Anji E

OMG the food was delicious went for my birthday during dining week this week would definitely recommend this restaurant. Had the Little Italy with the mini antipasto with Italian dressing. Three course meal for $35.00.

Barbara Pine

My husband, Marty, and I went for dinner. We were seated immediately. Marty ordered mozzarella sticks for an appetizer with lasagna and coffee. I ordered a small Caesar salad, a small pizza with onions, green peppers and tomato and a diet Pepsi. Garlic knots arrived with our drinks. Our appetizers shortly after. The knots and mozzarella sticks were delicious. I liked the fact that the lettuce in the salad was chopped into smaller pieces and the dressing tasted homemade. Marty's lasagna was a good sized square and was made with meatballs. My pizza was their thin crust and cooked to perfection. Our waitress was attentive. My only complaint was while the waitress refilled my soda, she didn't ask Marty if he wanted a coffee refill. Price was reasonable. Would definitely eat here again.

+2

Amber Marie

So delicious! The red sauce was on point, the RATIOS of my pepperoni slice were perfection. This spot definitely hit the spot for my NY pizza cravings. The staff was awesome, hard working, attentive and helpful. Definitely recommend this joint.

Erica Slater

Thank you Sal's! After a day of canoeing on beaver lake we definitely worked up an appetite. We have heard great things about the food and pizza so decided to give them a try. We are a family of 6 so we never know if there will be accomodations for our party size. We got there around 3:30 and got greeted and sat right away. It was only the bar tender but we didn't mind this at all. She got our drink order right away and did a fantastic job making my Manhattan. We didn't realize that there was a different menu for lunch and dinner so when we started reading the menu we were surprised that we couldn't find some of the items we heard about. After a quick explanation from the server and because it was so close to their dinner hour the staff allowed us to order off the dinner menu. We were so grateful for this because the food we ordered was exactly what we wanted. Everything was delicious and everyone was happy and satisfied. My favorites were the chicken wing pizza on the cauliflower crust, the pasta fagioil, and the lobster raviolis. But everything was great, service was excellent, and the kitchen staff gets 5 stars for accommodating us so graciously. Thank you.

+5

Isaiah Bishop

The pizza here is ALWAYS completely satisfying in every way. I go here weekly for lunch. Thursdays and Fridays they do specialty slices that are to die for. The Korean bbq, the buffalo Mac and cheese, or the sweet chili pizza that they use the chicken from char broiled wings on, are all outstanding, among the massive selection of other pizzas. Ive yet to eat in the restaurant, but if its as good as the pizza, I couldn't imagine its bad by any means. Great service. Amazing food. 👍

Ellie

i’ve been coming to sal’s for years, and the food has always been great! i recently got the state fair penne and it was very good. however, the service can be quite slow.

Rachael Miller

Food was warm and hit the spot. We had this delivered and it took a while longer than they said it would. We tipped quite well for our food and that didn’t seem to get it there quick (which is why it got a four star). Otherwise, great pizza joint! Heard good things about their chicken riggies which I will try next time.

Beth

My group of friends ordered pizza and wings for game night last night. We got 2 large Pizzas and an order of their house wings. We dug right in and it was all sooo good. I'm not a huge wing person but they were delicious. Then we get a knock on the door and they came with a 2nd order of wings that we didn't even call about and they said "sorry we gave u the wrong wings, here's the right ones" . We didn't even notice we had the wrong wings nor did we call and complain so that was fantastic customer service. Edit: hubby and I went for our anniversary dinner, we arrived at 4:30pm it wasn't very busy and we ordered. I ordered the stuffed shells but switched the sauce to alfredo and when the food came out, it was just the shells with a crap ton of melted Mozzarella cheese. I asked the waitress and she says "yeh I told them..but they just drained the butter and sent it out.. " then after asking for to go containers she brought me a cup of alfredo sauce for my left overs... and said "sorry, that's the best I can do right now". We waited for what seemed like forever between each encounter with the server. She got busy around 530, but by then we were just waiting for the check and change etc. Their pizza and wings are great, but I don't recommend dining in.. finally left at 6:10pm. I'm a bit shocked that a place with amazing customer service previously, has now just brushed us off and decided to send out food they KNEW wasn't done right.

John Oliver

Sunday night order for the family. Large pepperoni and cheese. Wings and such. Wings were cooked so hard they were tough to eat but the sauce was good. Crazy part was the 4 cold slices of pizza in the box instead of the complete pie. Driver didn’t sneak it, grease marks on the paper proved that. They were quick to fix the issue…..by dropping off another 4 slices…..in the end we got what we paid for…..being in customer service myself, I try to up my apology game when the situation happens. Gotta keep that quality control in check if your gonna charge a premium

Lynn Fofi

Three things - told an hour for delivery-was over an hour and a half, asked if knots were included with riggies - told no so ordered four knots, paid extra for a Caesar salad and got a regular side salad, and knots did come with order so I didn’t need to place an extra order. Need to keep on top of this Sal - a little better customer service on the phone as well! I know the restaurant business is hard these days but attention to detail keeps people coming back!

Haven’t been to Sals in a while, the wife and I wanted to come in to sit at the bar and get food. It was amazing, as always but we were disappointed with a bartender. She’s never waited on us before, her name was Brooke. She was rude to us when we sat down, first thing that came out of her mouth was “What do you want?” Thought it was weird because usually when we come in, the service is great. It took her a while to get our order because she was standing in the corner on her phone. Dinner was good, the other bartenders checked in on us and were attentive and nice. When brooke gave us the check, she slammed it down and didn’t say a word. I overhead the couple sitting next to us saying the same thing, that she was rude. I don’t know if she is new but she needs more training on how to talk to people. Anyways, we will be back but hopefully a night she isn’t working.

C rose

They had a deal pasta chicken and pizza 30 something dollars sounded great. The pasta was cold and dry with no flavor. The chicken was dry with the breading all off it. Do not recommend.

Paul Roosevelt

The order was a medium pizza, an order of wings and a salad. The total was $65. It was over 30 minutes late. The pizza was cold. And it cost $65. I like their food but I will never order from them again. Absolutely ridiculous. I know I'm old and used to pay $30 for the same thing, but if you're going to charge me for steak and lobster, make sure it's hot and on time.