Menú
Donnelly's Public House
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Fairport

Donnelly's Public House

★★★★★ 4.6 · 102 reseñas

At Donnelly's Public House, we're all about good times and great tastes. Our neighborhood bar & grill is the perfect spot to unwind with friends and family, surrounded by the lively atmosphere of a classic pub. With 30+ taps rotating through local brews, you'll find the perfect p...

Donnelly's Public House

Pub · Fairport

4.6 · 927 ressenyes Google
donnelysph.com
Yelp 4.0 (164) TripAdvisor 4.3 (168)

Sobre Donnelly's Public House

At Donnelly's Public House, we're all about good times and great tastes. Our neighborhood bar & grill is the perfect spot to unwind with friends and family, surrounded by the lively atmosphere of a classic pub. With 30+ taps rotating through local brews, you'll find the perfect pint to pair with our...

At Donnelly's Public House, we're all about good times and great tastes. Our neighborhood bar & grill is the perfect spot to unwind with friends and family, surrounded by the lively atmosphere of a classic pub. With 30+ taps rotating through local brews, you'll find the perfect pint to pair with our delicious pub grub. We've got a loyal following because of our friendly service and generous portions - just ask our regulars about our famous burgers, or take a seat by the fireplace for an cozy night in.

Què diuen els clients de Donnelly's Public House

Donnelly's Public House is a popular, warm pub known for its friendly staff, extensive beer selection, and good pub food. Customers rave about the welcoming atmosphere and consistent quality. Some find the beer list heavy on IPAs.

Plats populars

Fried haddock beef bomber sandwich Build Your Own Burger Chicken wings pretzel mushrooms sandwich wings fish fry

Ideal per a

Parelles Famílies Grups Locals Informal

Tip: Don't miss the rotating specials. If you like wings, they are killer. For football season, they have a 10 for 10 special on Sundays for afternoon games (dine-in only).

Services

🌳 Terrasse 🅿️ Parking Accessible 🍽️ Déjeuner 🌙 Dîner Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy Trendy 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Què veure a prop

First Baptist Church of Fairport
Patrimoni
A 237m

First Baptist Church of Fairport

iglesia

Veure detalls
First Congregational Church of Fairport
Patrimoni
A 400m

First Congregational Church of Fairport

iglesia

Veure detalls
Potter Park
A 774m

Potter Park

parque

Veure detalls

Dades de Wikidata

Explora els voltants de Donnelly's Public House

Donnelly's Public House es troba a Fairport, envoltat de llocs d'interès cultural i històric. Aquests són alguns dels punts més destacats als voltants.

Patrimoni Històric

  • First Baptist Church of Fairport (A 237m) — church building in New York, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
  • First Congregational Church of Fairport (A 400m) — historic building in Fairport, New York, United States Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos

Parcs i Jardins

  • Potter Park (A 774m)

Dades de Wikidata

Preguntes freqüents sobre Donnelly's Public House

Donnelly's Public House es troba a 1 Water St, Fairport, NY 14450, Fairport.
A prop de Donnelly's Public House es troben llocs d'interès com First Baptist Church of Fairport, First Congregational Church of Fairport, Potter Park.
Donnelly's Public House ofereix cuina pub.
Donnelly's Public House té horari d'atenció. Consulta el perfil per horaris actualitzats.
Donnelly's Public House ofereix els serveis següents: menjar al local, per emportar.
Els plats més recomanats a Donnelly's Public House segons les opinions dels clients són: Fried haddock, beef bomber sandwich, Build Your Own Burger, Chicken wings, pretzel.
Donnelly's Public House és ideal per a parelles, famílies, grups, locals, informal.
Donnelly's Public House is a popular, warm pub known for its friendly staff, extensive beer selection, and good pub food. Customers rave about the welcoming atmosphere and consistent quality. Some find the beer list heavy on IPAs.
Don't miss the rotating specials. If you like wings, they are killer. For football season, they have a 10 for 10 special on Sundays for afternoon games (dine-in only).
927
Ressenyes

Opinions de Donnelly's Public House Fairport

4.6
927
5★
72%
4★
21%
3★
5%
2★
1%
1★
1%
Ressenyes (102)
P
Pamela Holmes

Fantastic bar & restaurant!! Loved the huge sandwiches; generous portions of everything. Relaxing atmosphere, good service, and fantastic food. It's definitely a place worth visiting again and again.

J
Jeff Allen

Great place for a quick meal of bar food. Our table had a BBQ and Rueben sandwich with a side of tots. Fair prices, good food, good service, good location.

G
Geoff

I have been frequenting Donnelly's for over a decade and the service and quality of food/beer have never diminished. A sign of a restaurant doing things right is when they retain staff long-term, and some of those at Donnnelly's have been there since I began going. I love that I can go here with friends, family and coworkers and everyone enjoys their experience and raves about the food.

