Evon Shay

Really tasty slices!! Loved the service, there was abundant seating on a weekday night, and the Italian music was a great touch to the atmosphere, highly recommend and I will be back to try their full pies

Laura Jorgensen

So good I came back twice in three days. The buffalo chicken is especially ridiculously delicious!

Emily McWilliams

Really friendly people & the flavorful pepperoni had an excellent crispetycrunchety bottom (a perfectly cromulent word and I’m talking NO sagging) with still a nice bready end crust. I’ll be happy to pay 4.50 a slice again! Oh and a good amount of indoor seating.

Mukarram Shahzad

Best pizza in New York City 11/10 August 22: just came here again. The staff was very helpful with picking the right pizza. We ordered 3 grandpa pies, OMGZ phenomenal pizza. We ate some cold later, and it almost tasted even better lol Cant recommend enough. What an amazing spot

Alexis Eftink

A true hidden gem. Best pizza in NY. We love dropping in for a slice and we ended up ordering Joe and Sal’s for our casual rehearsal welcome party before our wedding. Everything was amazing and they even threw in extras. Their communication, kindness and of course the food, was above and beyond. Thank you Joe, Sal and your team for being the best!

Hannah Luree Odland

Okay. If you call to order, you might get put on hold - but it’s worth the wait. Joe & Sal’s is a small shop with big flavor. Some of the best, no-frills pizza I’ve ever had. The dough, cheese, flavors, quality and customer service are top tier. Will definitely return.

Fayvenn

Neighborhood gem ✨️ I have been coming to this place almost every week. Sometimes multiple times a week. It's my go-to pizza spot. I have introduced 3 people to this place and they are all hooked so it is a tried, tested, and proven best pizza spot in Crown Heights. My #1 go-to is the La-Burrata pie. Thin crust, fresh burrata cheese, fresh basil, and tomato... it all just melts in your mouth. Next, is the Nonna pizza if you're into Sicilian style. Yum! My tip is to get a full pie instead of slices because A) it will be freshly baked. B) much cheaper that way. Their pasta is also really good. The penne alla pesto and fettuccine alfredo are what I have tried so far. I will update when I try more. This place has history and a reputation as a solid pizza joint. Dave Portnoy, the pizza guru, gave this place an 8.1. But I round that up and give it a solid 9. There's enough seating area and Tiffany lamps for added aesthetics and a vintage feel. They also have a memory wall with pictures and notes of people who have made memories in this place. And of course, the Godfather references and an Al Pacino portrait 😉

+5

Andrew Dabydeen

Very surprised and sad that I didn’t come here sooner! Tried their Sicilian square and original slice and both were excellent. This is a quality Brooklyn pizza joint with the vibe that seems to be missing from a lot of places. The owners were very friendly and everyone seemed to be having a good time. Definitely looking forward to my next time here.

Es Thompson

Woooowwwww! I went on a Thursday afternoon to grab slices and dessert for my friend and I. Everything was amazing! The pesto burrata was so flavorful and creamy. The everything seasoning on the pepperoni had me loving the crust just as much as the rest of the pie. Not sure what the last one is called but I think it had like sesame seasoning on the crust and it was delicious! Service here was also excellent. Everyone was friendly and helpful with suggestions. I think one of the owners, Joe, was at the counter and he was very sweet. I thought the prices for the specialty slices were a bit high, $6.50, but after eating, I felt they were well worth the price. Highly recommend you try this place for good pizza with good quality ingredients and flavor.

Alan Varghese

Excellent pizza with a thin flavorful crust (medium crisp and great chew) with great sauce and cheese. One of the best slices I have had (I got the pepperoni). They give a big discount if you use cash. Prices are $3-$5 ish mostly and slices sizes are regular. They have tons of pizza options by slice (10+, including deep dish), pasta, desserts, salads etc. Seating for about 6-8 people is available inside the store.

+7

Dee Dee

THE FOOD IS HORRIBLE, IMO. I ordered spaghetti meatballs and baked ziti. Both ended up in the trash. I got 3 big meatballs, one of which was burned and not edible, and a box of pasta. I was not able to digest it. Idk what they used to cook it but it had me extremely bloated after 2 bites. I saved the baked ziti for a different day because I had to recook it. On top looked backed, but after I peeled the first layer back, NOTHING ABOUT IT WAS BAKED, more like boiled. I eventually added my own sauce and some spices to it, it was barely edible but I ended up throwing half of it away. I wasted $28 for the food here. Idk about their pizza but their food is not good. Also wait times are LONG!

Ze

I ordered pizza for family dinner through Slice around 6:40pm on Dec 31st. The app said the estimated delivery time was around 8pm. By 8pm, the status only changed to out for delivery. We waited and waited, and never saw the pizza arrived the whole night. The status got updated to order completed at 9:30pm. We tried to call the place multiple times, but never got picked up. I bet the pizza is delicious, but DO NOT ORDER DELIVERY from them.