had a line of customers, I was Greeted and seated. The server was friendly and the food and drink came out promptly after I ordered. Penne & Broccoli with white Wine. It was just right. I would highly recommend this place.

First, pizza is normally not my thing. But, I could eat their garlic white pizza every day if possible. I also tried the Shrimp Scampi. That was also delicious.. Plus the secret spicy pizza was amazing.. The guys there are super cool. Highly recommend

Great pizzas and a very nice and Italian atmosphere

I've been coming here to Pelham Pizza for over 20yrs. and without a doubt the best Pizza in the area. The staff are amazing very neighborly and the food is awesome. Family friendly and always consistent with their quality of food and service. All my kids know they can't miss their take out night with Pelham Pizza.

Great pizza, just how I remembered prior to covid. Plenty of staff to keep food flowing out the door. My family enjoyed the pie I brought home...I enjoyed the price I paid😉. It was a little less than what I would've paid somewhere closer to home. Pro tip, bring someone with you... unfortunately they are limited to street parking. At night it can be a little difficult to get a convenient spot and the police presence (on the weekend nights) can be felt. You don't want to double park. I'm dying to go back to try the pasta.

I have been going there for years, it was my Daughters favorite too!...truly the... "Best Pizza in Westchester!" Old fashioned Pizza, with substance, generous toppings, all fresh and so delicious! White Cheese Garlic five star***** Spinach and Garlic five star***** Regular saucy and cheesy five star***** All pizzas are served extra hot, and full of flavor! Service is Great!

I love this place it is so good and the food is great the wedges are super good

I've been coming here for the last 20 years. Even when i moved out of state, id come here to eat before id get to my house when visiting. Hands down, the best pizza I've ever had. But not just great pizza, everything in their menu is always on point

Pelham Pizza has been one of my favorite pizzerias for many many years now. Although I haven't been there in a while I stopped by this past week and nothing has changed. Still great pizza great food. Highly recommend

I’ve enjoyed great pizza throughout Connecticut and NYC and the pie’s from Pelham Pizza are top notch. I don’t think it’s possible to get pizza any better than what they serve! Thank you to the owner and chefs for providing everyone with quality pizza.

Great pizza. Easy menu. Some staple options with easy to build pies by topping. The white pizza is no joke. Comes out looking oily and heavy. But after letting it sit for a little bit until it was just warm, delicious cheese taste and didn't feel greasy at all.

Food quality more like an upscale restaurant rather than a pizza place. A little busy and noisy but worth the trip. Great Sicilian slices and great dinner choices. Prices went up recently like every other place but not outrageous

OMG we love this place. The Pizza is SO GOOD!

Possibly one of the best pizzeria I've been to, definitely the best one I've been to in Westchester. I go at least once or twice a week. Friendly staff and quick service. The spinach slice is absolutely delicious and has become my regular order. The slice is fully loaded with spinach- a soft buttery flavor with a crispy crust just underneath. This gives it a good crunch and a bit of a char flavor as well. It's a big slice, but loaded with vegetables so you get all the flavor without the guilt. 10/10 would dine there again.

Fantastic neighborhood pizza joint, definitely authentic. The founder of this place cared deeply about the community but passed away a few years ago. The people that still work there continue to make this a great place for locals to dine. Cash only, but worth the hassle. It can get crowded in the evenings, so we often call to place an order ahead of picking it up.

love there pizza. they have fresh pizza in making all the time. we tried plain cheese pizza, spinach pizza (i ask them to put serano chilli on it to spice it up), and white pizza. these were delicious.

This is our favorite pizza place. It is a tiny, family run operation with the most delicious 'chicken slices' - a wedge of chicken pizza - we have ever had anywhere. Customers are welcomed as if they are part of the family. Smiles all around and special greetings for regulars. There are a number of other delicious dishes on the menu - pastas, calamari, a wide-selection of pizzas, and so on - and one of our favorites is their escarole and beans.

Bustling pizza place with great pizza and other Italian specialities. Good slice selection as well as a large selection of soups. You can get waiter service or just order at the counter. My family loves the Sicilian, eggplant slices and Diablo slices. They serve beer and wine as well. Super friendly service too.

A cozy, hometown feel pizzeria with fantastic food and service. Atmosphere is what you'd expect from a pizzeria, but with table service if needed/requested and a staff that always have a smile. Great slices and meals alike. Give it a try!

