Large indoor pub atmosphere (without the smell of stale beer) with a great menu and fast turnaround. It was surprisingly quiet. Food was very good and waiters super attentive. Great for lunch meetings. My guest remarked at the surprisingly good pick and said he'd return. Can't get a better review than that.

Classic pub atmosphere with a relaxed, local crowd. Drinks were well made and the vibe is easygoing, a good spot to catch up or unwind after work. Service was friendly and casual, exactly what you expect from a neighborhood pub. Grab a seat at the bar for the best experience and conversation.

Such a great meal. I would give the food 2 extra stars if I could. The lamb burger was perfect flavor, balance, and size. The fries were good. The shepherds pie is some of the best i have had outside of Ireland. The bartender, she makes amazing Old Fashions! Went for drinks last night. Tonight for food. I wish we were staying longer, we would go back again. It was a nice atmosphere. Live music tonight. So good. Service was ok. A little slow. But they were friendly. We are glad we went. It was right next to our hotel! Super convenient!

Really nice pub with lots of space. It was quiet when i was there on a weeknight, but I'm sure it gets packed. I tried their lamb burger with a Brooklyn lager for dinner. The burger was huge and unwieldy, but very good. The staff were friendly and my server, Marisol, was very attentive. Prices are very reasonable too and they even proactively offered a discount for staying at Candlewood Suites nearby. This place made my night and I would definitely come back.

Sarah

Delicious. Quick. The sauce is very fresh and flavorful. Garlic knots are fire.

Kimberly Le’Vere

Absolute best pizza my husband and I have ever had!! We will most definitely be going back

Vanessa Le

the pizza was fine but good god, the garlic knots. For $4 you get 4 massive garlic knots with a crispy buttery exterior, and the soft pillowy interior of a cinnamon roll. These were genuinely the best garlic knots ive ever had in my life. I don't even like garlic knots or go out of my way to order them, but i saw these beautiful gorgeous babies glistening, SHIMMERING in the glass case and i knew we had to get some. 10/10

Elisaa

An amazing place for a slice. It’s very tasty with a lot of choice. The quantity and the price are very good. Be careful, the restaurant is not very confortable but you can take out and eat it in front of Times Square.

M L

This place was a two minute walk from our hotel. They had a vegan option so I was anxious to try it. I got fresh jalapenos added to it. It was amazing! I ordered a small and it was a pretty good sized pizza. Definitely recommend it!

Deanna Swisegood

I ordered the Margherita Pesto slice-- hands down, the greatest slice of pizza I have ever eaten.The crust was soft but crunchy, and the toppings were just perfection. Going back for another slice before our trip is over!!

Harold Rosa

The Alfredo pasta is one of the best options here in Times Square, perfectly cooked pasta with grilled chicken and the garlic bread that comes with it, it's perfect to eat, it was totally worth it.

Julia Menzel

The gluten free pizza is AMAZING!! The best I’ve had!

Teresa Ngo

Amazing pizza and friendly staff :) The spicy honey pepperoni pizza was probably one of the best pizzas I've had in a very long time - a great amount of sweet and savory! I would definitely recommend this! The Nashville hot wings and habanero mango wings were also super juicy, savory, and delicious :) Good price, good food, and friendly staff that were quick and helpful :)

Dermot O'Mahony

Absolutely excellent. Pizza was perfect, fries were excellent, couldn’t fault them!!! Will be back!

Monique Wu

Best NYC veggie pizza ever. Thin crust with delicious red sauce. Must try.

Josh D.

Wow! The vodka sauce is amazing. I’d put it on any pizza, pasta, or even drink it! With the fresh basil and fresh cheese this is easily the best pizza I’ve had anywhere. The crust is flexible so you can fold the slice, but it’s got a crunch still! So glad I went here. I’ll definitely be back and telling friends about it.

Anar Gojayev

Pizza is great here. And even for NYC standards. There is no bathroom.

+3

Michael Hiles

Stopped in for a couple of slices. Pretty good. Had pepperoni and mushrooms. Also a slice of meat lovers. The sauce was indeed a bit sweet as indicated by other reviewers. Not offensively so, but noticeable. Big plus was some really tasty beef and cheese empanadas.

Amy H

My son loved this pizza! We went back a second day and got the pasta. Ordering online was easy and pick up was quick. The pizza box is huge!!! We had a party of 8 adult and it was perfect amount of food!

Stephanie S.

Ok so after trying another place one block away, I find square pizza to be magnitudes higher in quality. Perfect crust. Piping hot. Takes credit cards if you don't have cash. And I can tell this crust consistency is what New Yorkers brag about when they leave the city. "You can't get pizza like NY, anywhere!" I can taste the flavor and consistency of the crust is something I won't find at home in LA, and in the time I finished my slice at least a dozen customers have come and gone with takeout. Plenty of room to stand and eat. Two thumbs up, A+.

aarati bapat

Found this place on a random search for pizza as a tourist in NYC. And so glad I did! Of all the pizza slices I had in my week here, theirs was the best hands down. I preferred it way more than the famous ones that people usually line up for. Definitely the best pizza in NYC for me!

