Anthony Pastecchi

What an amazing experience - authentic - amazing dishes including the eggplant parm and meatballs - pizza was refreshing and not heavy - staff was incredible and attentive. Highly recommend to anyone in NYC.

Nick J

Incredible experience! The white pizza with buffalo mozzarella, ricotta cheese, jalapeños, bruschetta, and hot honey sauce was absolutely delicious & perfectly balanced flavors with just the right kick. Sat at the bar, and Otman, the bartender, was phenomenal and super knowledgeable. Excellent service and atmosphere. Highly recommend!

Rylan Gordon

Finding a restaurant in NYC that can accommodate a group of 12 and is reasonably priced can be a challenge, but San Matteo was the perfect spot for our birthday dinner. The service was exceptional—attentive, friendly, and welcoming. We were seated upstairs, where the atmosphere was relaxed, avoiding the typical moodiness you get at other restaurants. We tried both the pasta and pizza specials of the night, and they were outstanding—flavorful, fresh, and of high quality. I highly recommend San Matteo for anyone looking for great food and a comfortable, inviting setting.

Connie Kwok

Always a 5 start experience here at the bar or seated in the restaurant, alone, on a date or with a group. We celebrated a ladies night reunion here, and had exceptional, attentive service to make sure we left on time for our show. It was early so we enjoyed a spot to the right of the restaurant enjoying plenty of windows. Lots of space, a welcoming and rustic atmosphere. There is a broad menu of cocktails, legit Italian pizza and food, esp with the specials! It was very hard to choose! For 6 people, we enjoyed 4 pizzas, a pasta, a couple of salads. We also had the brussel sprouts (decent, but we didn't realize they were roasted!). Food was served hot the waitstaff is fast with requests. Make a reservation, enjoy the authentic Italian pizza! We'll be back!!

+3

Shari Kia

Amazing pizza crust and friendly staffs! Definitely go back here and try other pizza choices the have! Prices are not cheap but not very unfair! Tiramisu and coffee were decent but not exceptional! The only point to improve is the sanity of the restroom as they only have one restroom and it wasn’t clean when I dined over there!

+2

Luis A

Simply amazing amazing food. The pizzas are the best high quality “fancy style” pizzas in NYC! The crust is nice and crunchy and has little burned tips just amazing. They have a wide selection of delicious apps and drink/wine selections. The staff are friendly attentive and super amazing. I ended up ordering delivery a week later! Highly recommended.

+13

Phillip Burmester

We looked a lot for a great pizza 🍕 place and found San Matteo. The place is amazing 😍 and would recommend to reserve a table ahead of your visit. The quality of ingredients is amazing. The appetizer with the ham, buffalo, tomatoes and Rucola was insane and already enough. We had one extra pizza 🍕. It was great but we had better ones I have to say but still high level of quality! Definitely a place to visit.

Ed Racho

Nice quaint little spot. Food was great! Service was fantastic! Our server, Dexter ( I really hope that’s correct ) was not only polite and pleasant, but extremely personable, witty, and charismatic. Not overbearing or pushy by any means. A++ service! Pizza was nice and light, ingredients were fresh! Our Arugula Salad was also very tasty and very fresh. I also enjoyed the spices on the calamari very much. Overall great experience and another part of what made our New York trip with our first born son a very memorable one! Many thanks!

The start of our meal here wasn’t great because we had a reservation but the restaurant overbooked by a ton. Waited a full half hour to be seated for our reservation, which was disappointing but the hostess was working hard to make things work for everyone! The food was incredible, we had the Ravioli (so good), the margarita pizza, and the Burrata & Prosciutto. The absolute best part of our experience here though was our sweet and fun waitress, Carmella! She was amazing!!

Ellen

Good brick oven Neapolitan style pizzas. I tried their white pizza special with sausage, ricotta, mozzarella and hot honey which was good as well as the classic margherita pizza. The porcini tagliatelle pasta was creamy and tasty as well. The servers were decent. There wasn't enough seating by the window so we had to sit on the high tops.

+7

Lisbeth Rodas Amaya

We stopped here during our road trip hoping for authentic Italian food. The food itself was genuinely good and tasted authentic, but unfortunately the overall experience was disappointing. The prices felt incredibly high for what was offered, and the service really affected the vibe. We felt unwelcome from the start—there was a passive-aggressive tone, and staff repeatedly hovered and checked over our shoulders. What made it more uncomfortable was noticing that an Italian family seated behind us received noticeably warmer and more attentive service, while our experience felt rushed and cold. Good food alone couldn’t make up for the lack of hospitality. If service had matched the quality of the food, this could have been a great stop.

Adele Freeman

Sad I have to do this. I love a Neapolitan-style pizza, and it was my go-to pizzeria, although I have to say I would usually order a take out. Last night I’ve ordered their porcini&truffle pizza, and I received a pizza with maybe 1 porcini overall. The thin slices of that poor one mushroom were spread over pizza, so I had maybe 4-5 slices of porcini on the WHOLE pizza. Totally not worth the money. Big disappointment for me, because I used to order at least twice a month from them.

Eddie Zhang

Never had a worse delivery pizza. Arrived cold fresh from the fridge. Didn’t give me the topping I asked. So clearly they didn’t even bother to throw my toppings onto the cold pizza. Maybe they ran out of sausages from last week to pair their one week old leftover cold pizza.