S
Stu Shoots

Despite going out to eat ALL THE TIME, this is the first review I have written for a restaurant. My wife and I are very picky and have "cut" a majority of the places in the area due mostly to poor service. Donnelly's is the ONLY place we can count on consistently. Their terrific food is only topped by their terrific staff. You can eat a simple $7 dollar sandwich or, what I always recommend, order one of their "specials". Either way, you will leave satisfied and wanting more.

L
Lovely Rotten

Great food and friendly, cozy atmosphere. The staff were attentive and charming. Had the burger specials with the onion jam. Very delicious. Fries were awesome.

J
Jack Kreitzman

Great sandwich, beer, and atmosphere.

R
Richard Mietlicki

Great place a must to go check it out. Owner is on-site an serves tables to help out staff. All the staff that I met were incredible an helpful. Food was very good and cooked perfectly. It's a great reflection on the commitment of the owner to provide a great experience.

M
Marc Zicari

Great Beer Selection! Great Atmosphere! Great attitudes! I like the Steak Bomber, but Tom seems to come up with some really good nightly specials, too. The Beer Cheddar soup (when available) is always a hit as well.

K
Kathy Gehl

Great food! Very inviting, staff are quick and all were very welcoming! Fast service. Food was delicious, and the serving sizes were huge! Large selection of beers. A must hit when you are in the area.

A
Almighty Truth

Stumbled across this place on a buisness trip. Owner was working the dining floor.....very conscious on quality and his staff and very nice. Food was top notch. Will return next time I'm in town.

M
Matthew Vercant

Excellent local pub, great beer selection, love the new owners and the atmosphere. Open 7 days a week, unlike a pretty big chunk of Fairport eateries, so no wondering "if" I can grab a bite here. We're here all the time!

A
Anthony Mock

One of Rochesters gems. Always a great craft beer selection on tap. Supper solid regular menu however their specials are awesome and if they sound remotely good you'll be happy. Can't go wrong here.

H
Heather K The Traveling Mom

Jenna was an awesome server. She makes awesome Arnold Palmer's. Never had to ask for a drink. The food is high quality. They have a regular menu and a rotating menu giving the option of trying something new. Thank you Jenna for great service.

J
James Robb

Service was very nice and meals delivered quickly. Throughly enjoyed the homemade potato chips.

L
Lawrence Hand

Was in town over the holidays and stopped in to have a quick drink. The staff was very welcoming and friendly and the atmosphere was great.

d
d wurth

Love this place! Such a nice, friendly and laid back atmosphere and the food is always great. If you like beer on tap, the bar is an embarrassment of riches week in and week out - ever cycling through a dozen or so new micro brew selections. Stop in and check it out - it is the best unassuming little hole in the wall you're going to find for miles around! In the summer they put the canopy over the front sidewalk to add an open air option if you like and since it is on a lightly traffic'd side street near the canal it's a very comfortable outdoor vibe. Probably sounds like I'm the owner, but far from it - just trying to share a local gem.

D
Dan Buchholtz’s

The big smile at the door said enough. Open dining area with quaint booths didn’t feel crowded at all. Stephanie, our server was terrific and knew the beer selection very well. Food came quick and was really good! I’m particular about beef sandwiches, the French Dip was juicy even without the Au Jus. The pretzel was a perfect crispy salty snack, but the takeaway really is the help and smiles. Fantastic work Donnelley’s. Thank you!

m
mike Tumm

Great food great service and great specials !

D
D1am0nd

I love Donelly’s. I’ve been coming here for years. The food and service is always fantastic. They also have plenty of awesome craft beers on tap and the vibe is warm and comforting. I highly recommend!

r
racerpoet

If you go here, get the grilled wings! Pick your flavor, but make sure you get them grilled! Donnelly’s has some of the best wings I’ve had. I enjoy coming here late at night, getting some food, and then going on a walk on the canal afterwards. Great food. Perfect location close to the canal. Chill atmosphere.

E
Elizabeth

Always love coming to Donnelly's with the family. The food is always delicious and everyone is so nice. We regularly come back and enjoy our experience every time!

S
Steven Vandevander

Fantastic service and food! Annie was our server. She let us sample the soup and beer. The side order of Tot’s is huge! The grilled chicken sandwich and 🦬 chicken were both terrific! Very fast service and the food is a must try if you’re in town for lunch or dinner.

J
Jacob Foltz

Awesome food and atmosphere! We loved the homemade BBQ sauce and French fries (recommended getting the cheese with them)!! Shoutout to Steven for being an awesome waiter! Him and the staff were friendly and very personable.

