Johnnie's Pier 31

Lauren Varno

My family and I came here for dinner and sat outside. From the minute we walked in we were greeted with a smile, seated promptly by Ellen and orders taken quickly as well. The food was absolutely delicious with generous proportions. But what really stood out for us was the service. The waitress was the best we've ever had. Every time our drinks got low she filled them up, whenever the plates were clean she took them, she stopped by to make sure we were satisfied throughout the meal. I don't remember her name but she is the reason we will be returning.

Patrick Wills

Great little place right in Oneida Lake. Been past it a ton if times and finally dropped in for dinner. Has a diner feel but the menu is fine dining. Totally casual but entrees are top shelf. Great dinner: a lot of seafood selections along with steak, pastas, great desserts! Will definitely be back 👍.

Sara Tuthill

Great place! Amazing waitresses and staff. The food was great, we ordered a variety from wings to haddock and prime rib. We also ordered drinks and they were great. Family friendly for our 3 year old. Overall a great experience and we will definitely be going back soon!

Lars Hansen

Great seafood place. We had the Haddock in various styles and New England Clam Chowder. Both VERY tasty. We sat outside on a nice deck with umbrellas and a lake view. Our waitress was fantastic

Linda Jekel

We came into the bar. We ordered two Margaritas. John made them on the bar in front off us. Delicious. We went out to the deck. We had a fabulous meal. Great drinks, great service, & great view of Oneida Lake! I give this place 5 Stars

Milton Cooper

Have been here before. It was amazing the last time. Yes it was 8 years ago when we bought our home on Lakeshore rd cicero. It is our 34 year anniversary so we wanted to go back. Very busy place on a Friday night. We expected a little wait,and it was to be expected. Our server was quite older but finally greated us and took our drink orders. Then we ordered our appetizers which was the fried calamari. $16.95. Really expensive but hoping it is worth it. Ordered our meals and a side salad aswell. The calamari finally came out and it was crispy. A tad to much but we still ate it. Just a little upset because or the price and the portion size was really small. My wife ordered the fish sandwich and fries and her side salad that was $6.95 aswell. My Daughter ordered the fried purch sandwich and a side salad. Then I ordered the fried purch Dinned with fries and coleslaw slaw,also with a side salad. Let me just say the 3 small side salads cost us just under $20 let me be honest, they were freaking tiny. The purch looked like it was a kid chicken tender meal. The food was okay but my complaint is $130.00 + a $20 tip. $150.00 for that was unbelievably over priced and we weren't satisfied. We are sorry to say we would have been happier at Dennys. I also would like to add i am a retired chef of 29 years. I understand the kitchen and restaurant more then most people would ever know. I'm not bashing this place, infact I wish this best for it. I'm just a very honest person. Just was not worth it for us.

rebecca brown

Nice spot near the lake...prime rib overcooked but w good flavor..mashed potatoes are instant. Has deck seating also. Overpriced for quality of food.. extra for salad w dinner. Friendly staff

Steve Sheehan

First of all our waitress did a great job in taking care of us. My steak was medium to medium well, I ordered medium rare, she made that right. Steak was excellent. Was happy when we got the bill and the price was $6.00 more than menu price. I guess they have outdated menu’s. Not sure I would have got the steak for that much more!

Margaret Luttinger

Charming ...old school ...nothing "chain " about this place. Sit at the bar and see old photos of bygone years. Sweet. Casual. Proprietors were gracious and welcoming Gorgeous night to dine outside. View of lake - not on the lake.

Angela Cushing

Worst experience, never coming back, staff was not friendly. Salmon was overcooked and perch basket very underdone

V Kelly

Based on all the great reviews - we decided to try the restaurant. It was Saturday night and we ordered mixed cocktails which were good. The waitress very nice and other waitresses were extremely dedicated to their clientele- they truly cared. We ordered shrimp cocktail - they were 5 butterfly that were ok but not large in size. My husband and I both ordered prime rib king/queen cut. I have never sent a meal back so this was my first time. There was no size difference between king/queen cut, 1/2 inch thick with no seasonings and tasted like old steak. We asked for horseradish and received a dish of sour cream with a hint of horseradish. I appreciate reviews and always refer to them before trying anything new - the wait staff were top notch and could go up against the best of the best but the food quality did not match.