When my son played in Cooperstown, this was our favorite place to eat. The garlic knots are amazing!! We came back and ordered more to take back to Maryland before we left. Next time I’m up that way, I WILL BE BACK FOR MORE GARLIC KNOTS!!!

We enjoyed relaxing and eating great food. We felt this restaurant in Oneonta was tastier than the one in Norwich. Our server was friendly and did a great job and the rest of the staff was just as friendly. Thank you!

Tj Randall

Amazing when you wake in the door beautiful Italian home away from home.! Oheven gets better walking in too a small that just hits your teast buzz that you would need to ask for more. They have a menu that you can choose out of what you want they have a glass or bottle and or fountain drinks that you can choose from

Michael Katilas

The best Sicilian pizza i have had since I was in Manhattan 8 years ago.

Katharine Hicks

I always go to Nina's. I am really particular because lived in NYC and love Italian. So I've tried every place in the area and I honestly will tell you this is the only real Italian restaurant in the area. These are real Italians. Im talking reggiano parmesean...quality ingredients...great gravy...or sauces... Do not go to any other place.. Fresh salads. Premium ingredients. You can taste the quality of the ingredients. Pizza, lasagna, Alfredo sauce to die for. Perfect flavor perfect consistency.... and if Nina ever cooks for you... it's like taking a trip to Italy! Like i said....come here and very picky.

Jackson

★★★★★ – Absolutely Amazing Pizza and a Local Gem Nina’s Pizza is hands down one of the best pizza spots I’ve ever been to — and I don’t say that lightly. From the moment you walk in, you can tell this place has heart. It’s not just another chain; it’s a cozy, welcoming, family-run place that clearly takes pride in everything they serve. The food? Incredible. The pizza is next-level. The crust is that perfect balance between crispy on the outside and soft, chewy on the inside. You can tell it’s made fresh, not some frozen nonsense. The sauce is flavorful and just the right amount of tangy, and the cheese… wow. It’s gooey, perfectly melted, and doesn’t feel greasy or overwhelming. Whether you’re a plain cheese kind of person or like to pile on the toppings (try the pepperoni and sausage combo!), every slice is satisfying from start to finish. They also offer garlic knots, wings, salads, and a few pasta dishes — and everything I’ve tried has been solid. The garlic knots are soft, buttery, and addictive. The wings are crispy and packed with flavor. It’s clear that quality ingredients are a top priority here. The staff and service? Super friendly. Everyone working there is always kind, patient, and genuinely seems to care about your experience. Even when they’re busy, they’re efficient and polite, which really makes a difference. The place is clean and well-kept, and there’s a relaxed, welcoming vibe that makes you want to come back. Prices? Totally fair. For the quality of food you’re getting, the prices are more than reasonable. You get generous portions and never feel like you’re overpaying. Final thoughts: Nina’s Pizza is a must-visit if you’re anywhere nearby. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice after school, picking up dinner for the family, or just craving something really good, this is the spot. It’s the kind of place you keep coming back to — and tell everyone you know about. Five stars, easily. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Rich Bennett

We placed an order on Sunday the 4th of May for pick up right as they opened up. We were told a half hour. We left our house and arrived 10 minutes early. The place was booming! The employees were wonderful. They had seven other pizzas along with ours coming out of the ovens. Fantastic place!!!

Katherine Roberts

The spinach tortellini soup that I had here was very delicious. It was a little strong in flavor and I had to ask for a little extra bread to soak it up, but it was still good. I will definitely come back here again.

Hazel Campbell

Pizza was the best I've ever had! From dinning out or making it myself. But the wing were to saucy for my preference, but still great and a bit spicy! Also my sibling who is autistic was playing his favorite video loudly but no one(customer or staff) made a fuss! Love this place. Definitely coming back!

Ariel

I had a great first experience here! I ordered a slice of mushroom pizza. It wasn’t too expensive for the quality of pizza! The toppings were great! The sauce was good. It was not too crispy and not too soft! It was just right! You can fold the pizza in half without it breaking at all! The taste was spot on!