K
Kaeri Carroll

Donnelly's is a classic Irish pub - friendly but low key, you can sit at the bar and chat or snag a table in the corner for privacy. The beer selection is excellent with a good rotation, and the food is also very good. This is my go-to place in Fairport!

L
Lisa Froble

Everything on the menu was amazing. We had a party of 17 outside. I don’t remember our waitresses name but she was very attentive and kind. The food was fresh and plentiful. They have a very good selection of IPA’s. We were all visiting from out of town and it was a perfect end to the weekend. Thank you!

M
Meghan Volker

This is my new favorite hot spot! Loving the new bartender/server Jordan! Wonderful company and his recommendations are always on point. We’ve been going here 2x/week since we met him. I really like the variety of food and drinks that are offered. The chicken Caesar wrap is so fresh and delicious. The best I’ve had!

K
Kerry Ideman (chasnfireflies)

A bustling little pub canalside. A crowd favorite for local residents and a great new place to check out if you are visiting or new in town. I have heard they have some great eats,(a hostess promptly offered to seat us) but, we did not order food. The bar was crowded, but not over crowded. Service was friendly, and quick. They have a nice outdoor patio with ample seating for food,drinks, and a view of the Erie Canal. My Corona with lime was the perfect end to my birthday. Enjoy!

N
Nigel Demers

I live in Ontario and make Donnelly's a staple stop when I drive through the Fairport area. Love this place, amazing owner, great staff, deliscious food, tons of tap choices and a stellar crowd.

A
Andrew “Spanky” Mencher

Everyone is very friendly. Food and drinks are great. It feels like a pub that if you are a regular, they will know your name and drink

N
Nicholas Daszkiewicz (Nick)

The owner and the bartender were incredibly friendly and helpful... We were "those guys" and tried to sneak in just before the kitchen closed... They scrambled and got us all in and made us some tasty fried food. They even stopped to made small talk. 10/10 would recommend

J
Jeremy Lloyd

Today was my first visit to DPH with a very large party of 13 people and the entire experience was absolutely unquestionably top notch! I have to first compliment our server because she was fantastic across the board with the huge order and then, props to the kitchen staff. I wish I went back to the kitchen to compliment them directly because it is extremely rare that an entire meal for 13 people can come out, perfectly timed, all warm and ready to eat all at once. That is an incredible feat and this entire staff @ DPH deserves nothing short of the highest praise out there. I will absolutely make this a regular spot now. Simply incredible.

M
Melinda Muth

This place holds a special place for me. It was where I met my husband for our first date. It's a great little place! The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars, is because of the fact I'm vegetarian and the options are okay but limited to a veggie burger, mozzarella sticks, quesadillas, sides, nachos and salads. The salads all have meat and I usually order the Asian Chicken salad and remove the chicken. It's delicious! They don't charge less if you ask for the meat to be left off, though. Which is okay, I give it to others dining with me. That's a me issue. So, I won't blame them.

L
Lauren Walravens

First time at Donnellys and we can’t wait to return! Ordered the Buffalo chicken sandwich and it was by far one of my favorites. My fiancé got the steak bomber and it was incredible! Best one he’s had. Great service and cozy atmosphere. Be back soon!

D
David Muth

My go to local pub. Good beer selection and food that far surpasses the typical bar offerings... The daily specials are usually unique and fantastic. Best wings in Rochester on my opinion. Great staff and the owner is usually in house serving food, cleaning tables and talking with his guests.

J
Jack Britton

I've been coming to Donnelly's since practically the day it opened years ago. The food is consistently fantastic, and the people are friendly. I LOVE THIS PLACE. I eat lunch here 2-3 times a week and dinner at least 1, sometimes more. The wings rock (get them hot and grilled). As a serious foodie (some might even say food snob) I cannot recommend this place enough. Yes it might be crowded sometimes, but that's just because people know good food and service when they see them.

K
Katelin Zalar

Today was my first experience at Donnelly's and I have to say, they delivered. I ordered a simple build your own burger and the meat tasted great, it was cooked exactly how I asked for it to be cooked and the toppings were fresh and delicious. I will be returning again for sure and highly recommend checking this wonderful establishment out! I know I wasn't disappointed at all.

R
Rob

Great place for lunch with excellent service and reasonably priced.

W
Warren McGrail

Places like this are what make Fairport such a friendly and inviting town. The beer selection A•, the food, and especially the staff are excellent

K
Kevin P

Great service, food and beers! The tap list is always solid. Actually, it’s the best in Rochester! The food is fantastic and the service is top notch. I am glad this spot is so close to home for me!

J
Julie Millar

Love this place. Rich, Lindsey, Annie and the rest of the staff all make you feel welcome and at home. The food comes out quick and hot. They have different specials each week, which never disappoint, and their Friday fish fry is delicious. Just don’t wait too long to go, because it does sell out sometimes. The outside space is nice in the summertime! I highly recommend Donnelly’s and love supporting local businesses.

