David Weid II

Good sized, tasty sandwich options on bagels. I got the chicken club, which is breaded chicken (only half pictured). Inside, the place is fun looking and is like a mini convenience store with gum, candies, bottled and canned drinks, etc at the front. They also do drinks, so plenty of options and service was quick.

Willow Benz

They have SO MANY vegan options! I had a vegan sausage, egg, and cheese sandwich on a pumpernickel bagel, and it was delicious - huge, too! The staff was very friendly, and the service was quick. Overall, a great experience. Edit: I went back today for vegan bacon and avocado on an everything bagel. It was also quite delicious!

Mercedes Smelik

This bagel shop is very cute and follows, I believe, BTS Korean boy band theme. The decor was cute, and they even have displays of their bagel sandwiches in a case- very helpful. All their cream cheese options are visible through a deli case, which is great to get a visual for what you’re getting. Their bagels are also on display. They have a huge menu that you can customize and modify to your liking. I got a pastrami salmon sandwich on a multigrain bagel with pickle cream cheese (don’t judge lol). It was huge, full, and very filling for a late breakfast/lunch. My husband got an onion and steak sandwich on sourdough bread, which he loved. For a dude like him I think it wasn’t big enough to “stuff” him, but left him satisfied nevertheless. We got two iced lattes which come in really cute and unique cups. I tend to be picky with coffee flavor when I get a plain latte, and to my surprise this latte did not disappoint. The guy taking our order was kind and funny, which made the place all the better. I also got an almond croissant, and I will say it’s not my most favorite. I personally find value in a croissant when it is crispy, buttery, flaky, so flaky. This one was very almondy and definitely did not lack in the almond filling, but it was just a little bready and dry in my opinion. Very edible and tasty if you’re not picky, but definitely not French bakery type of croissant. The only downside was the lack of seating, and how easily the shop gets crowded while everyone waits for their order. If I’m not mistaken there’s only one table. We wanted a place to sit down and eat, so we had to scout for a nearby place that had seating. For two sandwiches and 2 iced lattes, and one almond croissant, it was $60. Overall, good experience and worth a try. They also have lots of other fun drinks, snacks, candy, and pastries available!

Giovanni Martinez

My brother and I needed something quick to eat for a late breakfast, so this was right by us. Read the reviews here and I agree: Excellent food, decent prices and quality service. Kept it simple with a sausage, egg and cheese on an everything bagel. Coffee was good too! There’s not a whole lot of dining room space, so you’ll either have to take it to go or get lucky to find an empty table.

Wes Pipitone

Awesome selection and unique flavors. They had a pumpkin shaped and cheese Doritos flavor. May be untraditional in style but it's full classic in quality and flaver when it comes to NYC bagels.

+3

Porter Charles

Really amazing flavors and unique options! I craved this the next day and would win the award as my favorite restaurant on my trip! I had the "pico de gallo" on a garlic bagel and my wife had the bacon egg and cheese on a salted bagel. Both were really great. Plenty of spread options and fun candies and sweet dessert bagels. I really want to try the french toast bagel with apple pie cream cheese spread. Cute design inside, very little sitting so plan to eat out.

+3

Lisa HD

Loved the vibe and the variety of bagels from this place. I had an as asiago bagel with blueberry cream cheese. My family had an egg bagel with avocado on an onion bagel. Both were yum delicious and perfectly melted in the mouth. Definitely a good breakfast place. It doesn't have a sit down area, so good to grab and go. Highly recommend.

+1

Afnan Aqdus

Awesome bagel spot right by Port Authority. I got the Egg Everything bagel with Garlic and Herb cream cheese and an iced caramel latte which absolutely hit the spot. There is a lot of variety for what kind of bagel and cheese combination you want to put together. My group all enjoyed our breakfast here. Highly recommend :))

+6

Jouanna J

I was super impressed with all the vegan options here! I tried the Prime Cubano, it wasn’t on a baguette like it normally is and was more of a toasted sandwich than grilled but still packed with plant-based meats and tasty pickles. The staff were really friendly and the spot had a cozy vibe. I’d definitely come back to try more of their awesome vegan options!

daniel G

Amazing experience at Bagel To Sandwich The bagels are outstanding. I highly recommend the blueberry, Asiago, and plain rainbow—each one has its own unique and delicious flavor. They offer a wide variety of bagels and cream cheeses, which makes it hard to choose just one. The quality is excellent, and I was truly impressed with how they served the iced coffee—they really know what they’re doing! Definitely a must-visit spot for any bagel lover.

+3

Food was excellent. Bagel sandwich was delicious! Service was good. It’s crowded and lots of people come through in a short period of time so not everyone cleans up after themselves…

Since this bagel shop is located in Times Square, I was expecting a really lousy bagel. I had an Everything Bagel with Butter here and it was better than what I expected. It's a small and crowded spot (understandable given it's location).

John Masseria

I enjoyed my stuffed bagel sandwich. We had our bagels toasted and maybe we shouldn't do that with fresh bagels as the bagels didn't seem fluffy or super fresh.

+1

Jimin Yeum

Their bagels are not very thick, more like pretty flat, so I don't think it's classic NYC style but I still liked its texture that was not chewy, and appreciated their cream cheese options. Also people here were all nice and friendly which made me smile.

This spot would be great if they sold real bagels. The Turkey bacon club sandwich had generous portions but was a bit pricey for what it was - the bagel was so dry and didn’t taste good. Anytime I’ve tried their bagels on their own, they are just inedible. It’s small space inside with about 2 tables that are usually filled. Staff is nice