Brooklyn Joes

Judy Browne

Best pizza ever outside of NYC! This is my 3rd time ordering pizza and it's always perfect. I ate it in the car because I couldn't wait.

Mark Edge

5-25: Brighton Location. Today I had 2 slices of pepperoni which are cooled and reheated. From 3-5 they run a special of buy 1 slice get the second free. Excellent promotion to use up the pizza that was made and not sold before the dinner rush. It was good! 6.7 Then ordered a large plain pizza to go, which took about 10 minutes. The crust, the sauce, the hotness of the pie cooked my mouth, which was to be expected, since I must enjoy as many slices as possible before it gets cool. OUTSTANDING, crisp, texture, chewiness, sweetness to the sauce, and a quality mozzarella. Perfectly cooked, and friendly clean environment. Great Job staff!

Christina Zeng

Okay I was pretty skeptical at first. We ordered three pepperoni slices, one pepperoni Sicilian and a plain Sicilian and it came out to $27 and I was not happy with the price. However the pizza was pretty damn good so I changed my mind and decided it's worth it! Also I didn't have any issues with customer service as other reviewers noted, they seemed pretty friendly to me! I grew up in Brooklyn but live in Binghamton now. I've been looking for a good Sicilian slice for years. I haven't had one in a while so my memory might be off, but in my opinion this is legit and it hit the spot!!! Also the slices were HUGE. The picture is of the pepperoni Sicilian and even that was quite big but the cheese Sicilian was even bigger... It didn't look that big through the glass so just keep that in mind! They're gigantic!!! Also I liked that the pepperoni sicilian wasn't just a cheese slice with some pepperoni on top. Even the bites without pepperoni had some good pepperoni flavor. The cheese slice was really good too though. I tried a bite of the triangle slices and it was also delicious. Super-thin crust for triangles, super puffy for squares!!! As they should be!! If I didn't live 2.5 hours away I would definitely come back all the time.

Black Butterfly

First the positive. They have buy one get one free slices between 3pm and 5pm. They also offer a variety. Now. The cheese slices looked like they were sitting for a few hours. I asked. One employee stated, yeah they've been sitting for a while. Anything over 2 toppings were considered specialty pizza and were over $6 per slice. So besides the old cheese slices, they only provided 2 toppings on the rest. I got 3 slices and so 3 slices were free. That's 6 slices of pizza for a little over 20 bucks. That's crazy. I get a whole 18 inch cheese pizza (16 slices) from Pizza Stop, which is delicious BTW. And, the only reason I paid for it is because I ordered it. This was the last time tho. It doesn't even taste like it came from Brooklyn or NYC for that matter.

Kien Lam

We were hankering for some New York style pizza, and Joe's didn't quite hit the spot. The crust is a but, um, floppy. Oh, the double-thick stuffed pizza *is * quite impressive -- it is h e a v y ! It might to TOO heavy. LOL.

Ashley Jean

I got the stuffed pizza and 12 garlic wings crispy. A few things I’d note is that it’s not a stuffed crust, it’s just a stuffed pizza. In fact the crust was just filled with kind of uncooked dough, kind of disappointing. The pizza itself was super good where it was stuffed at least. The wings I got extra crispy garlic. I wouldn’t recommend it, as it was kind of flavorless. Good thing I got a side of the barbecue sauce, because the wings were kind of bland. They did have garlic on top and some oil on the bottom but it just wasn’t cohesive. I ordered through Uber eats because I had a $35 off coupon. With the $35 off and $10 to the driver the total came to $56. I don’t think this was worth that price normally, let alone without the coupon the order would have been almost $100. That’s nuts. I prob won’t go here again, it was good but for half the price I can go to little Venice and get the best pizza and wings in Rochester. I just really wanted a stuffed crust. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Peter Graham

I would have liked this pizza place better if I was not charged over $20 for 3 slices of pizza. The pizza does not have the same taste as true Brooklyn pizza and was overcooked with individual slices sitting for much time before serving. I wish I could write a better review but this place was definitely not worth $20 bucks for 3 slices.

Jeff

Honestly, the pizza here is really good! BUT THEY'RE SO OVERPRICED! I came in at 2pm and got 2 slices and a coke and this man said $18.39! Granted, I'm the one that paid for it because I was hungry and in the mood for pizza...but THIS PLACE IS NOT WORTH THE MONEY!

Heidi Henrichs

I was so utterly disappointed in their "stuffed" pizza. We have been looking forward to trying this for months. First of all, there was a severe lack of toppings on the Brooklyn Bomber stuffed pizza. They were sparse. The pizza itself was so flat, despite it being described as literally two pizzas. The pizza was way too thin to be even closely worth the price. The amount of pure crust on this was incredible- I would say that the rolled up crust was literally almost 30-40% of the pizza we received. I have some hope that perhaps ours was made by an angry employee or something- hopefully not their typical presentation. When picking it up, the employee was basically complaining about the time it takes to make this pizza/ the hassle of it. I truly hope that was just one sour employee because if it truly is an item that employees don't take pride in / want to present correctly, it really shouldn't be on the menu. Particularly as the pizza costs $45! We were extremely disappointed to say the least. The only silver lining being that the crust did have a decent flavor so at least the large "pizza bones" weren't horrible to take care.

Robert Knobel

My first step in, the smell was classic and inviting. I was excited to experience this place for the first time. I saw two gloomy workers who didn't seem to want to be there and one of them didn't even know the price of a slice, let alone any questions about their double layer Brooklyn Bomber pizza which I saw on the internet and drove 2 hours to try. The pizza, being nearly $50 was a huge disappointment. The crust was the majority of the slice and the toppings were skimpy. I tried to make some small talk about the big pizza, and the maker just frowned and said the pizza takes 45 minutes to make. I bet their normal pizzas are delicious and wish that was my first experience with them. They should just remove this double layer pizza if they hate making them so much and make them sub par.