Lou

I've been wanting to try this place out for a very long time as former WWE star Matt Cardona/Zack Ryder has given them the nod of approval on social media over the years. Finally got the chance to stop by and without a doubt this place has the best sandwiches I've ever had. Will definitely be back when in the area. The seeded bread was a hit as was the unbelievable honey turkey. Chicken cutlets were also top notch. Wow.

Joseph Lanzarotta

Finally after years of wanting to come here I finally did and I regret not visiting sooner! Had the fan favorite club sandwich with the works and WOW was it one of the best chicken sandwiches I’ve eaten! Chicken was cooked perfectly and nice and think and all the toppings went well together and a great bread they use! I see they now carry semolina and I need to try a sandwich on that as well and I love the old school feel to the place great potato salad as well prices I feel are very fare Cash only and cash only places are some of the best! Can’t wait to try different sandwiches and I’m excited they will be open on Sundays soon so I could visit more!!

+3

fahim ahmad

I have to say I was skeptical of the new owners at first, however they have come through. Food is amazing. Chicken cutlets - better then ever New items - bang bang chicken, chopped cheese are amazing Chicken Parm - still the best in NY Chicken Supreme- beautifully made All American - when "the works" soaks in tastes amazing Happy to have My Hero in my life

Erik Vliek

My Hero, has been here forever, a staple of my highschool days. And they haven't missed a beat. This place rocks. Good food, friendly staff and now, better parking! That was the only downside, but it's fixed! Cash only, that's the only thing you have to know before coming here

This message is for the owner of My Hero. On 3/3/2026 at around 1:00 PM, I went into your store. A gentleman was there, and I told him I had a pickup for “C.” The whole exchange took less than a minute. """"""""He told me the total was $33"""""""", so I gave him $40 and got $7 back.After returning to my car, I spoke with my wife. She told me she had ordered two small sandwiches over the phone, priced at $11 each. I went back inside to confirm the size of the sandwiches I had just picked up, and the gentleman said they were small—$11 each. I explained that I had paid $40, and he immediately said “Oh, right,” and gave me another $10 back.I’d like to ask about the remaining $1. Since two small sandwiches at $11 each total $22, it seems there might be $1 unaccounted for. Was that for tax? I just want to make sure everything adds up correctly.

Rahj

Chicken parm hero is gooood. One of my favorite parms. Strange, the chicken club always has less meat than the chicken parm. I've gotten the chicken club twice too. I'd go for chicken parm and skip the club. Cutlet itself does not have much flavor.

anthony giardina

This place is a classic. My favorite is the chicken supreme which consists of Chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and the works. But any chicken cutlet sandwich from this place is great. Idk why other places dont do this but these guys pound the chicken nice and thin and fry it so well. The chicken cutlet is very juicy and flavorful. The hero rolls from this place need to be toasted otherwise you are wasting your time. What can I say they make a great sandwich. The only problem with this place is that people behind the counter don't really seem like they want to speak with you. They just want you to spit out your order asap so you can get out of their face. Or that the vibe I get anyway. It's kind of annoying. Other than that this place makes a good product so I would recommend it.

+4

After hearing how great this place is I was disappointed after finally getting there. Ordered the all American w/ mayo. Why the would put oil and vinegar and mayo on the same sandwich is beside me. Roast beef in the sandwich was totally lacking any flavor. Also I don’t want to hear about how iceberg lettuce is $76 a case when a gentleman asked for a side of mustard and you were charging him $1 for it. 1 and done.

A O

I was one of 3 people in the line and my order was quickly taken. However, my want time to finally get my order was 30 min for 2 small chicken clubs. What I noticed was a lot of talking behind the line. The other thing I noticed was the focus was on orders coming from the phone and the automatic system they have set up. I fell that the in person placing of orders was not as important as the phone orders. Also if less talking behind the line was taking place by the person making my order I would have been in and out within 10 min not 30 min. They should be more attentive to the people who walk in.

Mike C

first time back here in about two years Ordered Chicken Supreme with grilled chicken with the works Presentation looks great after taking my first bite of the sandwich, it was OK. The only thing that stood out that I did not like. the roasted peppers are extremely sweet almost as if they were in sugar syrup. It’s not a good combination with the sandwich. I ate about a quarter of the sandwich and could not finish because of how sweet it was.

Well I used to come here 2/3 times a week and now no more besides it’s over priced and always getting my orders wrong WE HAD A Catastrophic experience with my wife and our sandwiches yesterday for us and the kids. Never in my life have I seen a bug that big walking on the deli meat! We had to be polite and then leave and go to rvc for lunch! Never will be back again as a regular super dissapointed with the way things have gone these past months . Many praise this place , I thought it was OK at first kind of like a step up from a subway or Quiznos - But now it’s off my list and friends and families also, do not recommend, never know how Old the food is your eating or what’s crawled on it

This place is sexist. I ordered 1 Sandwich and waited 30 minutes. Every man who came in after me, with some ordering multiple sandwiches at a time, left with their sandwiches in hand well before me. This place is a disgrace. They really need to figure out their ordering system and prioritize orders that are placed first. I will not be back to this boys club.

Frieda

EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED I’ve been using My Hero Deli to cater my parties for over 20 years, and up until recently, they were the go-to place for great heroes and friendly, accommodating service. Sadly, since the new ownership took over, the experience has gone completely downhill. The staff is now rude and dismissive. One of the biggest issues? Without them mentioning that they don‘t provide basic condiments like mayonnaise or oil and vinegar on the side unless you request it, they apparently just throw on whatever they decide without giving the customer a choice. I also ordered a fresh vegetable hero with simple specific ingredients: lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, cucumbers, onions, and banana pepper rings. When I called to confirm the details, the man I spoke to was unnecessarily rude and said, “You don’t need to confirm,” and when I politely emphasized that the vegetables should be fresh and not cooked, he snapped, “We don’t cook our vegetables.” Needles to say the hero came with cooked peppers, no cucumbers, brown lettuce and charged me $25.00 a foot. The attitude was completely uncalled for especially if I’m spending over $350.00. After two decades of loyalty. I will never order from My Hero again, and I’ll make sure my family and friends know how much the service and quality have declined. Very disappointing!

Marisa Dobrev

***EDITING*** to include a pic after the owners insane response lol here is the TINY size - smaller than a can of seltzer which I’ve also included as a reference. Yes, my friends and I used to be able to order a small and half of it would be more than enough for one sitting. And yes, I post pics in my reviews when it’s great AND when it’s bad. So what?! Why are you lurking in my reviews now? 🤣 What an INSANE response. Do better. How unprofessional. Not sure when you guys started using different bread, but that used to be the best part of the sandwich. It’s so different now and a fraction of the size. The small I got today was a little bigger than a hot dog bun. It used to be enough to have half for lunch and the other half for dinner. Disappointed. Place has definitely changed