Ingrid Roosma

If you craving an authentic Italian dinner without paying Little Italy prices, then head to Carlo‘s. Such a treat from start to finish. Portions are super generous. (Pics are gnocchi and Lasagna)

dalila zanchettin

I’ve been three times, and each visit to Carlo’s in Yonkers has been a delight! As an Italian (living in NYC for just over three years), I hold Italian food to the highest standard—yet Carlo’s American‑Italian twist wins me over every time. The cozy, warmly lit dining room feels like home, and the service is friendly and attentive without ever being intrusive. Highlights include their braciole simmered in a rich tomato sauce over rigatoni, stuffed clams, and the cannoli. Pair any dish with one of their carefully curated wines, and you’ve got a meal you won’t soon forget. Highly recommended!

Steve

How this place doesn’t have all 5 stars blows my mind. This is the definition of an off the charts restaurant. The food here is excellent to say the least, and on top of it, VERY reasonably priced. The drunken chicken parm (chicken parm w/ their house made vodka) is seriously the best thing I’ve ever had. Definitely recommend making a reservation here as it does fill up.

Angeline Bernard

We had our family repass gathering. Lunch was served! Everything was excellent. Chicken Marsal, Eggplant /Parm pasta & vodka sauce, house salad, & salmon with roasted potatoes. The accommodation were great. We confirmed at the last minute & they were happy to assist. The large party staff was very polite, service was professional, the atmosphere was great. We could talk to pur loved ones. Bathroom accommodations good & clean. My personal thanks to the staff.

J.Z.

An unpretentious old-school Italian ristorante serving generous portions of traditional favorites at very good prices. Their arugula with gorgonzola salad is beyond scrumptious. The raspberry dressing, I was told, is made with fresh raspberries. You can make three meals out of their veal (or chicken) sorrentino. But it's not just about portion size. It's about quality and taste. Carlo's has it all. Look at the photo I posted of their tiramisu.

+3

Zury Bourque

Amazing service!! Delicious food and portions are HUGE which was perfect because we were starving after walking all day. We called 3 places to request seating for 13 but other places said no. We arrived 5 mins before closing and our table was ready. All the staff was friendly and welcoming. Thank you for Voula, Max & Antonio. We have a wonderful memory!!

Chris Bourque

Food was so delicious and HUGE portions. Staff was amazing. The manager keep the restaurant open late for is because we were coming with a big group right at closing time. Everything we tried was tasty. They even have Fettuccine Alfredo, you just have to ask for it (not on the menu) but SO delicious.

+1

Eric Muller

I was in the area and came in for dinner. Food was excellent. They have all the Italian classics you would want and dishes can be ordered individually or family style. The pictures I took are of individual portions, which are generous! Cesar salad was fresh and well dressed. Chicken parm was delicious. Cannolis were perfect. Staff was very friendly. Overall a great value. Our table did not order this, but I saw many other tables order the NY strip steak, which was very large and came sliced. The steak seems to be a very popular dish and looked delicious.

Ruben Roque

Food is good, atmosphere is nice. Place gets packed! Definitely reserve a table if you can. Chicken parm was delicious and penne with vodka sauce was good but darker than I'm used to and they left out bacon bits in it. That garden salad with their homemade dressing 😍 They also accommodate big parties of 20+

Rosalynn M

Large portions, plus everything looks good so we end up ordering so much that we're stuffed no matter what. It was so good the first time we went that we went back with different friends later in the week.

+8

Jonathan S

Food was good. The vibe was weird at first. They sat us right next to where the servers hang out, and they were literally on top of us, and were so loud I couldn't even enjoy. Wasn't even crowded so they should not have sat us at that terrible table. But we asked them to move us, and they did, and it was fine after that. Still, it's annoying that they put us in that position to begin with.

I love their food, but they've messed up my orders enough times times for it to be an issue. I'm only making this review though because they had the audacity to be rude about it too. There's tons of other great Italian places in the area, not worth the grief of coming here again. Crazy long waits too.

Not one, not two, but three times they messed up our order for a pick up. On the third time they gave my order to someone else. They didn’t even have the courtesy to tell me or even ask me if I was still waiting on an order when I was the last waiting for their order. When I finally ask how my order was coming along, they realized I was the order who was given to someone else. To top it all off, when they knew I was unpleased about the whole situation, they rush to heat everything up and my food was lukewarm at best. Not that losing my business makes any difference nor will they change anything about their service, but maybe this review will at least help someone else out when they are thinking about ordering here for pick up.

Homayra Ferrando

I’ve ordered from this restaurant twice, and unfortunately both experiences were very disappointing. The first time was about a year ago when we dined in, and it was a terrible experience. This past weekend, we decided to give them a second chance and ordered takeout. We ordered shrimp parmigiana, penne alla vodka with chicken cutlets, and a side of calamari. After waiting an hour and a half for delivery—even though the restaurant is only 10 minutes away—the order arrived incomplete. The shrimp parmigiana was missing. When I called the restaurant, the woman I spoke with insisted the order was complete. I even offered to FaceTime to show her that it was missing. Eventually, she said they would send it out, but it took another hour to arrive. We had planned to eat dinner together as a family and ended up waiting so we could all eat at the same time. To make matters worse, the next day my boyfriend became very sick with stomach pain, a fever, and constant trips to the bathroom. We had to go to urgent care, where he was diagnosed with food poisoning. Between the long wait times, missing food, poor customer service, and getting sick afterward, this will definitely be our last time ordering from here.