J
Johnny Castillo Moore

Good food menu and selection of brews. The location is in a great area

R
Randy MacShara

Great food, and the service was excellent. First time trying Donnelly's, but I'll definitely be back. The Ed Baronowski sandwich was fantastic if you're looking for something a little different. My buddy got a Cajun chicken sandwich, and we both tried the chowder. All very good. For family members, we picked up wings and the French dip, which were also excellent. The service was seamless, and our food arrived promptly. Highly recommended.

D
Danielle Bender

Was a really cute place that was welcoming to a pair of out of towners meals were fairly priced and we'll done. Service was great.

S
Skylar DeWitt

We were in Rochester on a trip from Kentucky and went here for dinner on a Saturday night. Our server was Danielle who was very sweet and made sure we had gotten what we needed. My family all said their food was good.

a
angeshift

All I did was google lunch in Fairport and here it is ! Nice old building atmosphere good ,service good,food was excellent. Had a buffalo chicken salad couldn't eat it all and my sister had the tuna melt on sourdough a big sandwich and very fresh . First time here thought we would explore and I will go back to try again . Big menu and also homemade clam chowder was spot on perfect ! Sara serverd us such a nice lady. Im telling you it's good !

P
Pam Fraboni

I always value the atmosphere of a place more highly than the food. I can get good food at home, but a gathering of people celebrating and enjoying themselves is one of life's bright spots. Donnelly's has good food in abundance. To my delight, it also has a celebratory atmosphere with personable staff. We had a great time for a fairly reasonable price! Thanks, Donnelly's!

F
Fred Hayes

Always excellent, one of my favorite places for lunch and a beer.

J
J L

This place might have the best craft beer draft selection in the Rochester area. Options rotate regularly and they usually have something you won’t find elsewhere locally.

L
Laura Schneider

Had a lovely lunch here with family. Kind service, delicious food. Very nice outdoor dining. Simple food, done well. Great cocktails, strong and cold on a warm day. Visit here the next time you are in the Village of Fairport, walking the canal or shopping. Yum.

N
Nancy Fleegle

Always a fun place. This was my husband's first visit, and he loved it. We try to visit every time we are in the area. The food is good, and the beer and wine selections are good. All around, a pleasant dining experience. The server and other staff are pleasant, and we are never rushed.

D
Daniel Tucker

I should rate this place more often, it’s just never popped up. I’ve been here at least 8-10x and have never had a bad experience. I was just before noon today, so kinda slow and quiet. I heard another patron mention how quiet it was, so the atmosphere wasn’t top notch h, but it did become more vibrant once noon hit Service was great. Fish fry Friday. I think Panko breaded, amazing! I like this place.

S
Sudo Nimh

Irish pub in style, large bar. Food is legendary. Not cheap, but not overpriced. Wings done well, incredible burgers (bison!), excellent fish fry, and compelling specials. Friendly staff. Highly recommended. Very busy on Friday night, quiet on weeknight.

S
Shirley Bentley

Stopped by for lunch...The food was great! Service very, very good, excellant.

S
SunflowerBirb (Birby)

A very comfortable dining experience with friendly, attentive staff. The beer flights are a great value! If I lived in the area, I would be a regular for sure! Instead I'll just tell people they're worth the visit!

J
Joshua Lewis

Went here once before with co workers. Donnelly's kills it every time. Great food, great beer selection, amazing staff.

H
Homey Bryan

best place around... visit the pub... for what it is.. you cannot beat it... easy for me to say... longtime visitor... cool place to hang out and chill... keep it local.. one of the best places for sure... the haters dont know... meet you down the pub... yes...

Sue Higgins
Sue Higgins

This was a wonderful Irish pub experience with a fun and varied beer list and delicious comforting filling food. It was so good that I'm coming back with my fiancé.

Kyle
Kyle

The food is good, mostly have wings or a salad. I had a burger in this night it was juicy, flavorful and cooked to perfection as was my wife’s. Never have trouble choosing a beer to wash down the food as the selection is always fantastic. I would highly recommend this place if you are ever in the area.

Brandon Rehak
Brandon Rehak

Best pub in the area. Food is absolutely amazing and fresh. Beer selection is top notch and the team working there know their beer. Traveling for work and have never had a group make me feel more welcome. Wings are killer and fish fry is worth going for.

Laura Kile
Laura Kile

The staff was super friendly and helpful. Our food came in a timely fashion but Will (we think that is his name) apologized for it being delayed. In our opinion, it was in no way delayed. It was delicious and when we were finished, Will came up and offered us each a free ice cream on him because our food was so late. We protested but finally gave in and accepted a cup of cookie dough ice cream to share. It was also quite good. We all highly recommend you visit this establishment!

