Darlo

Tried 8 of the highest rated pizza places south of Central Park, and this place ranked 3rd. I'm not knocking it. Top 3 is great when you're only trying pizza spots 4.8 stars or higher. The Burraprosciutto is fantastic. Would get it again!

Ashley Barbosa

We tried 4 pizza places so far and this was BY FAR the best and the staff is so friendly. It’s a 30 minute walk from our hotel but we don’t care, we’ll be back for more before we leave!!

+3

Rumpelstiltskin

Sweet spot for the adventurous ones! As the name suggests, this is not a place for regular pizza but for inventive flavors and fried spaghetti. Yup… FRIED SPAGHETTI! Quick tip: A ball of burrata is cheaper here than at the grocery store so do yourself a favor and take one home. Staff is really nice. Place is nicely decorated and is perfect for single-slice-stand-up dining. No chairs inside. We recommend the Cacio e Pepe fried noodles.

+1

Delicious. The triangle slice was super crispy, you can hold it parallel to the ground. They had veggie in and vegan squares. The veggie square was full of in taste and filling mm

Delicious. The triangle slice was super crispy, you can hold it parallel to the ground. They had veggie in and vegan squares. The veggie square was full of in taste and filling mm

The ultimate pizza experience in the city awaits you! I love that. The staff are really friendly

The ultimate pizza experience in the city awaits you! I love that. The staff are really friendly

ive had the caciao e pepe before and its great. they have beautiful pizzas you wont see anywhere. never have to wait in line and excellent service

Yum! Very nice place and cool atmosphere. Nice workers. A great area too so nice! I would recommend to others

Awesome pizza, and the chicken vodka brioche is insane! Nutella pizza is a great finish!

After seeing this pop up on TikTok and instagram for years, decided to give it a shot. The garlic bites were made from amazing bread and packed with flavor, but the fried penne vodka was clearly th…

The food is great and I love the ambience! Great vibes and service, especially Rocky. The pepperoni was great and very fresh, definitely recommend.

Delicious pizzas! Great sauces and fresh ingredients, crispy crust but thick slice. We had the margherita, veggie and meat pizzas. Want to try prosciutto burrata next.

Great environment and awesome staff! The pizza hot and looked delicious, if I lived closer it would definitely be a regular spot for me!

Great environment and awesome staff! The pizza hot and looked delicious, if I lived closer it would definitely be a regular spot for me!

Great environment and awesome staff! The pizza hot and looked delicious, if I lived closer it would definitely be a regular spot for me!

Great environment and awesome staff! The pizza hot and looked delicious, if I lived closer it would definitely be a regular spot for me!

Fresh, crispy and delicious pizza! We stopped here in the Essex St Market and the pizza was divine. We treated ourselves to the Nutella Pizza… and, wow. Taste explosion! It was divine!

Fresh, crispy and delicious pizza! We stopped here in the Essex St Market and the pizza was divine. We treated ourselves to the Nutella pizza… and, wow. Taste explosion! It was divine!

Truly unregular pizza. You won't find nothing like that anywhere in the city. Come here for a a good and irregular time!!

Truly unregular pizza. You won't find nothing like that anywhere in the city. Come here for a a good and irregular time!!

What an incredible place! Not only does all the pizza look incredible, they have amazing deals and the atmosphere is incredible. We got the burrata prosciutto and grandma peppina pizzas, they were …

So yummy. Would recommend the garlic bites especially. The staff was super nice as well. The pizza boxes are also soo cute.

Amazing pizza! I love the vegan pizza and appreciate all of the variations. The staff is always extremely nice and welcoming.

It's SUPER cute and SUPER friendly with great music. You can have classics or modern takes on NY pizza. If in NYC It's a must try!!

Good food, fast and good price. Good to take away. Place is small but comfy . The grandma peppina is delicious. Gentily staff

Good Pizza styles and Good lunch deal! The location is nice and clean! The service is so quick I will come back for sure!!!

Very good pizza! A variety of choices, a bit expensive but somehow worth it. Staff is friendly, and the Nutella pizza is real good.

1. I haven't had a meatball and sauce this delicious since my Italian grandmother was alive - and I've eaten at all the premium Italian spots in the city - Rao's, Emilio's Ballato, Carbone, Scalina…

Amazing crust, amazing flavors, just a little burnt bud in the right ways. I paid $11.26 for this prime rib pizza including tip.

Yummy Toyama Eats

Crust is so crispy good! Tomato sauce is well flavored and FIRE! Love it!