Sal your Pizza was excellent and really to die for. 1 large w/1/2 pepperoni & other 1/2 sausage & onions. 1 med extra cheese & sausage. Price was great. The staff knew almost everyone that walked through the door. They have sit down and take out. Alot of walkin and calling. Very professional. Loved it.

Wow the food was great! Many great places in the area but this place pushes up towards the top.

I come here often ,usually order different slices or soup ,I wanted to try a sausage and pepper roll for a change ,it was amazing ,fresh , delicious,can’t wait to come back and order this again .Staff is so friendly,nice casual atmosphere.

I can’t wait to go back… I ordered the sausage slice… ate it in the car… walked back in just to order 3 more slices!!!!

Been a customer for 10+ years. This place never lets me down. Always treated like family when i dine in. These new pepperoni/ jalapeño slices are insane.

We love Pelham Pizza! Their pizza and food is always so fresh and they have so many options to chose from. Awesome customer service - always so friendly and accommodating. Highly recommend

Got a regular cheese slice and it was delicious. Crust was nice flaky and thin. Wasn't too expensive 4 the slice either like most pizza shops now. Service and atmosphere was great. Seems like an old mom n pop shop. All the locals come in and are greeted like friends. Love it!

I love the slices at Pelham Pizza. It's always a pleasure to support local businesses and eat great food!

Good customer service! Great Pizza!

+2

Amazing pizza, classic old-school joint, and a regular visit anytime I’m heading back from the Bronx. The pasta fagioli was excellent. Highly recommended and will come back again for sure.

Great place for amazing pizza, pasta and salad... This is the perfect all in one pizza shop! And I can honestly say that this is the BEST Pizza within a 15 mile radius. They care for the ingredients , they take pride in the presentation of their food, their service is great as after you order and sit, they bring the food to you. Outstanding service, I am a fanatic of pizza, as a Chef I have made it my mission to find the best pizza and this truly is one of the top ten within NY and CT.... A Must Try!

Very nice pizzeria restaurant the food there is great I recommend it to anybody

Family owned pizza place. Always packed with people and so delicious. Service is very fast and they've never disappointed.

One of the best Pizza I have tasted and let’s not talk about the customer service. One word: PHENOMENAL . They don’t even know the day That I went , My day was not going so good and they made my day by giving my 2 year old a lollipop during her meltdown . I have visited a few times after and have made this my primary pizza spot. Get over and get you a slice .

Warman welcoming place. Usually busy, with a great regular chicken slice

food was great, the server nicolette (sorry if i spelled it wrong) was really nice, i recommend the spaghetti and meatballs and the cheese pizza (or any they are all good) i would for sure come back !

As a Bronx native, pizza has always been a family go to for a quick dinner on a busy weeknight. Stumbled across this gem and was not disappointed. We opted to get assorted slices and sample a few- we were hungry! The buffalo chicken slice was delicious, perfectly spiced and fresh. The plain slice was amazing, you could really appreciate the sauce which was flavored nicely. The spinach slice was great, sautéed to perfection. Lastly, the grandma Sicilian slice was scrumptious. The crust was perfectly crispy but not too hard that you would worry about chipping a tooth. Definitely a family favorite! Plus- the serve wine and beer!! Enjoy!

I don’t know what’s better here the food or the staff. Both are top notch. That was hands down the best Buffalo chicken slice I’ve ever had and the crust was perfect for it. Sturdy enough to support all that chicken but not too thick. I also got a chicken roll that I couldn’t eat because the slice was so filling. I did have 2 bites of it before I wrapped it up to go and it was sooooooo good. I’m glad I had to catch a train otherwise I probably would have stuffed myself with it. The prices were great, too. Perfect old school pizzeria. I’m now motivated to leave for work a little bit earlier so I can come here.

It’s a pleasant surprise when you accidentally find a great restaurant. Born and raised in Chicago, I have been in New York for about 8 months and have been less than impressed with most pizza here. Then today I wandered into Pelham Pizza and am glad I did. Crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings were all ‘spot on’. I’ll definitely be coming back.

maybe the best slice in Westchester, this is a regular slice with mushrooms & peppers,, my favorite !!!

I’m Great pizza! Great service!! The staff makes you feel like family when you step in.