David H
David H

Ireland has a home in Fairport and it's at Donnelly's Public house. From the moment you arrive it feels like home. Great sandwichs and Chili. You must check it out.

Jennifer
Jennifer

Popular, warm, neighborhood pub. Staff is so welcoming and friendly, everyone feels like an old friend here. It’s nice for families, couples, and groups. Extensive beers on tap and full bar with skilled bartenders. Good pub food with rotating specials. While I generally have simple tastes in adult beverages, the bar staff has demonstrated skill mixing more complicated cocktails, and depth of knowledge regarding the multitude of whiskeys and craft beers on offer.

J.G.
J.G.

What do you look for in a restaurant? Consistency. Donnelly's nails it every time. My go-to is Build Your Own Burger (don't forget the meat sauce). Chicken wings? Heck yes. With football season here, every sunday that has an afternoon game, they got 10 for 10 special - dine in only. They kill it with the salads too. Had a 10k race - i'm typically a creature of habit. But i decided to go crazy, and order a salad instead of my burger. The Taco salad - probably in my top 3. The service - amazing. Outside seating always available.

Teufel Hund
Teufel Hund

I had the beef bomber sandwich. The meat was soft and flavorful❗ The quantity was very large and came with a choice of sides. The bartender was very personable and attentive❗ Parking was plentiful, restrooms were clean. The price of the food and beer are reasonable. I had the Colonel Hopkins Vermont 32 IPA, which had the fruitiest hop scent out of all the IPA's I've ever tried! I asked the bartender where I was sitting, just out of curiosity what the alc/vol content was? I was NOT expecting her to go out of her way and bring it up on her tablet and gave it to me to read up on the beer. That was impressive and unexpected for anyone to care so much. SIMPLY OUTSTANDING SERVICE❗ This is a GO TO restaurant / pub without a doubt❗👍

Keishlah
Keishlah

The appetizers were great!👍 I really Loved the pretzel and it tastes great with a side of cheese if you don’t like the mustard. I also had mushrooms sandwich with fries and it was perfectly cooked and crispy fries. 🍟 Definitely will be back. The server was so polite and on the ball with everything. Great Food and beer spot.

Lucy Costa
Lucy Costa

Second time I've been to this place with Pati and Matt from Robben's Nest stitchry. Good atmosphere for a late afternoon, having drinks and eating tasty dishes, such as a wonderful Fried haddock. Without forgetting about appetizer, follow the photo.

Award winning Blogger / Influencer
Award winning Blogger / Influencer

Aimee, Was such a Treat for two travelers from Lancaster, We Loved everything about this place, I’m a chef and not one thing was out of place Here, everything was so delicious, if you’re like us and on the Erie Canal Adventures boats and have one place to stop, choose Here! You have to ask for Aimee the server / Owner, she will make your visit so special, She did ours with the very best recommendations, The Buffalo chicken salad was spectacular, The Cheese sauce (mornay) was unbelievable, the tots were the best bargain for what seemed like the hundreds you got! Ask for them with the cheese sauce you can’t go wrong! The wings looked like Turkey legs, the Burgers appeared perfectly seared, large sizes all around, This will be one of those places that we won’t soon forget and will measure every other pub style Faire by, They set the bar unbelievably high, Such a Gorgeous memory of this place will always remain in my Heart because of the kind Service, phenomenal food, and awesome atmosphere out on the patio, Loved it! Loved it! Loved it! Thank you again Aimee, for making our Visit Something we won’t soon forget, You’re exactly the best kind of steward the restaurant business needs and so seldom finds, not to mention community Ambassador right in Your centrally located spot for a community like Fairport, Who won’t be forgotten, because of the special people like you and your husband who’ve dedicated their lives and time to a place & public like this who I hope keeps you successfully in business for a very, very long time, because Not only are You doing something special every single day for the people who remain Here, but also for the people like myself who because of you and your Restaurant, can’t wait to come back! I’ll be remembering Donnelly’s Fondly in my Heart for a very long time, until I can see ya’ll again which will never be soon enough! -Chef Dan From Lancaster County, PA

Rachelle Marie
Rachelle Marie

Great meal! Tons of tap! Friendly staff. Another good stop in Rochester especially if you’re checking out the brewskies in town!

A
Anthony Ferrari

Great local brew pub! Outstanding rotating selection of beers. Food is good solid bar food with some other fine entres available. Service is good. It can get quite crowded on weekend evenings so get their early for dinner if you have kids. Prices are average.

M
Michael Shon

My first visit, probably won't be my last. Everyone's food was very good. Surroundings were clean and comfortable. Kitchen was perhaps slightly slow, but not very. Waitress was a bit too fast, accidentally taking away a dish still in active use, but she was paying attention, stopped, and apologized. Beats being ignored! Overall quite good.

