Susan Carvel

My husband and I had a great experience at NY Beer Project. We were seated quickly and a server came over shortly after. We had the beef ribs entree and the Times Square burger. Both meals were very good. Nathan, our server, was efficient and friendly!

Patti (Pattinys)

This is a nice buy busy place to grab a meal and enjoy a beverage. The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming. There are plenty of food options for even the most picky eaters. The wait staff are amazing!

Antonio Brieno Rankin

Very nice atmosphere. We got there right when they opened and it did not take very long to fill up at all. Overall, the experience was pleasant. The food was pretty good. My wife and I shared there version of Buffalo wings. She got Lobster Eggrolls and I got the Mulberry Pizza. All pretty good.

Ashley K

Absolutely LOVED this place! We sat outside because we had our dog with us. The waitress was extremely kind and efficient. Every single dish was a crowd pleaser. The buffalo mac (hot) was soooo good, hope to come back someday!! Recommend!! P.S. we came at an odd time (~2:30pm) but it was still quite busy. There would probably be a wait during traditional dining hours.

Bryan Equinozzi

Had dinner at the New York Beer Project with my dad, and it was a fantastic experience all around. The place has an awesome vibe—spacious, stylish, and full of energy without feeling too loud. You can tell they put a lot of thought into the design and the overall guest experience. The food was excellent—fresh, flavorful, and well portioned. And the beer selection? Top-notch. There’s something for every taste, and the staff is more than happy to help with recommendations. Our server was attentive, friendly, and made us feel right at home. It was one of those meals that felt more like a moment—great food, a few laughs, and quality time with someone important. Definitely a place I’d come back to, whether it’s for a night out with family or just to enjoy a solid local brew.

Geneva Williams

This place is so cool inside! My husband and I got the Manhattan Mac and the brisket panini. We would highly recommend both. The service was spot on too, our appetizer and food was timed perfectly even though we ordered it at the same time. Would highly recommend stopping here even if you don't like beer. (But my husband understood why their beer has won awards)

Joey and Steph were great and attentive! Fall/Oktoberfest burger special was flavorful. Spicy watermelon marg was good but my favorite was Walter's Jelly Donut Beer (raspberry ale) on tap.

Caci Flores

Food was very good and the atmosphere was cool. What brought the review star to a 4 was that the description of the food was different from what was served. Also the noise level was on the high level for the atmosphere. What was most important was the beer (and there isn't a star review for this) NYBP would have gotten a 5 star! The cerveza was fantastic! Go have this refreshing summer beer!

Jan Sherburne

Bartenders are great. Lots of great food options and all are delicious. However they used to do their winter white cosmo drink and also had it in their giggle juice. They didn’t do it last year and I was really hoping it would be back this year!! It would be great any time of the year. Just change the name for summer!

Melissa Stio

Went to the NYBP for the first time with my partner and had a pleasant experience 🙂 I thought the building itself was very interesting and well-decorated. Also, our waitress was kind, quick, and responsive. The food was delicious - I had the salmon and my partner had the celebration sandwich. For a place having "Beer" right in its name, I guess I was looking for a larger selection of beer and all items on the menu available. I would definitely go back as the meal and drinks were wonderful.

Alcris Luzecky

Food was just okay (at least I gave it a try), but the service and vibes really stood out. The beer selection, though- that was excellent. Definitely worth a visit for the drinks and atmosphere alone.

Sammie Kali

Had the Asian Salmon Bowl. It was ok but a bit bland for my taste. It was decent. But nothing to be excited about. The crab cake was full of flavor. My co pilot really liked it. I'm not that huge on seafood. But it definitely had a burst of flavor in your mouth. The weather was great for sitting outside. So other wise... normal decent time.

To the owner, I sincerely hope you read this! Our family used to come here for dinner a lot. We live down the road and wanted to see it thrive.The music and atmosphere are amazing. Our waiter Donnie is also a favorite of ours, his personality brightens anyone's day. He always knows us and is always our waiter! Please hear me, with what I and many others have to say regarding your food. The menu is more of an overpriced diner menu. It is basic items they can turn over very fast, burgers, grilled cheese, wings and the like. Our family had the General Tso' chicken which had hardly any chicken on the plate, the Mac and cheese was so bland it had no taste whatsoever, Kraft had more taste than this did! I had the $16 cozy grilled cheese with tomato soup. Way overpiced for such a basic item, and lastly a bacon burger which was perfect. Just because you can afford it doesn't mean we'll keep buying it. These last few times have been DISAPPOINTING to say the least. I also bought 4 Gameday growlers which were $60! Yikes!! The bartender an older woman with glasses completely ignored me, (not the men though) to the point that a group of guys let me get in with them just to order because they felt bad for me.She was so rude for no reason whatsoever.I was also absolutely shocked when I got the bill for the to go beers, the last time I bought them they were $20, I'll NEVER buy them again at this price! We try to come here as we want to see the business thrive but with just an overpriced diner menu, Im not sure we'll keep coming back. You can have a basic menu but don't overcharge on basic items that belong on a kids menu. Lastly, there was almost no heat in the womans bathroom and absolutely NO hot water to wash your hands and in the dead of winter thats an issue.We truly want any business in our area to thrive especially yours, however if it stays like this I'm not sure you will in the long run

Adam Nichols

We stopped by for dinner. There was about a 30-minute wait. There is a good selection of house made beer. The tropical lifesaver was a favorite. The server was great. I ordered the beef on weck with parmesen truffle fries. The bread was soggy, and the meat was cold with a flavor that I didn't like, along with cold fries. I would not recommend either of those items. One in our party ordered wings half bbq and half buffalo. The buffalo wings were not very well sauced. They tasted more like a plain wing. They do have an option for extra crispy. I would recommend trying them extra crispy. One in our party ordered a side salad with salmon that he described as OK. My wife tried the chicken sandwich special on jalapeño corn bread. She said that she loved it, it was really spicy.

Joe Cass

Although the atmosphere is excellent, the staff and servers are excellent… the FOOD… is NOT GOOD. At my previous visit I was served brisket that was so undercooked that it was inedible. Brisket is the ONLY cut of beef that MUST be fully cooked due to the connective tissue. Properly cooked brisket should MELT in your mouth. At THIS visit the food was again… horrible. The bun for the sandwich was old and stale. The French fries were old and stale. How do you mess up French fries? My stomach felt awful after today’s meal. That’s a sign of poorly handled food. I’ll never eat there again. I did tip the server over 100% because he was excellent and the crappy food isn’t his fault. Never go there again.