Courtney Boettcher

Love Papa Leos!!! Always excellent and if it's not, they correct it and make it right. Highly recommend.

Blake Lemoi

Papa Leo’s is more than just great pizza — it’s a true community spot for Lockport. Consistently good food, friendly faces, and a place where locals actually connect. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or feeding a crowd, they show up for the neighborhood and support the people who live and work here. Small businesses like this are the backbone of a strong community, and Papa Leo’s gets that. Proud to have them in Lockport. 🍕👏

Jackie Pratt

Papa Leo's is always good food, fast delivery~!

HanDog

Great people! Great service! Great food! What more can you ask for! We love pizza night with our local Papa Leo's!

Dakota DuBois

good food, friendly customer service. pizza is hot and crispy and not a long wait time. i’ve been served by Izzy, and she is a wonderful worker. very friendly and always so kind. everytime i go, i look forward to seeing her.

Dana Cooper

My favorite place to get subs here, but I haven't been swinging by a lot lately. Their 8"-and-a-drink is a good value, and I like the new rolls they've been using. Plus, they don't use the cheap shredded lettuce that wilts real quick. You know the stuff. My main complaint is that orders take a while to fill, especially if you eat there. Still, it's worth the wait. Also, Leo's uses a sweet sauce for its pizza, dips, etc -- not my preference personally, but to each their own. Staff is pretty laid back and polite, though again, I can't recommend them if you're in a rush. If you've got the time to eat in and stay a while though, they've got some good stuff.

jennifer g

Anytime you want a solid slice fair price

curt noon

Called to order our food for the game guy answers phone with an attitude. Then asked to read back my order, and he keeps saying banana peppers. I say no I didn’t order that as I only eat pepperoni. He tries telling me I did and wants to argue with me about it. Dude you need to learn customer service. You just cost your store a nice order today and all my future business. So I ordered from pizza oven where they were very kind.Update. Emma called me to see what happened and apologized for the incident. She was very apologetic and we spoke for several minutes. Thanks for calling and speaking with me, and I will order again soon thanks to Emma!

John

Standard pizzeria type, crust and sauce like most places. Nothing special or unique. The pickle pizza was weird.

Marcus Veytia

I stopped by and ordered the meatball sub (8" size). I appreciated that the bun was not thick; I don't need all that starch. However , the meatballs were pretty good size and it satisfied my hunger. The taste was pretty decent as well.

Used to love this place, but lately every time I go they play games with coupons. Recently I gave them cash and the man at the register tried to convince me I owed $6 in sales tax on a $20 pizza, he then took the coupon. Not giving them my business if the employees won't even bother to honor what you give them.

Mark Fanara

This is the first time I have left a bad review for a restaurant. I was told 20-30 mins for a pick up order. It took over an hour and they were clearly not busy. The pizza was THE worst tasting pizza I have ever had. The cheese had never melted, but was also browned? It was flavorless and looked like plastic. Cheap garbage. Inedible. My kids couldn’t even eat it.

Andy Swift

Man I hate the drag down local businesses, but this experience ruined it for me. We ordered online, which I’d never suggest to anyone ordering from here. The app said it’d be done in 30 mins. I get there and they can’t find my order. Turns out they hung the ticket and never told anyone else. So they say it’ll be another 20-25 mins. I get it, mistakes happen. I worked at a pizza joint for 9 years. So I’ve seen it all. So I wait 25 more mins in my car and go back in. Mind you, I’ve only seen 2 people go in to pick up their orders during the 30 mins I’ve been there.. so not busy at all. At least to my standards.. I go back in and they tell me it’s gonna be a bit longer. I’m now watching them work to kill the time. It’s obvious they missed a few of my items… they scramble to get my order together. I finally walk out of there after an hour spent waiting there, on top of the 30 mins I waited to drive over and pickup. The staff is severely disorganized, and lack proper training. They desperately need management.. The food was below par, but it definitely wasn’t gonna taste good after that experience regardless. I truly hope they can get it together.