Kurt Ingerick

A culinary institution with Red at the helm. Super comfortable dining room filled with good friends, great food, and time honored stories. Always a great meal with enough to enjoy the next day. I've been going there for over 30 years and Red's never disappoints.

Abbey Morante

We had a lovely dinner for my father-in-laws birthday. Reservations were easy, food was fantastic, portion sizes were more than adequate and our server - Lisa L - was exceptional for a party our size. I'm writing this at the request of my 10-year-old son who requested I personally give Lisa a shout out as she did "an amazing job." Thank you all for giving us a wonderful family dinner to cherish for years to come. 🩷

Joey Fazoo

🤼 Last time I was here I was disappointed. I knew there isn't anything wrong with the place. I guess it's just on who you get for a server. This time around i was very happy with the food a service. Home of the NYS section 5 hall of fame. 🤼‍♂️

+1

Terry Herne

Reservation needed. My wife took me there for my birthday 🎂. Spaghetti and Meatballs and rigatoni we gad. Very goid. Beef soup was superb. I took home triple chocolate cake and ate it later. VERY TASTY. Went again. Great food, portions and service

+12

David Lecordier

Very friendly staff, and beautiful back patio. The interior of the restaurant is pretty large. I had the special, which consisted of scallops on top of angel hair pasta, beans (cannellini I think?), escarole, and some sort of broth? I'm not sure, but it was pretty good! The scallops were cooked perfectly 👌 My dish wasn't exactly what I was expecting, and I probably won't get it again, but I still enjoyed it. I'd love to return and try one of their more traditional dishes and enjoy another glass of wine.

Kelly Kinard

This was my first time here and we had two tables of ladies to celebrate the birthday of an amazing friend. Brooke and David were our servers and they were top notch! The atmosphere was great and the food was spectacular! The owner walked around to the tables to check in and it was a wonderful touch. I will definitely be returning.

+1

Todd Cannarella

If you are looking for a good Italian dinner this is a great place. It has a wonderful casual atmosphere and delicious food. Tge service is great and give a warm family feeling.

Ann Curti

I went here for the first time on Saturday. I had made reservations but didn’t realize they were required. The service was good. They have a full bar but no drink menu so bring your imagination lol. We got cheesy garlic bread which was the complimentary bread turned cheesy garlic bread but was delish. We got a side of sauce to dip the bread and the sauce was sooooo good. I got chicken Angelo with a side of shells aka Rubinos (which were amazing!) my friend got rigatoni Asiago and said it was amazing! I will be back for sure!

Tina M.

GNOCCHI are the best in town! Homemade and authentic. Chicken quattro also a very flavorful dish. Plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. Prices average. Always on the busy side. 8/22 went with the family. Been awhile and they never accepted reservations before but now they are required. They fit us in since we didn't know and we waited 30 min for party of 8. Not terrible. It was extremely busy for a Monday at 7pm......packed. Everyone enjoyed their dishes. We ordered the calamari app....our favorite! Also the eggplant casserole, salmon dinner, chicken French and gnocchi. All dinners come with soup or salad.

+10

Saturday night the 8th we went to Red Fedele's for dinner without reservations. it was kind of early so we sat at the bar for about 30 minutes and the hostess came and got us. We sat at a booth by th…

Saturday night the 8th we went to Red Fedele's for dinner without reservations. it was kind of early so we sat at the bar for about 30 minutes and the hostess came and got us. We sat at a booth by …

We have been to the Brook House many times and it gets better as we explore the menu. Tonight I tried the Chicken Diquatro for the first time. I usually have the Saltimbocca, but the waitress said th…

Great food, excellent service! Short wait but the food was worth the wait. Highly recommend if you're looking for quality Italian!

Great food, excellent service! Short wait but the food was worth the wait. Highly recommend if you're looking for quality Italian!

Great food, excellent service! short wait but the food was worth the wait. Highly recommend if you're looking for quality Italian!

Was there on evening of July 1st. Great meal. Salad, lasagna, fresh bread and cold beer poured to the top of the glass and great service.\n\nDon't miss this one!

Was there on evening of July 1st. Great meal. Salad, lasagna, fresh bread and cold beer poured to the top of the glass and great service.\n\nDon't miss this one!

We came here on valentine's day and it was a very short wait. they decorated the restaurant for valentines and it was so cute! the food was hot and delicious and came out at a reasonable time and…

I joined my friends, who were celebrating their 47th wedding anniversary, for dinner. For a Tuesday it was very, very busy but after a short wait our table was ready. We ordered drinks and dinner…

I joined my friends, who were celebrating their 47th wedding anniversary, for dinner. For a Tuesday it was very, very busy but after a short wait our table was ready. We ordered drinks and dinner w…

Very authentic Italian food! My absolute go to when I visit Rochester. Great venue. pasta greens and beans to die for. Artichoke French, so delicious \n All the people here are very friendly.

Anyone who has left a (profanity removed) review doesn't know food. Service is always money. Just eat here trust.

