Caleb Warn

The Pony Bar, although a little pricey has a great atmosphere and the bartender was very sweet and attentive. Great place to have a few drinks and catch a game while in the city.

Erika Schmidt

A cool neighborhood beer house with a relaxed vibe and a staff that hustles. Frani and Sara know how to lock it down as they keep up with conversation and orders. If you're looking to try a wide variety of beers this is your place, but go in without wanting something specific because they rotate them frequently. Also, they have a frozen margarita that is dangerously good. The nachos with pulled pork were the best out of the pretzels and two types of wings, but all delicious. I'm from out of town, but I will be back to this spot!

Mark Leverone

Top notch. Was quiet when I arrived early but very busy by the time I left. Fran and Sara did an awesome job keeping up with the flow. Tacos were tasty.

+2

Kyuwon Lee

It's a neighborhood beer house with a laid-back atmosphere and friendly staffs. But their selection of beer is totally bold and cutting-edge. For my first visit, the bartender recommended me the DDH IPA from Interboro saying that it's his favorite and I liked it very much as well. High-speed wifi, clean toilet, and well-managed hall. Must be run by a person who knows the business.

+2

Adina Klein

It’s a nice local dive. No bells or whistles, but friendly staff and good beer.

Lydia Birnbaum

Cute bar that’s great for sitting for a long time and having drinks. They do have food options, but nothing spectacular. Drinks are good but a bit pricey given the fact that it’s a pretty casual bar, I would more so expect those prices from a cocktail lounge. My only big complaint is that the bartender was very chatty with other guests and multiple times I had to wait 5+ minutes for her to come over because she was just chatting with the guests, not even serving them drinks. This happened to my friends as well. It was a little frustrating because she definitely saw me waiting both times and just resumed her conversation

Andrew Kanouse

Pretty straight-forward pub in a super convenient location. Service was nice and there was a good amount of options. I didn't realize that the two TVs had different options, so be aware of that (only because I wish I had ordered something from the second TV). Prices were super reasonable. And bar seating was nice with tons of options.

Rick Bame

Cool little hangout. I had to see what the founders hangout was all about. Nice beer selection. Pricey, but it’s…New York. 5/21/21

+7

Nick Felker

The place is called "Pony" bar but I didn't quite get the theme. The theme seemed to be the bar itself. I got a beer and stood next to a barrel underneath a canoe. They didn't have a seat for me, which I guess was fine. They have a reasonable selection of items on tap and a t-shirt if you drink more than a hundred beers.

James

Beer is good, service is nice, customer base is a bunch of hipster wannabe transplants. Will not return