Real family atmosphere. Waitress is cute young lady who is friendly and courteous. The fellas behind the counter are also very nice. I like going there. Wish they could expand the store but it doesn't look like that's gonna happen. Really nice place to eat and take out. 5 🌟.

growing up in CT had pepes pizza all the time and sallys. this is the best pizza i have ever had in my entire life.......

We stopped here on the last leg of a lengthy road trip. The pizza was incredible, the restaurant was charming, full of locals and small town charm. The staff got our pizza going, then boxed and taped the rest and threw in extra paper plates for the car. Even offered to refill my son’s water flask. Can’t wait for our next trip up again.

Work across the street on Mondays , in my cardiology clinic , which is now officially Pizza Day for me. Great stuff with my favorites being the reverse and the grandma but also love the white and the soups. Another big plus are the people that work there. They are always happy and attentive, unlike some of the other places we’ve all been to.

This is our favorite local pizzeria. The atmosphere is basic storefront pizzeria, but the food is excellent. The folks behind the counter have been there for years and welcome everyone like family. You can’t go wrong with any slice or meal you choose.

Just came here from Queens. This is the best pizza I’ve ever tasted in this area. Their pepperoni slices were very good! Keep up the amazing work!

Pelham Pizza is an institution in Pelham and for a good reason. It's got the best kind of small-town feel where you're inevitably going to run into someone you know and the service is fantastic whether dining in or taking out. And while the pizza is great, they also serve a number of other delicious dishes for very reasonable prices. Our family has made regular visits part of our regular routine.

Wow the pizza is amazing and I went with a group of people and all the Italian dishes were superb. I had gnocchi with chicken and escarole and it was delicious. I have enough for at least two meals and maybe three lol. I also had a homemade lentil soup which was great. The people they were super friendly and the prices are reasonable for the amount of food you get and the quality. I can't wait to go back!

Very fluffy and delicious, very large for a large pizza - barely fit in the box (not complaining)

One of the best slices I have ever had. Worth a visit if you are in the area. They seem to have many loyal local customers. Lots of people were ordering the soup. I had a margarita slice and a Sicilian with Pepperoni. The Sicilian had bits of gorgonzola inside the Pepperoni which was a nice touch and added a distinct flavor. The Margerita pizza was better, but not by much. Both were excellent slices! Highly recommend!

man, been coming here for years thanks to my buddy Nick. Hands down the best pizza shop in westchester county. The jalapeño pepperoni pizza is perfection. EVERYTHING on the menu is perfection. The Staff will treat you like family; come through show these guys some love 💯

Jessica Rivera

Intown for work, didn’t really think I would get this pizza, but I was getting some for my friend. A bit on the cost of your side since it was eight dollars for two plain sizes that I used to pay a dollar for down in the city, but we’re not in the cities so I’ll be fair. It was quick service. It seems like the shop had its regulars and I got out within five minutes and it was a safe meal so a win.

Eddie Cheaz

Am amazing local pizzeria and restaurant that's family oriented and a great low-key place to hang out with friends and family. Pizza is amazing, their food is 5 star with nonna sized portions, and carry excellent Italian beer from Biella, Italy!! My only wish is that they carried Italian desserts like home-made cannoli, even if on a small scale, first come, first serve basis.

Devan Taylor

Awesome place! In town for the Ryder Cup, walked in and everyone was great and welcoming. Would definitely recommend. The guys working there were a blast to hang out with while waiting on pizza

Dalma García

The pizza was really good and the portions are huge—one pizza is extremely large, definitely more than enough for two people. The place was very busy, which probably explains why the service was so slow. It took a while to get our order, but overall the food made it worth the wait.

Johnny Garcia

The food here is amazing. From the soups to the main dishes nothing less than outstanding. Pelham Pizza gives one that family vibe with how friendly and interactive the staff is. After a long day to sit and enjoy good food with great people is the best. Shoutout to Pelham pizza and the best PINO :)

Scott Patchin

We were looking for great pizza and Pelhams did not disappoint. Great crust and sauce, which we always look for. We did takeout and they were right on time with our order. It is clear from pictures on their wall of the founding owners that they are an institution for the town. I like to support locally owned businesses, so I look forward to returning. I would highly recommend you Pelham Pizza.