I came here for my grandmas birthday and my family rented out the whole back room for the celebration. The space was set up very nicely with a table full of wines and coffee and a buffet line wit…

We were here on August 8th, - and everything about this Night out was just BEYOND Compare!! For starters, - we were fortunate enough to eat out on their BEAUTIFUL deck, - which we both think really …

Tremendous experience! We had a table outside, and the weather turned and started sprinkling. On Friday night they accommodated and found a table for 12 inside. The food was amazing. The best part …

Always a treat to go to Fedele’s! We moved to Florida two years ago and have not found any restaurant in SWF to rival the food there. I had chicken Angelo which is eggplant and chicken Frenc…

Always a treat to go to Fedele’s! We moved to Florida two years ago and have not found any restaurant in SWF to rival the food there. I had chicken Angelo which is eggplant and chicken French. S…

Red & his family have been serving outstanding authentic italian food since for many years. I can respect this since my family have been in the business and we are Italian. I can tell you that thi…

We're from the Boston area....... were visiting Rochester...... picked Red's off the web..... the food and the atmosphere was excellent. Pasta gravy was "fresh + clean", the homemade gnocchi was …

Martin Maschke

Menu options are quite interesting, food is maybe slightly above average, prices ... (bring extra), atmosphere - overcrowded (which points to people happy with the place). What's ALWAYS great is Red walking around, speaking with people and even helping his kitchen crew. Go for a birthday and you'll get a complementary cake and one of the ladies there had a phenomenal voice singing Happy Birthday!!

Kele Coloma

Italian Eatery with steak and seafood. We had a reservation which they book in 30 minute slots, arrived a bit early and were sat immediately as there were a few open tables. Atmosphere is like a cafe/diner. Waitstaff is on the ball. Pasta portions are Very Generous and come with soup or salad. All of our dishes were delicious and we couldn’t finish so took boxes home!

Always good. Have been eating at fedele's for years . They have been around a long while. Red is a great person very family oriented. I always enjoy eating with them it's like eating with family.

Everything was awesome, as usual! Specials are great price and always fresh and delicious. Love when they try a new dish, usually excellent. staff, so very busy but attentive to a tables needs. I a…

Everything was awesome, as usual! Specials are great price and always fresh and delicious. Love when they try a new dish, usually excellent. Staff, so very busy but attentive to a tables needs. I a…

We had a 6 PM reservation on May 11, 2024. Placed our order when we were seated at 6:15. We were told by our server that it may be half an hour to 45 minutes, which we were fine with. At 7:30 we wa…

We went with a group of 9 people. Being a group of Italians we go to a different Restaurant each month (mostly Italian). To start off, the service was good. As far as food it was very disappoint…

Have been to Reds several times and normally the food and service is good. During covid, carry out was just OK. My first in person return was terrible, My dinner was anything but hot, and the wai…

Kelly Degraff

Went to dinner for my birthday with my husband. He ordered his steak medium rare and it came out rare, to the point where it looked 100% raw. They took it back and cooked it to his liking. The gross part is he already took a few bites out of it. He doesn't but what of he had hepatitis or something. The gentleman behind us also had the exact same problem with his steak. Now we've been there many, many times and never had an encounter like this. Never got an apology or even a discount or anything. Not sure we will ever go back

RFBH is on the other side of the city from me and I've always heard great things. I always wanted to visit but the food was bland, pasta overcooked and was no better than Olive Garden (as I recal…

RFBH is on the other side of the city from me and I've always heard great things. I always wanted to visit but the food was bland, pasta overcooked and was no better than Olive Garden (as I recall …

Went for a banquet. Service was excellent. Rolls were fabulous. Salad predictable. Overcooked pasta. Chicken French was swimming in a godawful sauce (sherry I presume). Inedible. Baked potato perfe…

This used to be my absolute favorite Italian food in all of Rochester, the best gnocchi in the world. I've been eating here for over 25 years and recently it's taken a dive. I always get gnocchi Ala …

This used to be my absolute favorite italian food in all of Rochester, the best gnocchi in the world. I've been eating here for over 25 years and recently it's taken a dive. I always get gnocchi …

This used to be my absolute favorite italian food in all of Rochester, the best gnocchi in the world. I've been eating here for over 25 years and recently it's taken a dive. I always get gnocchi Al…

Prices high for type of dining, Hostess directed is to table in sun although we asked for shade and there was a table in shade, same hostess was rude last visit, charge points to use credit card, not…

prices high for type of dining, Hostess directed is to table in sun although we asked for shade and there was a table in shade, same hostess was rude last visit, charge points to use credit card, n…

Jennifer Richard

requested no dairy because of allergy, got cheese all over my pasta. the penne that came with my guest’s meal was not cooked. there were no desserts left on a Friday night! the other food was just ok. our waitress was lovely so i tipped well, but probably wouldn’t go back.

Sadly, this restaurant has gone terribly downhill. The food is poor to mediocre at best. One of my friends said, 'The sauce tastes like creamy tomato soup'. As an Italian, I will never spend …

Save yourself do not eat here or waste your money . Said something to the owner on the way out he could've cared less!!!! The service was terrible and the food not cook and what was sort of cooked …

Terrible experience. Got yelled at when we arrived for not making reservation. Food came and both meals were luke warm. Had them both redone and was better. Seafood dish presentation was really bad…

I will not make the mistake of coming to this restaurant again. We made reservations for Thanksgiving because none of us are into Turkey, so we thought italian sounded good. When we got there we fo…

Jeff Thomas

62 degrees in the dining room. Portions meek and flavor bland. I believe the fish was microwaved. Cold chicken french had to be reheated. Seafood platter under cooked scallops, over cooked shrimp, terrible wet sauce like a swimming pool. Gnocchi was like wet pancake batter cubes with no salt. Drive south down elmgrove a couple miles and get quality meals at agitinas or papa joes.