Jack Wehrle

We just had lunch with our family and some friends and this restaurant is awesome. The food was amazing and the servers were great!! I had the chicken Sabino and it was so good, there was a pink vodka sauce to dip the bread and it was to die for. I will be bringing my friends asap to share this amazing find!

Jose Cerda

Came to celebrate our 6 month wedding anniversary, the food was amazing! The cheese was so melty, and delicious. Great atmosphere- BYOB and amazing Bread. Owner is Eddy - ask for Ava

AnnaLisa Johnson

WONDERFUL SERVICE! And the BEST food! My husband and I come here a lot but this time it was for a ladies networking luncheon and they were amazing! The restaurant was PACKED but everything went so smooth! Thank you to the amazing owner and the wonderful waitress who served us!

Alastair Hunte

We felt like we discovered a hidden gem in McKinney. The GIGANTIC rolls were amazing, and food was delicious and reasonably priced. Normally we would take pics of the food, but it was so good and we were so hungry it was devoured too quickly! 😉 We'll definitely be back.

Nicole “Coleyworld” H

One of my favorite Italian restaurants in Texas, hands down! My boyfriend's parents live in McKinney and we go here every time we visit, every chance we get. We order the Chicken Parmesan with the penne pasta, and it's our most favorite chicken parm. No other restaurant has mastered it to be this good, as Sicily has. The garlic rolls are HUGE and they're served with delicious marinara. I also get the tossed side salad served with a scrumptious dressing and I always get a bottle of this dressing to go. Eddie and crew are amazing and have some of the best service I've ever come across. Furthermore, it's BYOB so we bring our favorite reds, and enjoy a glass of wine. Cheers!

Marcus A.

We had pizza and it was fair. Loved the bread and portion amounts but when I asked for Italian sausage, I didn't expect rolled cut sausage that looked similar to pepperoni. I will definitely try this restaurant again and adjust the rating if the food is better. Our friends had items from the menu that looked good.

Chana

This restaurant is great. We go pretty often. But this time the cheese pizza wasn't good. Well my son's cheese was but my one slice wasn't. Everything else was fine. Just my one slice. As you can tell the last pic is my slice it doesn't look like the rest.

Spent over 30 dollars for 3 Tiramisu and they were completely frozen. So disappointed. Will definitely not order this again.

Edward Guzman

So Googlers, I know now that I live in the country, Princeton, that I would stop reviewing. Wrong! So my favorite food is Italian. So when I read that Sicily's Pizza & Pasta is where the, 'Real Italianians go' I had to. Sorry to say, 'molto deluso'. The appetizer, the Home Bread, was recommended by our friendly waitress. Soggy tomatoes on some sort of bread with sliced white cheese. Molto Deluso! I ordered the Eggplant w/ Italian sausage and my wife the Chicken Alfredo. My dish was passable. But my wife's Alfredo was watery. I've tasted better alfredo and red sauce out of a jar on aisle 6 at Kroger. And that's the main problem here. The food lacked flavor, color and imagination. My wife commented the her Alfredo was just boring white. Peas, scallions, hell parsley! I know a ton of people go here and that it's a McKinney institution. Maybe it's the pizza? We will try that on the next visit, cause everyone deserves a second chance.

+1

Azmina Pirani-Salameh

Pretty average Italian food. Nothing really special but nothing terrible expect for the fact that my tossed salad was literally lettuce with a slice of tomato(paid $4 for it)…

Abigail Peña

NEVER order here during dinner rush and NEVER do delivery! They just threw everything into the bag, it was leaking. I ordered their lasagna, no ricotta, with side meatballs, mushrooms and marinara they served the lasagna with ricotta (and I'm allergic to ricotta) I expected there to be an individual container for the meatballs, but nope, they threw it into the container with my lasagna, they also threw that piece of bread into the bag without any container, had to get my own bowl to set it up how I wanted it, the bread was cold and soggy. Overall flavor is just eh, I've worked in Italian food restaurants for two years now and I'm disappointed. I decided to eat the meatballs and not risk it with the lasagna, I am getting an allergic reaction in my throat already. If you got allergies, please be careful, they should've just called me to change my order, but they didn't put the ingredients on their website or any others. I know when it's dinner time, it's difficult, but you must prioritize what the customer wants/needs and put thought and care into the orders. Even if you're going slower than usual, you're making sure the order is correct, it saves more time and more money if you don't mess up. Period.

+1

Jessica B

My family and I came into your restaurant this weekend. We were so excited because the food is amazing. We’ve been coming there for 10+ years. My daughter and brother’s girlfriend got food poisoning

Leeah Sierra-Jackson

I ordered a 12 inch cheese pizza, which I would not order again. The crust was okay a bit too soft & soggy. Cheese was overpowering & had a weird buttery taste.. the marinara was OK. I think the “garlic rolls” were most disappointing. You get a mountain of cold bread with no garlic flavor what so ever. Marinara for the “garlic rolls” was tasty. It’s messy when you walk in & a mess behind the register which made me question the kitchen’s condition. The dining area was clean though.