G
Grace Soong

They have a large covered outdoor sitting. I ordered a glass of Riesling and their beef brisket/egg/hash browns wrap special for $13.99. It was generously sized but a little dry. It came with a side of spicy ketchup. I enjoyed the side of tater tots. My husband had the Cuban sandwich for $13.99 and a glass of Blue Moon beer. He wanted a bottle, but they do not serve bottled beer. They have a huge selection of beer on tap. He said that he would also give his sandwich a 4-star.

D
Dan Sheehan

My wife and I go here consistently. This is what a local pub is intended to be. Solid beer selection and excellent food. Try a mix of garlic parm and Cajun spicing on your wings and ask for them finished on the grill. Nothing short of outstanding! Scott is an involved owner and cares about customer service. This is a true gem in the village of Fairport.

J
Jeremy Brown

Great beer selection. Taps rotate regularly. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly and the owner is often around to chat you up. In the summer, there is wonderful outdoor seating as well. The food is very good for pub food, and has some of the best wings in the city, and the specials are usually very good and it's easy to find something you'll like. On popular nights it can get very crowded and very loud.

J
Jeff Walent

Had the Ed. Roast beef with Brie and horsey sauce served with side of au jus. Sounded amazing. It tasted great. However, I seemed to miss some of the Brie flavor and it was a little lite in the horsey sauce. i like bold flavors and I like horse radish and should have asked for a side go horseradish and extra Brie. However, the sub roll was crispy outside and soft inside (delish) and roast beef was flavorful and tender. I would try it again with those changes. Beer selection was fantastic with something for everyone. Service was great.

J
Jennifer Tanner

Great menu selection and the food is always good. The bartender is efficient but grumpy.

A
Alyssa W

Excellent food! Really enjoyed all the wing sauces we tried - garlic-parm (without buffalo sauce), Thai peanut, bourbon BBQ, and mild buffalo sauce. I got the French dip sandwich, which was outstanding. The beef was tender and flavorful, and the roll was delicious. Can't wait to go back!

K
Katie Rudow

My favorite place to visit in the village. They have great food and many drink options. Every food item I've ordered from here has been delicious! They have a nice patio area to enjoy in the warmer months, and stay busy year round because of their mouth-watering food! Along with the many drink options and great service have me giving this 4 stars. I'd love to give 5 stars but they get so busy and don't have space for waiting that the crowded feeling leaves me at 4.

S
Stephen DuMont

Food is great with tons of beer on tap, great environment although I wish they would loose the TV's. The waiter was not the best but oh well, he hovered and crowded us as we left. Also be sure to get the onion rings as a side your welcome in advance 😜

r
ryan kemp

This place warrants 5 stars but I reserve those for the best. Donnelly's is huge but cozy. They have delicious Guinness & the fish fry was better than average, but it's Rochester so comparing fish frys could fill a Robert Jordan book series. I'll recommend this place & definitely be back. The menu has a lot of fun creations.

D
Dan Michalko

Always great service and atmosphere. Food is pretty good as well.

K
Kevin Markman

Laid back bar and restaurant. Lots of kids for dinner and friendly people. Good bartender.

M
Mick La Lopa

Stopped in late for a meal. Had to wait a bit for server but finally came to table. I got the BLT. It was definitely a big sandwich but not happy that they used an end piece of the loaf for my sandwich, and there was a lot of B but not much LT, which would have made it taste more like a bacon sandwich. The prices were reasonable, too, and server ended up being mostly attentive throughout. Would I go back?

K
Kris Harris

Had the special, which was a beef stew with mashed potatoes, and it was fantastic. However, 2 small but tender chips of beef are all it came with. Still, I highly recommend it. This is definitely a pub, not a place to go for great entree selections. Mostly sandwiches. 30+ beer selection and of course Irish whiskey.

R
Ron Buckman

Always consistent quality food, brews, and cocktails. Always feel.welcome here.

Fred Miller
Fred Miller

Came with my Daughter tonight. Fish fry was excellent as was the service. Craft beer selection was amazing.

Matthew Cochran
Matthew Cochran

We go all the time. Food isn't fancy but always solid. Service is great even when crowded. Great beer selection.

Stewart Farwell
Stewart Farwell

Decent bar grub, nice selection of beer. Service was kind and fast and the food was hot-that was what mattered most on this visit.

Christopher Carlsson
Christopher Carlsson

Great food - especially some of the specials and happy hour offers. Beer list is somewhat disappointing for me - Lots of variations on IPA’s , a number of lager types , but almost no ales , porters or stouts without a lot of adulterants that have nothing to do with real brewing . Also it can get pretty load and crowded at times hence 3 stars for atmosphere.