+6

Isabella Grandic

Needed more cheese. Or a more interesting sauce. Unless you got a bite of burrata, it was a bit bland

+1

SK Yeshwin

Me and my wife had one unregular mushroom slice and we both loved it! We just wanted to try since it was the 1st time, but we’ll be back soon!

Sanchita Ochani

The pizz options are so unique and although I'm generally not a big fan of the square pizzas, I liked these. They are also very generous with the toppings. The proscuitto burrata was my fav! I do think that the quantity of sauce is a bit much, some bites are just an excess of tomato in your mouth.

Aлеksanдp Han

grandma and pepperoni slices were great, not the best though. super tiny spot, really only for 'to-go'.

Nuwanthi Perera Whiteley

It's not a big restaurant where you can sit and eat, but we all liked their pizzas. The lady there explained to the while crowd what pizzas they had there at that time because she realized people were finding it hard to recognize them all, which was nice of her. If you're going with a family with kids, yiull have to do take out, because there's no place to sit. We were 3 people, so we stood and ate there inside the place (they have a small counter to place the food while you stand and eat). I could say with no doubt, the left over re-heated pizza were still good, the next day.

+1

Terrible service-unhelpful staff who act like they are doing you a favor taking your order

Terrible service-unhelpful staff who act like they are doing you a favor taking your order

Hmmm...I don't know if something's wrong with me or with the laws of dough physics, but this pizza experience left me questioning reality.\n\nI ordered a vegetarian Stromboli and a vegan slice -- E…

After experiencing a date night out at the Chelsea Film Festival at the nearby Regal Theatre, we conveniently came across this place and asked for Vegetarian options.\nGuys working that night were …

A modern take on the square Sicilian pizza. Excellent flavor. Small shop - no seating. Average service. Good value. I had a "Diavolona" - pepperoni, mozzarella, tomato sauce & hot honey, $5.…

Unregular Pizza was tasty when it first opened two years ago. Today my Grand Peppina square was uneven and ordinary. prices shot up recently which makes it expensive. Service was attentive.

This spot is brand new, open less than two weeks and you should go there soon! The pizza is excellent - nice bite to the sauce and the burrata (messy and tasty) is something you don't normally fi…

Ryan Tammaro

Very crowded inside with limited spots to eat The Meat Lovers slice was fine but was kind of soggy but the garlic knot pieces were solid. Overall it was overpriced for what you get

H

The pizza variety was great and toppings were plentiful, yet somehow the pizza was still bland. There was almost no cheese and vodka sauce on/in the fired pasta ball. And all the food we bought, they only gave us 1 napkin for 2 people. Which we both put our own order in but paid together, so they knew we were together and would need more than 1 napkin.

Joel Roberts

The presentation of the pizza was stunning - Perfect for social media influencers. However, the flavors were pretty one note. I was hoping the flavors would be outstanding, but in all honesty, I’ve had more enjoyable slices at $2 slice stores. The pizza and fried pasta was fine, but it wasn’t amazing, as I really hoped it would be after hearing all of the hype. For the price, I was disappointed. Maybe it was an off day? Overall, prettier than it was tasty.

This review is strictly for their vegan slice - there are two options, one that was a margherita and a "veggie fiesta" which was essentially a vegetable pizza. While most vegans do enjoy vegetables…

This review is strictly for their vegan slice - there are two options, one that was a margherita and a "veggie fiesta" which was essentially a vegetable pizza. While most vegans do enjoy vegetab…

This review is strictly for their vegan slice - there are two options, one that was a margherita and a "veggie fiesta" which was essentially a vegetable pizza. While most vegans do enjoy vegetables…

Feb 19,2026, went to try their Roman-Style pizza since I was in the area prior to attending the Winter Film Festival and to my surprise was not impressed at all. I had like a veg Roman-Style pizza and the sauce was tasteless. Will not be back. The garlic square bread was not properly seasoned .Feb 19,2026, went to try their pizza since I was in the area prior to attending the Winter Film Festival and to my surprise was not impressed at all. I had like a veg Sicilian pizza and the sauce was tasteless. Will not be back. The garlic square bread was not properly seasoned . Also there is no seating and very narrow as well.

Ivy G

Gluten free is trash. I should have checked before I left, crust is soggy and undercooked. For the price point a complete waste. I’m sure their regular crust is fine. I continue the search for GOOD gluten free pizza. Don’t waste your time or money here. See doughy and raw par baked crust.