The Sophisticated Shopper LLC

I first came to Pelham Pizzaria as a teenager in 1978, and this July 2025, I returned with my wife and daughter—what a full-circle moment. Now run by the original owner’s son, Pino, the pizza is exactly as I remembered: hot, delicious, and full of flavor. One bite and I felt 17 again. Thank you, Pino, and the whole team, for making me, Sandy, and our daughter Victoria feel like we have two homes—Pelham and Chicago. The food, the service, the memories—it’s all five stars. We’ll be back. —Robert Zaffino

David Hale Smith

The owners of Wise Hardware recommended this spot while we were getting supplies in their store. What a killer spot! The guys making the pizzas were very helpful to a couple of strangers while serving up dozens of happy regulars. Incredible flavor perfect crust undercarriage on these traditional pies. And absolutely the best grandma slice I’ve ever had in my life! Hot honey and Gorgonzola finale! Oh my. Reasonable prices. Cold beer, too. Highly recommend!

Giselle Roberts

So I was hormonal and had a craving- a "need for cheese" if you will. I ordered an extra cheese pizza with my toppings via GrubHub and put in the order details that I needed them to be generous with the cheese. They understood. They took care of me. They always do. Love these guys.

Phil Geoffrey

Ordered the eggplant parmigiana hero. Perfect. Just the right amount of cheese, bread and eggplant. You will have to drive pretty far to beat this place. Prices are very reasonable. Will definitely come back.

Mike

Classic old-school pizza joint - as good as it gets. Best sausage slice I have ever had. Best lasagna slice I have ever had. The crust is always crispy and they are substantial slices.

Harry Otto

Eggplant pizza with entire sliced eggplant? Who does that LOL… this place is worth the “absolute mess” in trying to find parking. Take my advice and just hit the free parking on 4th Ave & 3rd Street👍

Nicole Tarsan

Family favorite spot from back in the day! Glad we finally got to experience. Sausage, pepperoni, plain = all fantastic. Love a good NY pie!

Ronnie Crawford

I stopped in for dinner, and although the counter had a line of customers, I was greeted and seated. The server was friendly, and the food and drink came out promptly after I ordered. Penne with Chicken and Broccoli in Garlic & oil with White Wine. It was just right. I would highly recommend this place.

Brigitta Danyi

For the serious pizza lovers! They have pizza like everywhere else as cheese, buffalo,margarita etc but you should try the rest…they have amazing flavors I never seen before . The crust so yummy! The ricotta what they use, it drives me crazy! Daily soups ,least 5 -6 you can choose from! Pizza place very busy hard to find a table just be patient, you will see worth for the wait! Very friendly people who works so hard the front and back in the kitchen, to serves the best quality pizza on your and mine table! Sorry I couldn’t wait first we took the bites after I did the pictures..

S.C. Tomlinson

One word, DELICIOUS!!! This place is a gem! The environment is friendly and family orientated. At first walking in, I thought it was just all pizzas. Don't get me wrong, the variety of pizzas offered is great but when I looked to the left and saw wine, fried calamari, soups being served at the table, I quickly realized that this isn't just some regular pizza spot. Stop in, have a sit, and grab something good from the menu. Great for family night out where parents can have a grown up meal and the kids can enjoy a slice!

+1

Our family's go to pizza joint. Great friendly staff. Great selection of pizza, even better selection of wedges (they call it this instead of heroes), soups, pastas and entrees. Our favorites? The grandma pie, the reverse pie, the white pie, the tomato pie, escarole and beans soup, broccoli rabe wedge, eggplant parm wedge, and spaghetti with clam sauce (red and/or white). What else you need to know?

Great pizza. We are visiting friends and got the arugula pizza and pepperoni, onions, and peppers pizza. Delicious New York pizza.

I travel all over nyc and NJ for work I like pizza. This pizza was very good. I really liked the crust. I tried plain and also there eggplant slice. Service was good to. Definitely a place to try if you are in the area.

I've been coming here for years. Lately they have been skimpy on the cheese distributed on the Pizza. Every now and then I will get a good slice but again, skimpy on the cheese.

This place is always busy, and for good reason. Pizza was great, and the like all good Italian food, it's all about the sauce. My anchovie slice was on-point, although the crust was a little bit burnt. Despite constantly being busy, (and I mean with a line nearing the door) service is excellent and all staff passing our table made sure we were good to go. Definitely the best Pizza in Pelham.