A S
A S

Cozy public house with 33 beers on tap, daily specials, and a big menu. I got the Buffalo garlic Parmesan wings, which were delicious. Company got the Rueben sandwich and the Don Cubano sandwich. Everyone enjoyed themselves and their food. Pretty quiet spot with a few patrons around late lunch time on a Friday. Good food, great atmosphere. Lower rating on the service as we had various ladies checking in on us so the service was a bit inconsistent - no one checked in after our food arrived. No one came by to see if we wanted more beer, did stop by eventually with a refill of our waters. but quiet time of day so not too surprised.

Matt Ruffell
Matt Ruffell

Nice pub, good food and beer. Service is great. Food is good and lots of menu choices best suited for lunch in my opinion. Can be loud on a busy day.

M
Mike Carlino

I wrote a good review for this place years ago, but it's gone now. I was going to add to it. Disappointed tonight. Beer was cold. That's good! Unfortunately so was the room, and the chili. Folks wearing winter coats, me included. The chili, it was like they forgot to turn on the heat under it. Chili was good, but it was lukewarm. Rest of the food was decent, but I got to thinking. They don't do anything particularly standout anymore. We went in because they had an interesting item on their specials menu. I saw it that afternoon. We get there and they've taken it off the menu. That's happened more than once. Bottom line, we're done with them for the winter. Too cold. We'll try them in the summer.

S
Shea Drake

Fish fry was good and we came here a couple times and the kids meal comes with a drink but they didn’t say that the drink they asked for was extra. The last time they didn’t charge for the same drink. They also didn’t say choosing a different side was an up charge. This is poor customer service. They took one charge off but it should be discussed.

T
Ted Weymouth

I want to start by saying that I have always had a great experience at Donnellys so please take this review with a grain of salt. My problem is that I have a person with nut allergies in my household. I placed an order of wings for 9 Thai peanut and 9 buffalo medium. The order was correct but they combined the two styles in one container with no separation between and mixed them together. I have placed this exact order before and they have always been separate so I didn’t think I needed to request special care. I mean who would think to mix those two different style wings together to begin with. The wings were great as always but we had to leave someone out from having them which is disappointing. I would hope that they take a little more care in the future.

m
maggie flip

service was good and liked the atmosphere. We had the fish fry and it was just not the best, overly breaded and greasy, fries not homemade and very small amount of coleslaw , no taste. They did give us a very large piece of fish, but with a very small container of tarter sauce, asked for a little more and charged an extra 1.50. Thinking other selections would be better.

T
Tyler Pripps

Cool little place. Easy walkin'. Well rounded menu and drink selection

Steve R.
Steve R.

People who came in after we ordered got served before us. Our $20 mac and cheese was very light on the specialty toppings, and the noodles had clearly been sitting under a warmer for some time. The outside seating is nice when the weather is nice. We ate on the first floor.

K
Kristina Krause

Our server, Sarah T, never checked on us ONCE after giving us our food. We tried getting her attention many times because she never gave us our curly fries (which we specifically said we wanted as an appetizer), but it was impossible because it seemed like she was actively avoiding us..? She never made eye contact, always rushed by our table without even looking over at us…so after 10 minutes of trying, we finally decided we didn’t even want the fries anymore. What’s the point of having a waitress if they don’t check on you, not even once? You’re not gonna make any tips if you call that “waitressing.” She also never brought us waters, and my portobello burger was burned on the bottom.

R
Rebecca Maier

Used to eat here a lot. Went there the other night for a family dinner. Service was great, however the quality of food has gone downhill. Their quesadilla used to be out of this world; alas, this go-around it smelled too weird for my niece to consume, and was not edible for any adults either.

David Dais
David Dais

Went here for dinner tonight with my fiancé and it was decent/okay at best. Ordered the buffalo garlic boneless wings for an appetizer and they basically were just covered in got sauce. For dinner I ordered a burger and she ordered the buffalo chicken salad (mild). My burger was okay but not great. I can tell they used a basic frozen patty because it tasted like it. I have had burgers at other pub places before and they were a lot better than this place. My fiancé’s buffalo chicken salad was ordered as mild, but was much hotter than she would have liked. Also, looking at my receipt, I noticed an up-charge for fries and gravy that the waiter never mentioned which was definitely not cool. Overall the food was decent, but we definitely wouldn’t come here again. There was actually a pizza place next door called TK’s and I saw they had great reviews. Will definitely try that next time. Also, there is a public parking lot adjacent to the building.

