Pizza Stop

Genuine Italians from Italy. All the food is great, but the sausage pizza is awesome! On Tuesdays they make wonderful lentil soup. Brothers, Mike and Sal, work food magic!

A generational long island pizza place, my grandpa ate here with my dad, my dad ate here with me and I’ve been here with my younger cousins and nephews, truly an exceptional pizza place by the slice and in pie format as well.

Pizza is elite! Thin crust and perfectly cheesy. Obsessed with their Greek salad too!

Pizza Stop! The best pizza in the known universe. I've been going here basically my entire life and my (ten years older) brothers before me. It's a hole in wall in a strip mall and the best thing you can get is a whole pie, eat what you can, take the rest home and reheat a slice the next day. It will restore your faith in humanity. Also try the garlic knots.

Best pizza place around! I love the grandma pie and the cauliflower crust salad pizza with apple cider vinegar dressing, the workers are very friendly as well. I’m never disappointed here!

My go to Neighborhood pizza joint. Always friendly service and great pizza.

Gotta say the pizza here is terrific. Had a plain cheese slice and it really hit the spot. Their other food is very tasty too. Will be going back to order some pies and entree dishes for a party.

Best Pizza! I've been coming to this place since before I could see over the counter. Still amazing! Still wish they would make an extra large pie though.

Best eggplant parm I ever had! Penne ala vodka slice is great. Nice snappy regular slice too. Been eating here 40 years! Always spot on! Keep it up pizza stop.

Great pizza place. Sal makes the best pie around for sure. The garlic knots are on another level. Ask for the garlic knot pie and youve reached top tier pizza.

Not many pizza places around that aren't just the same cheap garbage. This place you can tell uses quality ingredients and the man behind the counter is def putting love into his food.

Pizza is pretty good no complain and the staff was friendly.

Dan Check

Great pizza. I learned I need to call it a pie when I order here.

Marie Estrada

Ordered for delivery on halloween. Manager Mikey was super polite and delivered it himself SO promptly for a Friday Halloween. Food was GREAT. Best meatball parm hero I've had in ages.

Alexander Terzopoulos

I ordered slices of pizza from the Pizza Stop in the early 1980s thru the early 90s until I went to college in 1995. I will revisit after 30 years of a hiatus.

Eugene Aman

Best pizza anywhere, has plenty of specialty pizzas which I enjoy. Service is great went with friends has dine in options . Garlic knot slice was great

Mary Catalano

Delicious pizza and great service. Went on a Friday afternoon and was helped by a lovely young man. Cut up the pizza for my little ones and helped me clean up. Will be coming back to order pizzas for my daughters party

J

Great place to eat. I've been coming here since I was a kid riding my bike in the 90s. Love their food especially the pepperoni pie and the white pie is my favorite from them. They make some of the best calzones and pinwheels too.

brandon c

Randomly stopped in, i was ik the area and I'm still scratching my head the pizza was amazing. I will definitely be back!

Mike Reed

Great pizza always !!!! The sausage bites are the best I ever had great job!!!

Kristine Kazala

Ordered here for the first time when I was having my nails done a few doors down. Picked my lunch up it was delicious. Wish they were closer to where I live.

The Bluegill god

I recently tried out this pizzeria. The pizza was unbelievable. It is the closest thing to Brooklyn Pizza I remember growing up on. I highly recommend this place they are a really old school, Italian pizzeria. These guys know what they’re doing. Big Joe…😉👍

Rb1330

I have heard about this place for a while but never remembered to stop by. I finally did today and it was just as I was told. The Sicilian pie was awesome, the crust was amazing and the sauce was delicious. The Buffalo pizza was one of the best I have ever had. The gentleman behind the counter was very nice . It's really not that far from me, so I'd rather spend a few extra minutes getting here to have delicious pizza, then to go somewhere close that's nowhere near as good. The price was very reasonable as well.

Christopher Ciminelli

My favorite local pizza place! Pizza is always cooked perfectly and never had an issue here. Their sauce is delicious and it goes great with a calzone or garlic knot. The staff treats you like family and cares about the quality of their food. Will be coming back for years!

charles mehner

This is an amazing hidden gem. Food is delicious. It is a pizzeria that has been around since 69. Mike and Sal are awesome. Definitely should be on your list to try. I go 30 mins out of my way to get their Sicilian pie.

fr ran

It had been a while since I had their pizza. I ordered a Sicilian and a white pie. The Sicilian was excellent. The sauce was delicious, crisp on the bottom with a perfect crumb with a subtle yeastiness. The white pie was as I had remembered. The crust held the fold and the topping was perfectly seasoned. If you want the best pizza go there.

