Sayville Chocolatier

I love, love, love this place! They are constantly updating all variations of chocolate covered fruits and candy! The young ladies and the owner Kate are always super sweet and so involved in our community!🍫

I go there all the time! The most amazing chocolates and covered fruits. The owner Kate and staff are so sweet and accommodating! Highly recommend!!

I bought a pound of the most delicious chocolate. I had some butter crunch, caramels and truffles and other deliciousness. Totally worth it.

ONE OF MY FAVORITE LOCAL BUSINESSES TO SHOP! By far the best chocolate shop Long Island has to offer. If you haven't visited yet... bring the kids, it's worth the trip. Trust me

Such a gem. I stop in a few times a year for gifts and they also did my wedding favors.

Best chocolate and candies around! This is a treat for our family especially around the holidays.

Best local chocolate store with a delightful staff. A true staple of the neighborhood!

Smells amazing! They have such a great variety! We got our seashells for our wedding cake here! They came out beautiful!

Mel A

Best chocolate and candies around! This is a treat for our family especially around the holidays.

Jaime Burgos

Best local chocolate store with a delightful staff. A true staple of the neighborhood!

Connie Iannaccone

Smells amazing! They have such a great variety! We got our seashells for our wedding cake here! They came out beautiful!

Arielle B

Such a gem. I stop in a few times a year for gifts and they also did my wedding favors.

Catherine Calabro

I bought a pound of the most delicious chocolate. I had some butter crunch, caramels and truffles and other deliciousness. Totally worth it.

Keith Shripped

Went in here with my wife to get some thanksgiving chocolates. Mia was awesome. Very helpful and happy to do it. Hard working kid. Place is also very nice and clean. Will be back.

Matthew Tyznar

Best chocolate in the world! Great people ! Nicest and most courteous staff!

Chris olsen

I go there all the time! The most amazing chocolates and covered fruits. The owner Kate and staff are so sweet and accommodating! Highly recommend!!

Eileen Tyznar

I love, love, love this place! They are constantly updating all variations of chocolate covered fruits and candy! The young ladies and the owner Kate are always super sweet and so involved in our community!🍫

Chris C

Great little candy shop located in downtown Sayville. Huge chocolate fans, this didn't disappoint. Very fresh and extremely friendly staff. Parking lot behind building.

Frank Palermo

ONE OF MY FAVORITE LOCAL BUSINESSES TO SHOP! By far the best chocolate shop Long Island has to offer. If you haven't visited yet... bring the kids, it's worth the trip. Trust me

Deborah Ahmad

A friend of my daughter from Long Island brought me this as a gift. Best chocolate I've even eaten!!! I live in Louisville Ky. Would love to have a catalog if you have one. Thank you! ❤️

Easy to see right off of Main Street servicing Sayville and the adjoining areas of Suffolk County. Parking on the Street is available but it fills up fast especially at night and on the weekends. Clean facilities. Reasonably priced. Credit cards accepted. Give it a try and you decide.

Eric San José

Easy to see right off of Main Street servicing Sayville and the adjoining areas of Suffolk County. Parking on the Street is available but it fills up fast especially at night and on the weekends. Clean facilities. Reasonably priced. Credit cards accepted. Give it a try and you decide.

I always loved this place but not today I asked for half pound of creams told her which ones I got quarter pound with creams I didn't ask for plus I felt like she had an attitude won't be going back anytime soon

Sayville Chocolatier is a business I often frequent as a local resident for holidays, gifts, a stroll down the street etc. On Most occasions I have been greeted pleasantly and the staff have been helpful. I went in recently to purchase a gift for a co-worker, and have to say this is the second time now, that I felt the person behind the counter was “annoyed”, unfriendly and uninterested in helping a costumer or making a sale. Everything felt like an issue from start to finish. I picked out a box size (1 lb of chocolate for 35 dollars) and then after a few moments, while trying to decide she asked “do you just want pre-packaged”. Did I not decided fast enough what I wanted in the box? My answer was no. At the end I asked if she can put it in a paper handle bag with some tissue- as they have done before. I wanted it to look nice as a gift for someone who had never had their chocolates. She was trying to convince me otherwise, saying it won’t fit. It would be sideways. (That didn’t matter to me, I would normally put it in a gift bag anyway) She got annoyed, but put it in the bag. At the end, I asked “can you put your label sticker on the bag?” (Seeing the entire reel of them, plentiful by the gift wrap behind the counter ), like all small businesses do. Not only does it promotes a business, but it just makes everything look nice and finished and put together. Again- she was annoyed by my request. It’s important note that it was not busy, and I was the only customer in the store at the time. I planned purchasing additional items for myself, but was turned off by her behavior, that I left. What makes this even more disappointing was that I found out later that she was actually the owner of the store.

