Ana Butler

Their steady business comes mostly from repeat customers and referrals. The meal was perfect! The neighborhood's culinary standard-bearer. Employees make customers feel special with personal greetings. This restaurant satisfies my taste and I share that.

Phil Gill

I had the pastrami sandwich and it was absolutely delicious! Robbie, my son, had a cheeseburger and he loved it. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. The atmosphere was relaxed and comfortable. I appreciate that they are wheelchair accessible and the parking is free, though the lot is on the smaller side. Overall, a wonderful experience for both adults and kids.

+21

Аліна Кузневич

This was the most delicious beer I’ve ever tried! Grapefruit is my top favorite! The staff were very friendly. There was live music on Sunday, which added a pleasant atmosphere. My fav spot 🤩 Highly recommend!

Nicolette Suberska

Absolutely incredible spot. The old German decor & style had me reading the back of the menu about its entire history. Food was impeccable & portions are huge - especially that goulash soup. Service was friendly & efficient. I would absolutely travel from the North Shore just to have dinner here for the atmosphere & food. 10/10 highly recommend.

Frank Castellano

Haven't been here for a long time and I was surprised to find that the food and service was very good as I remember it. Beautiful old world decor made it very cozy. The pretzel appetizer was huge and very tasty. Venison and cherry sausage were delicious. Our entrees were Beef goulash, beef brisket, roast beef sandwich and pastrami sandwich. Each of us was very impressed with the dishes and commented on how good they tasted. Definitely will be back for dinner soon!

Chris Jack

Recently visited Killmeyer's Old Bavaria Inn in Staten Island and tried their burger - absolutely delightful! The burger was juicy and cooked to perfection, with just the right balance of flavors. The bun was fresh, and the toppings were generous, adding to the overall deliciousness. The atmosphere of the place added to the experience, making it a memorable meal. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a great burger in Staten Island. Definitely going back for more!

+2

Alec Schlotfeldt

Delicious. Highly recommend the jumbo pretzel with beer cheese and the chicken schnitzel. The restaurant was absolutely empty. One other table for two was filled. Shocking for a Friday evening. People began showing up around 9pm. The live music was enjoyable. Our server was more than happy to allow any substitutions for sides included with our entrees.

Natalia Med

This is the place to go for great German food! It’s interesting decorating inside and out too. The service was okay. If you’re looking for beer, then this is also a great place to get one. We tried a sausage platter and it was tasty! For the next time I will try pretzel and potato pancakes, someone said we must try this) On Friday night there was a live music performance. It was very pleasant to listen to popular hits and it added a good impression on the atmosphere in this restaurant.

+17

Henry D

Was there first time today, was in mood for some German beer and food. I was pleasantly surprised with the feel of the place, appears quite authentic with its decor. I got one light german draft beer that was a bit weak, and then got Octoberfest Spaten which was much better, so that's good. For food we got Killmeyers namesake dish which appeared to be beef pot roast with potato dumplings and red cabbage in some glaze. The beef was excellent, falling apart so easy and good quality. Unfortunately the glaze was sweet and just didn't go with the dish, so was the red cabbage, just too sweet. My wife got the goulash which was much more tasty than the sweet glaze so I'd recommend opting for that option. Overall I was pretty happy and would definitely go back for some sausages and more beer to try. Hoping next time it would be more 5 star experience.

Arik Burakovsky

I had a pleasant dinner here with my father and relatives. We ordered multiple items, and I had a chance to taste the Forest Wives Mushrooms, Bistro Salad, Oven Braised Beef Brisket, and Crème Brûlée. I also had a pear cider and coffee. The food was delicious, and the atmosphere was lovely, with jazz music playing and the old-fashioned Bavarian ambiance. The service was also excellent, though they took a bit longer than expected to bring us dessert. The location is convenient, with plenty of parking across the street.

+2

Francine Laura

Lunch at Killmeyer’s Old Bavaria Inn, the oldest bar in Staten Island with the largest Hummel in the world! For appetizers, we had fried mushrooms and potato pancakes. For main courses, we had the Rouladen (sliced rolls of beef stuffed with smoked bacon, onions, mustard, and gherkins with red cabbage & potato dumplings), the Rahmschnitzel (pork cutlets with a creamy mushroom sauce, German home fries & vegetables), and Dusseldorf Chicken (in a wine sauce with shallots, mushrooms and Dijon with vegetables & whipped potatoes). For dessert, German chocolate cake. The food was good, the restaurant is charming, and the service was excellent.

+16

Noelle Brunetti

Celebrated a bday. Comedy show is very vulgar and not funny. Spent way more money than we planned. Meatball was burnt and dry. Will not be going back.

+1

It was a terrible experience. Three mothers with their children went to Killmeyer’s Old Bavaria for dinner and felt treated differently, disliked, and discriminated against. When we entered, they said there was a table for nine and a wait of about an hour. We were willing to split into two tables to reduce the wait time and were told it would be 40-50 minutes. However, after waiting for 90 minutes, two extremely rude waiters came to tell us there were no tables available. We questioned why this wasn't mentioned during registration, and another waiter came, trying to appease us with a friendly attitude and offering a $15 gift card as compensation. Was this a joke? A century-old restaurant treating customers with such low-class service—no matter how good the food, it's not worth going back to.