CJ Garner

I've been here a few times on business trip. I tried a garbage plate this time around. It was good. It didn't have a lot of flavor so I had to add a little S&P. It was better than another local shop ive tried but could use some spice/flavor work. I followed up the plate with a cookie ice cream sandwich and that was delicious.

Johnathon Baker

It was maybe an off day with not much going on but being my first time at Bill Gray's I don't know what else to compare it to. The food was just as good as described. I ordered a garbage plate with everything. It was quite the heavy serving and I did my best to clean my plate. I really enjoyed the meat sauce on it all. I will absolutely be stopping back for more.

+4

Nathan Bantle

I believe this is the original bill grays. Amazing hot sauce and really good garbage plates. Burgers are thin but juicy and really good. They always have ice cream right there to pair with your dinner. Bill grays is very consistent in service and good quality. Don’t go in with out coupons or your getting ripped off.

+1

Adam Hovak

I didn’t know what the name of this place was, and had to look it up on the map. It looks like from the front it’s called world’s greatest cheeseburgers, and we stopped in because of that name. From the look on the outside, I expected a diner interior and it didn’t look anything like that. I went with two friends and we all decided to get cheeseburgers, one with American ch, one with Swiss ch, and one with motz. The burgers were decent, but not the best I’ve had and frankly “The world’s greatest” had a lot to live up to. Clean place, fast service, decent burger. It was a wee bit greasy, but the bun was soft and chewy. I gave it 3 stars because of the claim, and the fact 3 cheeseburgers were $30, and that’s a bit too much.

+2

Marjorie Rose

The burgers are very good but they are super heavy and the oily greasy foods will upset your tummy. Good service decor was very fast food. Yummy fountain drink choices. Won't be back because it made me sick couldn't even finish my food. Diabetes burgers.

Ed Heim

Well definitely not World's best cheeseburger. Not sure how they can even say that legally🤣. It was good but needed seasoning also expensive. $15 for combo 🤑

+1

Ross Gansz

Was just there and Spent $21 on two kitty ice creams and a peanut butter milkshake The server was very confused making the ice creams and totally forgot about the milkshake. Then when I reminded her about the milkshake, it was just that milk and peanut butter mixed up in a blender no ice cream whatsoever Needless to say it was disgusting and I ended up throwing it out. What a waste.

Tom Craw

Too busy focusing on online orders had to wait over 35 mins for a burger and fries… absolutely ridiculous… should have two stations… one dedicated to in restaurant and one for delivery… not first in first out with online orders… won’t be back to this location

Karen Moore

Cashier was not friendly, no greeting, no smile. Our fish & tater tots were both overcooked. My husband’s plate had so much grease on it you could have literally poured it off the plate. We take my elderly parents to Bill Gray’s every Friday in Webster NY. Due to a storm happening today we decided to try the Bill Gray’s in Ontario NY where we live. It was quiet, only a few customers. Tables were dirty and shouldn’t have been any reason our fish should have been over-cooked, as I said “not busy”. We will not be visiting this Bill Gray’s again. You don’t dare take anything back because you don’t know what they will do to your food. So disappointed & for $35.50 it was a total waste of our money. All that grease!

Tony Saxton

Do yourself a favor and stick to trash plates and burgers from here. Got wings for the first time from them today and they were disgusting. Waste of $20

Joel Ally

Upon visiting this establishment, I was thoroughly disappointed with the dining experience, especially given the price. The garbage plate I ordered had a steak patty that was alarmingly small, almost hidden under the meat sauce. In stark contrast, I highly recommend Perrington Hots in Fairport for anyone looking for a satisfying and value-driven meal. This delightful mom-and-pop restaurant offers a garbage plate that is both generous in portion and rich in flavor, making it a far superior choice.