First time visiting today. Very friendly staff. Other customers seemed to be regulars. I ordered what I thought was Sicilian and was told it was their new Focaccia with plum tomatoes and cheese and spices. Let me tell you... It was great! I'll be back

Pizza was the best I've had in a while!!! Loved the game knots. Didn't give it full 5 stars because the pepperoni stuffed garlic knots were very dry and the baked Ziti didn't have alot of flavor. But the pizza was amazing.

I've been coming to Pizza Stop since the early 2000s and the quality hasn't changed. Pasta dishes are solid and the pizza is always good. Their heros are the only thing I'm not a fan of. Friendly crew over there as well.

I have been on the hunt for good Sicilian pizza Recently ordered Sicilian pizza 12 slices Pizza was very good .However slices were much smaller then most Sicilian pies in the area. Perhaps I just remembering when you were lucky you could finish two slices of silician . The hunt continues

patrick pierce

Most mid pizza place ever sometimes was good sometimes was horrible never understood how they did it.

Deborah Zella

We love pizza stop. BUT every once in a while, like today, the pizza was horrible. Overcooked, dry, hard cheese, crust is black. When it’s good it’s good, but when it’s bad it’s horrible. Very disappointed

Food is very good but the guys who work there esp. The old one who you can't even understand what he says when he talks and is very slow serving people ruins the experience, he will always tell you minutes and it's not ready for 45

robert femia

Went here for years until we hit a run of bad pizza. Went back to give them a second chance after my favorite pizza place closed down. First 2 times it was excellent. Last night the Sicilian pie was burnt and not enough cheese, called the shop to let them know and Sal told me to come down to get a replacement. Second pie was undercooked and tasteless. Guess we are done again. To bad

Pizza slices are smaller compared to other local pizzerias and more expensive. Food was over Cooked, when I called to advise them the owner was rude and hung up. He stated that he wasn't going to take my complaint. What owner would say their product is bad, he even went as far as degrading the other pizza shops in the area stating they dont have quality products like he does. If it wasn't for the fact that you have to give one star to write a review, I'd give 0 stars. He said come get another pie, dud I dont like your pizza, I said no thank you so he said it was a wash. Wash my ***, he won, he got money for a bad product and in lost money on a bad product, never again.

I used this location for catering for my daughter's communion - the only food there- and my entire party got sick. Either it was from the amount for grease dripping off of every dish or something wrong with the ingredients. Caused huge sickness party wide. I tried to call the owner to let him know and he immediately started yelling at me. He got irate and nasty. All I wanted to do was inform him and see if he would make it right after I spent over $220 in food. Not the family friendly place they say they are. Never will go back. Not only did he make us sick but he yelled right off the bat.

$23 for a hero, 6 knots, and a slice. $4 delivery from a dirty disrespectful delivery boy. Crazy. If I didn't have a broken foot I would have drove the 3-min drive. I won't buy from this place again. Oh, food wasn't hot and it took 40min.

Angela Cusamano

Did not enjoy the pizza here at all! It was very greasy and cold. The sauce and crust had no flavor. The slices are smaller than other pizza shops. They charge you one price one week and another, higher price another week. The entire place is downright filthy! Looks like they haven't cleaned the windows, floors or tables for decades! Wonder what the kitchen looks like! The workers look shell-shocked and are very cold and not friendly at all! Won't be going back here! Found a better and cleaner pizza place down the street! Don't eat at pizza stop not only because of the bad food but to make sure you don't get sick! This place deserves 0 stars! owner's feelings are hurt to hear the truth! Read the other low reviews here. Are they lying too? Tisk-Tisk! And learn the language!

Bilal Arar

Went there to pick up and order for my sister. The older gentleman there gave me nothing but a silent stare when I said hello. Then told him I’m picking up for (name) says nothing but “a couple more minutes” while the food was READY ON THE OVEN. Food was soggy too.

Rosi Manzano

I just went to buy a pepperoni pizza, they told me to wait 10 minutes after 40 minutes they called me to deliver the pizza and they handed me a cold pizza... I was in the parking lot of the establishment and look, they only took one that I already had on hold for another customer and gave it to me... The pizza was cold.