E Brown

Wow. This is absolutely the best pizza! Great selection of flavors. Phenomenal crust and sauce. Some sitting, some standing places to eat. Definite recommend.

The Casual Compass

This nice pizza place near Madison Square Garden in New York was recommended via reviews. I'm glad I listened because the pizza there is unique and delicious. They sell mostly pizza slices and calzones, but can accommodate whole pies. I recommend.😁👍❤️🤤

Karim Nuri

Great pizza. The slice was $4-$5, but the sauce had great flavor. The crust had a nice crunch and good chewiness, and there was a good amount of cheese. Classic New York slice, simple and satisfying.

+1

Elisa D

Great gem in Time Square. Has a large variety of pizza toppings and is a great alternate to Joe’s pizza. The pizza bases and crust has a nice crisp. It’s a NY pizza slice done well.

+3

Christian Perez

really busy and delicious pizza shop in the heart of times square! i liked this place a lot. the service was friendly and the pizzas all look fresh in the counter. i got the white square slice and margherita slice and i recommend those the most, they had so much flavor. also get the garlic knots! they are so hot and good too with the marinara sauce. the wait wasn’t that long either. i recommend if you’re visiting new york and you’re in the times square area, come check out carnegie pizza 👍🏼

June Stoyer

This is a great place to stop and grab a slice. The slices are about 4.50 for a plain slice, which is reasonable considering it is Times Square. I didn't care to see suggested 25% 30% and higher gratuity for picking up my food at the counter. That is a bit over the top. I also ordered garlic knots, which weren't bad but not the best that I've had. There is no parking, so forget that. I did see two families eating, so it should be OK to take your kids. The guys making the pizza work hard, and you do get piping hot pizza. So for that reason, I would recommend this pizzaria.

+11

Linh Clark

So happy we found this place. I have ate at few pizza places around Manhattan, this is one of the best so far. Service really fast and friendly, pizza is so good and reasonable price. Definitely we will come back.

+3

Stephan T. Nguyen

My family and I are on vacation and wanted to try NY pizza. We wanted to go to Joe's pizza at first, but the line was way too long so Carneggie pizza was our second choice. I'm so glad we ended up here. The ambiance was small, but it wasn't bad and we were lucky to grab a table for 4. On to the pizzas. It was so delicious we had to get seconds. I highly recommend coming here if you are in the mood for pizza.

Great pizza. Cheese slices are huge and four bucks. Some of the best cheese I've had. Piping hot so let it cool a few minutes. Highly recommend the cheese. Wasn't crazy about their pepperoni but chee…

Great pizza. Cheese slices are huge and four bucks. Some of the best cheese I've had. Piping hot so let it cool a few minutes. Highly recommend the cheese. Wasn't crazy about their pepperoni but ch…

This Pizza place was right next to the Hampton INN where we stayed near Times Square. Great Pizza, lots of varieties. Super Affordable and hit the spot. My daughter and I went here a few times at nig…

This pizza place was right next to the Hampton INN where we stayed near Times Square. Great pizza, lots of varieties. Super Affordable and hit the spot. My daughter and I went here a few times at…

Nice pizza place. Casual. Nice atmosphere. Quick service. Would come back. We got a few different pizzas and all of the were very good.

Nice pizza place. Casual. Nice atmosphere. Quick service. Would come back. We got a few different pizzas and all of the were very good.

Excellent pizza! Great variety. Very clean. Customer service is wonderful! Overall loved it!

Excellent pizza! Great variety. Very clean. Customer service is wonderful! Overall loved it!

There's no way to have guessed that the pizza place closest to our hotel would be such a hit. \n\nIt's a cute spot with a few tables for dining. The service is very New York (take with that what yo…

Came twice in 3 days, mid day and midnight; good both times. Ask for it extra crispy. Quick service . Chill atmosphere.

Fantastic pizza and quick service. Get the margherita and garlic knots. I wasn't really looking for pizza to live, but ended up going twice cause it was so good. Some tables and a bar to stand and …

Some of the best pizza I've ever had - and I LOVE pizza. Tried the buffalo chicken & pepperoni pan pizza - both were incredible. Everyone was kind. Very clean.

Best pizza I had on my trip to New York City. \nService was incredible and the staff was constantly keeping the restaurant clean. \nThis will definitely be a constant stopping point for me on futur…

their vodka pizza is amazing. This place is really good give it a try. service is exceptional

Pizza looked amazing, but I really just drank a couple beers while my wife was getting Idina's signature on her playbill. beer offerings were great!

Was looking for a pizza place. This pizza was amazingly wonderfully good! Warm place only negative no bathrooms. Had to go to krispy crème and buy a donut to go to bathroom.

Was looking for a pizza place. This pizza was amazingly wonderfully good! Warm place only negative no bathrooms. Had to go to krispy crème and buy a donut to go to bathroom.

Went with my daughter when in nyc. Lots of choices of great pizza. Sauce and cheese were delicious! Great service and good food quickly! Had Sicilian, pepperoni and buffalo chicken!

Went with my daughter when in nyc. Lots of choices of great pizza. sauce and cheese were delicious! Great service and good food quickly! Had Sicilian, pepperoni and buffalo chicken!