Stephanie G

Sayville Chocolatier is a business I often frequent as a local resident for holidays, gifts, a stroll down the street etc. On Most occasions I have been greeted pleasantly and the staff have been helpful. I went in recently to purchase a gift for a co-worker, and have to say this is the second time now, that I felt the person behind the counter was “annoyed”, unfriendly and uninterested in helping a costumer or making a sale. Everything felt like an issue from start to finish. I picked out a box size (1 lb of chocolate for 35 dollars) and then after a few moments, while trying to decide she asked “do you just want pre-packaged”. Did I not decided fast enough what I wanted in the box? My answer was no. At the end I asked if she can put it in a paper handle bag with some tissue- as they have done before. I wanted it to look nice as a gift for someone who had never had their chocolates. She was trying to convince me otherwise, saying it won’t fit. It would be sideways. (That didn’t matter to me, I would normally put it in a gift bag anyway) She got annoyed, but put it in the bag. At the end, I asked “can you put your label sticker on the bag?” (Seeing the entire reel of them, plentiful by the gift wrap behind the counter ), like all small businesses do. Not only does it promotes a business, but it just makes everything look nice and finished and put together. Again- she was annoyed by my request. It’s important note that it was not busy, and I was the only customer in the store at the time. I planned purchasing additional items for myself, but was turned off by her behavior, that I left. What makes this even more disappointing was that I found out later that she was actually the owner of the store.

Denise

I always loved this place but not today I asked for half pound of creams told her which ones I got quarter pound with creams I didn't ask for plus I felt like she had an attitude won't be going back anytime soon

The smell of cat urine was so strong that I couldn’t bear the thought of buying anything in the store. I am certified chocolate lover!

I am a student at a culinary school in Manhattan (Institute of Culinary Arts) who lives in Oakdale and has experience working with chocolate through my small business I started during COVID. I went to Sayville Chocolatier to inquire about an externship for my program as we are sent out to find our own. I have been a customer here before and the younger staff in sales was very nice. Yet today, when I walked into my LOCAL CHOCOLATIER inquiring to SUPPORT THEM around March (a busy season for chocolate because they are starting to get prepared for Easter) I was greeted by a younger girl who looks like she just works in sales than, I had asked for the owner Kate and she had come out very assertive and aloof before I could even ask her the question about my externship. She gave me a regular greeting “What can I help you with?” no “hello”, no “how are you today?” following her rushed question up I answered with my inquiry where she than said “We don’t do that sort of thing, we only hire for our sales team, we do all the chocolate ourselves” in a very rude belittling tone and showed no interest or care for someone who wants to learn about this sort of business as a future entrepreneur. No “have a good day” no “good luck” none of it. I felt very belittled and honestly ashamed to call this my local chocolate business. Showed me exactly how NOT to treat anyone who walks through my front door in my businesses future.

Briana Centeno

I am a student at a culinary school in Manhattan (Institute of Culinary Arts) who lives in Oakdale and has experience working with chocolate through my small business I started during COVID. I went to Sayville Chocolatier to inquire about an externship for my program as we are sent out to find our own. I have been a customer here before and the younger staff in sales was very nice. Yet today, when I walked into my LOCAL CHOCOLATIER inquiring to SUPPORT THEM around March (a busy season for chocolate because they are starting to get prepared for Easter) I was greeted by a younger girl who looks like she just works in sales than, I had asked for the owner Kate and she had come out very assertive and aloof before I could even ask her the question about my externship. She gave me a regular greeting “What can I help you with?” no “hello”, no “how are you today?” following her rushed question up I answered with my inquiry where she than said “We don’t do that sort of thing, we only hire for our sales team, we do all the chocolate ourselves” in a very rude belittling tone and showed no interest or care for someone who wants to learn about this sort of business as a future entrepreneur. No “have a good day” no “good luck” none of it. I felt very belittled and honestly ashamed to call this my local chocolate business. Showed me exactly how NOT to treat anyone who walks through my front door in my businesses future.

Mary Marasco

The smell of cat urine was so strong that I couldn’t bear the thought of buying anything in the store. I am certified chocolate lover!