Sara Lopez

On 7/22/25 I called in a phone order for pick up. The girl that answered had the best customer service she helped me with my order and when I arrived I heard her take another call. Same professional service haven’t heard anyone else come close. This is my new favorite spot. Thank you

stephany

I've been here twice in the last month for 3 reasons: food is absolutely delicious, service is fast, staff are all friendly. The prices are fair for the quality of the food. My favorite thing on the menus is the Paisano Pizza Sub. Never had anything like it, if you want a sandwich but also pizza its the best choice. Local gem that deserves the 5 stars 🌟

DeathsownProductions

Was a wonderful experience. My family comes from back east and a good ol Italian nostalgic family NY style Pizzeria with real taste is a rare thing to come by out here 🤌🏻 That being said this nailed it all the way around. I just got a place down the street and I'll be making this my go-to at least once a paycheck 💯🤌🏻

+3

Melissa Lawrence

This place brought back memories of the pizzerias I frequented as a kid. The pepperoni was thin and crispy, the mozzarella sticks were to die for, and my husband and I barely made a dent in the huge antipasto salad. I loved the ease of ordering online and picking up at a time that was convenient for me. We will definitely be returning for more!

Daryn Nevels

Pizza is amazing and staff is just as amazing. If you’re eating lunch or eating for 2, I recommend getting the one slice drink combo. It’s cost efficient and very feeling. The dessert chimichangas are phenomenal as well.

Sal

I think it was excellent pizza! One of the best chili verde pizzas I've had hands down. The only reason I gave four stars instead of five was because the pizza was not cut all the way through. When we attempted to take a slice the cheese and meat slid off and the pizza ripped.

Jessica Hanley

I hate doing this. But yall have to step it up at this location. Tonight I ordered mosserella sticks on the phone to pick up as part of my order. The kid , I say kid because he is clearly young gave me bread sticks with cheese and said he thought that’s what I meant but wasn’t sure. He said I said cheese sticks. I’m pretty sure I didn’t . Regardless if there’s questions clarify. HE tried to pay for it , I told him No it’s on the business that’s not how it works. Because we all know it’s wrong to charge employees and you guys can right it off as a business loss. Regardless yall owe me 2 bucks and some change. He also forgot my artichoke which he put on so maybe yall owe me less than 2 bucks now. My salad had 1 single piece of feta. That sucked. Anyways, it’s not just him. He’s just a kid and mistakes happen but , In the last year I’ve been here for dine in and pick up alone and with my boyfriend, I’ve been with friends, and every single time there’s something wrong with the order. EVERY SINGLE TIME . Dine in you guys gave me burnt inedible potatoes logs that the cashiers agreed were burnt and didn’t look good. Picking up wise twice there’s been pizzas that were missing toppings that I didn’t notice till I was home. It’s frustrating because no one wants to drive to further locations. So can you please please please just get it together? When I got home and was asked what took so long before I could answer “she went to Cataldos” “why would you go there, they’re the worst, with getting orders wrong”. Again I love this places. Hate the service. Thanks.

Got an itchy throat as soon as I eat pizza on Wednesday now it Friday and it gotten worse. I whoul suggest to the owner to send there workers home instead of letting them work .

Christine

I ordered a calzone. And its not the same. Used to be sooo cheesy. Not this time. More sauce than cheese. Kinda bummed out. No wonder they weren't busy. Sad. I won't spend the money on good quality ingredients, if I dont really get them. Really liked this place for a special splurge. Not anymore. Ate it because I cant stand wasting money on something I already ordered. Sucks. Loved this place. Pictures are the small leftovers with no cheese. There is the to go box doesnt even show their name.

Thomas Forry

About 1/2 inch worth of lettuce is a 4 inch deep container, absolutely the worst amount of lettuce ive ever gotten from here and I am extremely dissapointed its literally about 1/4 cup of lettuce if evem that much!!!! >:(

Ezekiel Carrillo

Just bought 2 mediums With delivery for 50$ ....all I have to say is save your money. Go somewhere else.they are stingy. And their definition of medium is subjective. More closer to a personal sized pizza and many would agree with me.

Gary Snail

*My review was deleted/removed somehow* Wonderful pizza would definitely recommend eating here but service is horrible. Most of the workers are always great except the girl in front she is awful everytime. Cannot remember her name I think it’s Dailyn or something like that. She’s a rude argumentative girl who does not belong anywhere near a customer service job. Cannot believe this worker has not been fired yet it’s a horrible experience with her everyone we go in. We stopped going in and would just do delivery but even over the phone she’s awful. 0/10 this worker has to go before they lose more customers over her. Also, within this past year we stood at the window to watch the workers make the pizza we ordered and we witnessed a young male worker vape or smoke all over the food in the back and it was horrible but we couldn’t feel comfortable saying anything because of how rude the girl in the front is.