Went with my daughter when in nyc. Lots of choices of great pizza. Sauce and cheese were delicious! Great service and good food quickly! Had Sicilian, pepperoni and buffalo chicken!

Went with my daughter when in nyc. Lots of choices of great pizza. Sauce and cheese were delicious! Great service and good food quickly! Had Sicilian, pepperoni and buffalo chicken!

Went with my daughter when in nyc. Lots of choices of great pizza. sauce and cheese were delicious! Great service and good food quickly! Had Sicilian, pepperoni and buffalo chicken!

We ordered a whole pie between 4 of us. It was very busy but we waited about 10 minutes. The pizza was great and a good price/size.

Excellent Pizza, freshly prepared always delicious! Friendly staff. Hubby recommends the pepperoni & sausage and I love the cheese pizza, garlic knots are amazing

Great, hot and fast pizza! We had 5 different types and we loved them all! The staff was very friendly and held a seat for our little group. Was exactly what we were looking for!

Excellent gluten free pizza. The best I've tasted in New York this week. The sauce was tasty as well as the toppings. And it even came with a pizza cutter. Would definitely recommend.

This is one of the best pizzas I have ever eaten!!! If you are looking for awesome New York style pizza, this is your place. Friendly staff , amazing customer service, great atmosphere. This will b…

yaumaris aguiar

I absolutely loved Carnegie Pizza in NYC. The menu was a full display of different pizzas, which made it fun to choose. There were four of us and we all ordered different slices every one was delicious and perfectly cooked. They also have a great selection of drinks, including sodas as well as beer and wine, which was a nice bonus. The customer service was friendly and knowledgeable, and they were happy to explain the options. The environment was clean, though small. The only downside is the seating. There are only about three tables, so it was difficult to sit down during a busy time. Thankfully, someone was kind enough to let us share their table. Overall, great pizza, great service, and solid options

Pratik Bhatt

was really good — fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cheesy! 🍕 Carnegie Pizza is just about a 5-minute walk from Times Square, making it a convenient stop if you’re exploring the area. They also have a couple of vegetarian options, which is great to see. Bonus tip: if you pay in cash, they offer a 3.7% discount. Overall, a solid spot for a quick and tasty New York slice!

Essi

We tasted four different pizzas (both vegetarian and meat pizzas). Pizzas were ok, though the crust was a bit too crispy for our liking. They have huge variety of pizzas, also vegetarian options! While it wasn't the best pizza we've had in NYC, it's good quick option if you're in the area. The service was friendly, but the dining area (the tables and chairs) could have been a bit cleaner. We could still come back again if we would be nearby and need quickly something to eat!

+2

John Doe

This is a solid, by-the-slice pizza joint positioned nicely in Times Square! They have a solid array of pizzas considering the size of the restaurant, and I loved their selection of drinks, which included large-sized ("tall boys") adult beverages like White Claws.

+2

I absolutely loved Carnegie Pizza in NYC. The menu was a full display of different pizzas, which made it fun to choose. There were four of us and we all ordered different slices every one was delicio…

I absolutely loved Carnegie pizza in NYC. The menu was a full display of different pizzas, which made it fun to choose. There were four of us and we all ordered different slices every one was delic…

Ehh... no. \n\nThe slice I.grabbed from here had the most flavorless sauce and a mediocre-tasting crust. The only promising thing was the amount of cheese.\n\nI would like to think that I simply ha…

Joe's pizza wait was way too long even at 12am. Hubby did not want to wait so we went to try this place. Crust was thin good texture and tomato sauce flavor was good. But mushroom slice was a lil t…

I absolutely loved Carnegie Pizza in NYC. The menu was a full display of different pizzas, which made it fun to choose. There were four of us and we all ordered different slices every one was delicio…

I absolutely loved Carnegie pizza in NYC. The menu was a full display of different pizzas, which made it fun to choose. There were four of us and we all ordered different slices every one was delic…

Lots of variety, great pizza! Me and my 3 Friends shared a margarita and each slice was a great amount for a quick dinner. We came back the second night after a broadway show, which meant it was …

Pizza was great, have variaty and good prices! There was a long line but serve rapidly. You can eat inside if you have lucky or you can wait when the people leave to take their seat because its a s…

Needed a small, cheap dinner on this particular day and chose Carnegie Pizza following reviews on Trustpilot. I chose the Sicilian pizza slice, which was crispy and hot, but not very tasty. I prefe…

Good pizza and garlic knots. Staffs are not welcoming and not friendly 😕. They must definitely be more welcoming and greet customers. I was waiting to order and the staff kept taking orders from other customers who came after me 👎.

Mark Annese

Time Square tourist trap Thought id try and live around Time Square Checked the reviews and Carnigie had some decent scores. It was late night so no tables available. Choose the mushroom slice. Solid charred under carriage, nice and crispy and hot. Flavour was good. Overall good, but not great. Decent slice for the location. 3.5/5

Pizza was pretty okay service was nice and ambiance was what's expected from a NYC pizza places

$13 for 2 slices. Get your backside to 2 bros pizza. Tastes almost like for like and 2 slices and a soda for $4 restaurant immaculately clean inside but really not worth the money

Bland tasting pizza, crust not thin enough nor crunchy enough, sauce not enough flavor, it can also use a tiny bit more salt.