Rui Zhong

Awesome $4 slices. Perfect for any time or late night cravings. BBQ chicken pizza had more sauce than I would have liked but still good. They’ve got all the basics, margherita, Hawaiian, pepperoni and some other stuff like garlic rolls and square slices (not quite Detroit style). Friendly folks operating the place. Counter space for dining in. Would love to swing by again if I’m in the area.

Irish Pub near Port Authority Station. Popped into this joint while meeting with a friend. I went during happy hour and ordered various frozen drinks and also some eats. I ordered the fish tacos, and quite honestly i was very surprised, my expectations for bar food is well adjusted but yes, that fish was one of the most moist, and supple fried fish ever, even for a bar; so i was quite impressed and surprised by the quality of the fish tacos. now on other hand, i ordered their 10$ frozen margaritas and pina colada; now it wasn't bad by any means, it felt a bit short on alcohol or rum, i tasted a lot of mix and sugar, but not much alcohol, and mind you, i have very low tolerance for alcohol now, so it must of been quite absent. The staff was nice and attentive, and I would go back, perhaps this time, beers, and most of all, that fish taco again.

They were understaffed. We and all the tables around us were waiting for the server for various needs - ordering, drink refills, check, etc. The person filling our water was attentive so we had to communicate via him a couple times. We were stressed because we had a show to go to. On the positive side, the place had a warm, inviting atmosphere, reasonably priced drinks and food, and great vegetarian options. My husband and I liked our entrees - cod and a mushroom flatbread. The Joyce Amber was good too. I would come back on a night when we have no time constraints.

Typical burger joint but a great find for that part of the city. Reasonable prices and moderately good food. Very large interior (unusually so for midtown). Perfect for a quick meal before a show. I'd go back.

Sameet Sapra

Pretty good vegan pizza. I also got a slice of hot honey pepperoni pizza - the pepperoni and Sicilian style focaccia like crust was excellent, the cheese was very mediocre. I honestly liked the vegan cheese more than just the normal regular cheese.

Albert “No Onions” Ruggiero

I really liked this pizza. The sauce is kind of sweet, giving it a very unique taste. I thoroughly enjoyed both the giant slice and the Sicilian. My biggest complaint is that the price to add one topping is practically the same price as a slice itself. It’s $3-$4+ to add some pepperoni when the slice itself is only $5. If you enjoy just cheese pizza, then I’d recommend this place. Unfortunately, I always want at least one topping.

Quite a horrible experience. I had the most salty sweet potato fries I have ever tasted, they were just covered in salt, uneatable. Really don’t understand why, cause otherwise they would have been quite good. The burger bun was not good either. The waiter didn’t hear our order of the beer correctly, took the wrong one away, but then still charged us. Also I ordered red wine, but got white, but at least there the waiter acknowledged that he mixed things up (the wine was pretty bad btw). Crème brûlée was too sweet, the chocolate cake didn’t have the right texture. 20% tip was added automatically to our group of 4. Really don’t understand how they can have such a high score.

I am rating this off my son and my second visit. He brought me to NYC to celebrate my 70th birthday. The pub was right next door to our hotel. Our first night in down we stopped in for happy hour. Had a very nice waiter, reasonably priced happy hour drinks and an appetizer. The second night on the way back from celebrating my birthday we decided to stop in before going back to the hotel. We were not even there for 1&1/2 hours as the bar closed at midnight. I had house Chardonnay and my son had well drinks, gin and tonic. We each had a couple of shots of Bailey. The bartender was not personable and as he wanted to clear the bar by midnight he brings one of those stupid card readers around and charges you without ever presenting a bill. Unfortunately my son did not asked for a receipt. Imagine his surprise when he checked his account later and the total was $150. How we spent that much in that amount of time is beyond me. Something does not add up ASK FOR A PRINTED RECEIPT BEFORE PAYING. WOULD NEVER GO BACK!

We were super disappointed with this place. Sat down and the bartender told us the kitchen was closed but we could order drinks. This was surprising because it was only 9:30 and the hours said they closed at midnight. Decided to stay for a few drinks since it was our last night in NYC and it was close to our hotel. The bartender was talking to another customer nearby said several times that “it was slow so they were going to close soon.” She continued her conversation with him and took at least 10 minutes to take our drink order. 2 other groups walked in not long after us and were immediately told it was last call even though we had been told it was ok for us to stay when we had asked to close out. Not sure if this is a regular practice on slower nights but it made the whole experience super uncomfortable. We only stayed long enough to finish our drinks. Sad that the good reviews were so misleading. Would have chosen to go to one of the other bars we had enjoyed instead of wasting our time here