Israel Tovar

I honestly love the pizza here, great flavor and taste. The ingredients are A1 quality! The price is honestly worth the pie. Love how friendly the staff was! If you want to have a good pizza while close to the neighborhood, this is the place to go!

First off, the slice was HUGE. Definitely a great deal for the price. The sauce had a really nice robust herb flavor that stood out and tasted fresh. Customer service was good and everything came out quick, which I appreciated. Almost 5 stars for me. I just wish the slice was a little crispier, but that’s honestly just my personal preference. Overall solid spot and I’ll definitely be back. 🍕

Nice little New York style Pizzeria in La Frontera in Austin. They have a lunch special a giant slice with two toppings and soda for 6.99 the slice is actually pretty good and I enjoyed it it's worth visiting to check it out

Mr. K

Food was amazing but I'm not sure why the staff seemed so grumpy last time. We've been going here for years, some of the best pizza you'll find around if you like that northeastern corridor Pizza. Pricey but worth it. Not much seating, strongly recommend taking it to go.

Mike Butterfield

My first and last time to the Brooklyn Pie pizza. Discovered missing topping (black olives) only after returning to my office, I should have checked before leaving. Was not worth return trip to get it remade. Crust was very chewy and partially scorched.

Kay “Wise” Holi

First time visit and it was really good. We created our own pie. The ingredients were fresh and the dough tasted amazing. I visited NY and I must say they come pretty close to the city's taste. Pretty cool atmosphere. Outside sitting as well as inside. Cool staff. And did I mention the pizza pie is HUGE! I definitely may start getting pizza from here instead of others places simply due to the size and taste.

Eugene Karmazin

Ordered large custom pizza with a lot of different additional ingredients and other items. Got totally wrong order and ice cold pizza. Highly not recommending this place.

Dalton Ridgeway

I think the pizza tastes great. I was alright with spending ~28 dollars (with a small tip+tax) for a 14"-4 topping pizza every now and again. They upped the price of the same pizza to 31 dollars before tip and tax. That is INSANE to me. Each topping now costs more but it's because they claim everything is more expensive now, and not because they are adding more of that topping to the pizza. I understand price increases, but I already thought they were reaching for that ~28 dollar price. Look at the included picture and judge for yourself if you think that's $3 worth of pepperoni, $3 worth of ricotta, $3 worth of italian sausage, or $3 worth of black olives. I don't think it is. Especially the black olives. The blanket $3 per topping is pretty telling to me that they just want every cent they can get from you. There is no way they should charge the same $3 for black olives and Italian sausage. I brought up this price increase to a worker while overpaying for the pizza and she acknowledged that it was expensive and only offered that it was because ingredients cost more. I commented that at these prices, I won't be coming back. At the end of the transaction she just turned away and left without a word. I didn't raise my voice and maybe spoke for 20 seconds about the topic while paying. The way she just left without a word as soon as she gave me the receipt felt pretty disrespectful. I would've given them 3 stars with the above comments because it's ultimately up to you whether or not you think a ~31 dollar (before tax/tip) pizza is worth it. Unfortunately, they have messed up my order a few times. I always ask for ricotta but on more than one occasion they have given me mozzarella instead. It's pretty upsetting when a pizza place can't tell the difference between cheeses, and that was before the price increase. I won't be ordering from them again with these prices.

I picked up order for friend! The guy in the front has bad attitude since you walk in! Never smiled once. When I got to my friend’s I realized he forgot to give me a dr.pepper which we ordered. I dont feel like going back since it‘s a 15 min drive. Pizza rate: 5/10 cheese bread: 2/10 over all terrible everything.

Andrew

I wanted to share my recent experience during a pickup visit. When I arrived, I was not greeted by any staff members, and it took some time for anyone to assist me. In fact, two customers who walked in behind me were greeted, paid, and received their orders before I was attended to.

Diane Smieja

If you like the taste of cardboard and you want to waste some money, come here. The pizza was incredibly thin, barely any cheese, seriously lacked in flavor and was an extreme disappointment. I’ve been here before and the pizza was decent but I’m truly disappointed with this place now. Burnt crust, stiff as a damn board pizza, my jaw was hurting trying to work through this piece of trash. I now remember why I stop eating out and cook at home. People do not care about their business anymore and the staff cares even less. Just close please because this place is trash.

DavidJay

I visited Original Brooklyn Pie Co. a few years ago, eager to try their pizza. Unfortunately, as soon as we walked in, we were met with an unpleasant experience. I politely asked if they sold pizza by the slice, but the employee responded harshly, mocking us and making us feel unwelcome. The restaurant was nearly empty, and it was midday—we genuinely wanted to dine there. It’s disappointing to be treated that way, and it's an experience I haven’t forgotten. I hope the service has improved since then.

Christina Cheruka

Absolutely disgusting pizza. I was so excited to try this place since I just moved to the area and haven’t found a decent pizza place nearby. 1) cheese is bad quality and is super rubbery. Even tastes like rubber. 2) crust has a bad aftertaste 3) there is literally little to no sauce on a cheese plain pizza 4) this is not authentic Brooklyn style pizza 5) we couldn’t even finish the pizza 6) it’s a crime to charge $22 for a large plain pizza for inedible food If you want decent pizza, make the drive to Austin and go to Little Deli, all day pizza or home slice

Noralina Rodriguez

Biggest disappointment. Customer service and friendliness was great. Pizza was the biggest disappointment. Excellent that they sell by the slice except it is not freshly made. Pizza is seating on the side. When sliced pizza is ordered they place the toppings and rebaked, resulting in a very crispy and dry pizza. Flavorless to say the least. After 2 bites, could not continue to eat. Then tried just taking pieces from the top, but was overcooked and dry.