R
Rachel Volo

Food was great! Our waiter (not sure of his name but was wearing a bright green polo) came right up after we were sat with two glasses of water and said he would be right with us. Then he came over awhile later and asked us what we wanted for dinner (did not ask for our drink order).. I would have ordered my drink there but figured he would come around shortly to check in and I could order then. HE DID NOT CHECK IN AT ALL, THE ENTIRE TIME WE WERE THERE. I had to order my drink when the food came out (a different server wearing a black polo) he kindly asked if there was anything else and I told him the soda. he comes back very quickly with the drink. Then we realize we had NO Napkins or silverware. I had to ask a waitress walking by for napkins, she was very pleasant and nice. Then we sat for 15 minutes after we were clearly done eating, before the green polo shirt waiter came back. Meanwhile, I heard him ask other tables if everything was good, need anything else, etc. Then he proceeded to stand in the corner talking with the other waiter watching the game before coming over to have us pay and give us a box. I understand the pandemic has effected multiple things, short staffing, so on.. I'm not complaining about the wait, I just wanted a little more service after a long day.

A
Alex Smith

Wings are horrible they close for cold weather. They have staffing issues and just not same since new owners took over

R
R. Greeran

I was here today on my birthday and ordered The Ed B sandwich. The beef was green and iridescent; and the sandwich was cold. I had 2 bites. When the waitress came back I mentioned it. She took the plate to the kitchen and said no worries I'll take it off the bill. She came back without the plate/sandwich, but then told us the beef was fine and the kitchen said they couldn't take it off the bill because there was no issue with how it was cooked. They brought the check out... with the meal not comped. Literally charged us for a sandwich we didn't even get. No offer to make a different dish or anything. I could have at least had the side of coleslaw for $15. Even when we asked about them taking off the meal, she said the kitchen didn't authorize them taking it off because there was no problem with the food. Umm... you can't charge people for food they don't even have. What a fun birthday. Will never be back.

Inicia sessió per deixar una ressenya

Inicia sessió
👑 És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!

Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú

Explora la teva zona

Més restaurants a Fairport →
📸

92 Fotos

Explora les fotos de Donnelly's Public House

Donnelly's Public House
Donnelly's Public House
Donnelly's Public House
Donnelly's Public House
Donnelly's Public House
+87 Més
📍

Informació sobre Donnelly's Public House

Com arribar

1 Water St, Fairport, NY 14450

Carregant mapa...
Donnelly's Public House
Toca per direccions

Destacats

Altament Valorat
4.6/5 estrelles
💬
Moltes Ressenyes
927 ressenyes
💰
Preu Moderat
Nivell de preus
👨‍🍳
pub
Tipus de cuina

Serveis

🍽️ Dinar
🍾 Sopar
Cafè
🍰 Postres
🥡 Per Emportar
🍴 Menjar al Local

Opcions de Menjador

🍽️ Menjar al Local
🥡 Per Emportar

Informació del Restaurant

Estat
Verificat pel propietari
🕐 Horario Hoy
11AM-11PM
Valoració
4.6/5
💬 Ressenyes
927
💰 Nivell de Preus
$$
⏱️ Visita típica
People typically spend 45 min to 2 hr here
📞 Telèfon
+1 585-377-5450
🌐 Lloc Web
donnellysph.com
📋 Menú
Veure Menú

Comoditats

🅿️ Aparcament
🌿 Terrassa
Accessible amb Cadira de Rodes
🚻 Lavabo
💳 Targetes de Crèdit
🏘️

El Barri

Ubicació

1 Water St, Fairport, NY 14450

📍 Explorar el Barri

Weather
28°
Temps actualitzat cada hora · Feines i esdeveniments actualitzats diàriament
First Baptist Church of Fairport Patrimoni

church building in New York, United States of America

A 237m
First Congregational Church of Fairport Patrimoni

historic building in Fairport, New York, United States

A 400m
Potter Park
A 774m
🎮

Jocs

🎮 Guanya Punts Mentre Explores!

Juga a Find Me i canvia punts per descomptes a Donnelly's Public House i altres restaurants

🎮

Guanya Punts a Donnelly's Public House!

Juga a Find Me i canvia recompenses aquí

Guanya punts extra i canvia'ls per recompenses de Donnelly's Public House

🏆 Recompenses de Donnelly's Public House

💰

Descompte 10%

A Donnelly's Public House

1000 pts
Disponible
🍽️

Aperitiu Gratis

A la teva propera visita

2500 pts
Limitat
👑

Taula VIP

Experiència premium

5000 pts
Exclusiu

per canviar recompenses i guanyar punts

📋 Com funcionen les recompenses?

1

Juga a Find Me

Cada 100 punts de score = 1 punt de recompensa

2

Acumula Punts

Els workers obtenen 2x punts per partida

3

Canvia Recompenses

Descomptes, menjar gratis i experiències VIP

Trucar
Deixar ressenya a Google
👑

És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!

Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú

Inicia sessió i juga

Revisa el teu correu!

Sense contrasenya — t'enviem un enllaç per email

T'hem enviat un enllaç d'accés

Revisa la carpeta de spam si no el veus