With so many pizza places to choose from, I had a hard time giving this place a chance. I was told by one of the staff members to come give it a shot. Finally, I did and boy oh boy. It is my new place to come and have a slice. There are many types of pizzas and dishes to choose from. It can be a bit crowded at times but, hey... good pizza brings in lot's of people. Give it a shot. Definitely worth it.

I haven't been here on 20 years. Pretty good slices, much tastier if you buy a whole pie.

+6

I've only been here a couple of times, so I can't really give it 5 stars until I try more of their food. However they have decent seating for a pizzeria, (pretty typical), and they have table service as well from others i have seen dining there. I enjoy their pizza. They have a clean, well stocked bathroom which is always good. I would say this is definitely more of a pizzeria environment, rather than a restaurant. If you're looking for a place to go on a date, I wouldn't recommend it. But for slices and stuff, it's tasty.

I ordered from Grubhub. It’s had to find a good pizza shop after several attempts to order from a good one, I think I found a go-to pizza shop on Grubhub. My kids loved the cheese pizza and garlic knots!! The pizza was delicious and the knots!!! I highly recommend and I will definitely order again!!

I discovered this place through my family members. I only hear great reviews about them. After trying myself a few times I’d have to agree. Their customer service is so great, as well as their food. Bathrooms are nice. Overall great pizza place. I trust the quality and taste is delicious.

Its good pizza off rush hours, but on rush hours around 6 at night, especially on weekdays. the pizza is not so good. The pizza is a bit fluffy and sometimes dosent tastle properly cooked.

More traditional/regular pizza... treat yourself and go down the street to Pizza Fenice!

Patrons were not, we'll say, welcoming to certain types of people. Nothing to do with the establishment or the actual service or servers. The locals / other customers comments and disdain ruined the experience. The pizza was ok. Not like NYC pizza. Brooklyn pizza is the best🤷‍♂️

TheOnlyOne!

Pizza was good had good flavor but the crust was to thick not was I expected it’s ok pizza won’t be going back unfortunately.

Hermes Paulino

Very unsanitary!!!!!!! The staff here needs to be trained to be safer for their customers . The gentlemen here handle food , cash , computers and everything else with their bare hands. When you ask for a slice , the attendee holds the pizza in his hands and then takes your cash to later then continue to handle more pizza. Very dirty and unsanitary to be honest it could be improved! I like this place for the price and the pizza tastes good 😊, but I would prefer to see my food served a lot cleaner.

Do not give this establishment your card information over the phone. These bums will write it down and charge it again in there own establishment months later. This place is disgusting it should be shut down. The pizza is good but there scamming way of doing business is terrible. This is a none trust worthy establishment, first pizza shop I ever experienced fraud with. I would never ever/ ever come back here again. These bums don’t even deliver to my address how the he’ll they take a payment over the phone. The funny thing is I wasn’t even in town the day they tried it.

Pizza Was not hot and pasta I got there had was made in a rush, looked like it was just thrown together and had no flavor. I got penne vodka and another person got chicken parm and we both took one bite and said no. We would have brought it back but we were one of the last orders of the night. We threw it out. Never again! Maybe a decent spot to get a quick slice but anything else is a No! I would give a half star if I could!

Um... the customer service experience wasn't great for me. Ordered in advance. Went to go pick up, when I got there, I stood in front of the counter for more than 8 mins and not one employee helped me. Other customers got served and they didn't have to signal for attention, but I was at the front of the line and was ignored. It was unfortunate, but not surprising. When ur out of your element these things tend to happen. There seems to be a country club mentality there. As good as the food is, the customer service can be better.

I would never order pizza from this place again. The pizza was cold on arrival, all of the toppings were falling off, the pizza had no cheese, and had a terrible aftertaste. Definitely a waste of money! I ordered the buffalo chicken pizza

Shanell Smith

Worst penne vodka I ever had. Plain pasta with no sauce and no flavor.

Nicole Peguero

Wish I could give the review with no stars. What a rude and horrible customer service by Jose. WE DO NOT HAVE CHICKEN WINGS, YOU’RE CALLING THE WRONG PLACE! …I get it sir, you’re an “authentic Italian pizzeria” that doesn’t mean you have to be rude. If you don’t like to take orders over the phone from a new customer, just say that and pass the phone to somebody who could.