They made a gluten free dairy free pizza for my daughter. She can't eat at a lot of places. This restaurant was very accommodating

The fast and friendly! Great food. Great staff. Great prices. They send you home full with a smile. I appreciate having your place in town. Thank you.

Always delicious, the giant cookies are a must and the staff is really nice.

A very nice little hidden gem in the area. The pizza is AMAZING! Authentic New York style pizza at very reasonable prices! The spiedies were great too!

My friend said they were good but the pizza was amazing. Definitely a place to go next time I'm in the area.

Awesome crew of ppl. Fantastic pizza . Love them !!!

The best pizza I've had in a very long time. I tried three kinds, (by the slice) and they were all awesome.

The pizza was great! 🍕 I'm definitely gonna go there more often for food! And on top of that the service was amazing!

Great local pizza shop. Since moving to the area 8 months ago we’ve only bought pizza here. No need to look anywhere else!

I get pizza slices here when I'm out riding, good pizza. They have some HUGE chocolate chip cookies that are amazing too

Great pizza and wings. AMAZING Customer service. My husband and I are always impressed how friendly and on the ball everyone is here.

Amazing food, super friendly staff and great service make this our go to Pizza place in our area 👍👍

Always great pizza, wings, salads,etc! I recommend the cajun crust! Sooo good. Nice people. Great food.

This place is absolutely amazing. Top rate staff that will go out of their way to make it how you like it.

Always a fresh, hot pizza, on time, with friendly service!

Best pizza I've had in while, the slices are top notch

Great place for a slice "anytime" they seem to always have a fresh pie coming out of the oven hot and delicious.

Just happened upon this place on a road trip for the first time last week. Staff was friendly and and the food was amazing. Best sauce I've had in a long time for the pizza rolls. Will definitely stop again on my way through if not make this my destination for the trip!

Was there Monday with my girlfriend and her daughter had a pie and some soda.we stopped for some food riding back to Albany NY , we were on our way back from Cornell University and I have to say the service was outstanding and food was even better. If I ever go to Ithaca NY again I will stop by again and get another Pie here. I definitely recommend this place again outstanding service and excellent food. Stop by with the family....

THE best pizza around. Delicious, loads of fresh toppings, flavorful crust. Fat, juicy wings, decent prices. Overall amazing and a MUST try!

GREAT food!! Meatballs were awesome! They accommodated my daughters request for no bread with her meatball sub by offering to bake them in a pan with cheese in sauce. They were PERFECT!! Got Greek spiedie sub and it was DELISH! Definitely recommend! Also the wings were crispy and perfect amount of spice (we got mild). The owners were exhausted after a long day and went the extra mile for our order and we appreciate it!!

THE BEST PIZZA AROUND. They never disappoint! Their pizza is phenomenal, before you even pay for it they show it to you to make sure it’s up to par. They have great deals too! No where around here has pizza even near as good, they are the ONLY place we’ve continuously come back to - everywhere else disappoints. Definitely give them a chance even if it’s a slice from their case. They do offer other foods besides the pizza too; calzones, soup, salads, sandwiches, garlic knots, etc. Their service is fast and their staff is friendly and helpful! I LOVE Dominic’s!! Never going anywhere else!!

I work as a delivery person. I delivered he recently and decided to come back to try it. It was BETTER than I thought it would be. Compared to other local pizzerias this place had crisper pizza and the cheese was very savory. Made me think I was eating a mozzarella cheese stick as a pizza. Would highly recommend them as my favorite pizza place and will most definitely be coming back.

In Whitney Point. We're from NYC and Jersey and it took us 2 years to find decent pizza. Dominic's is terrific. A couple have been meh depending who makes it. But 100 times better than Aiello's pizza. A good fried haddock plate too. THE best French fries. Good lasagna, chicken tenders.

Great variety of available slices, Delicious pizza ! Friendly staff. Clean place.

My boyfriend and I had a lovely time. The pizza is Amazingly Great! Favorite place to go. Employees are very respectful and peaceful. Can't wait to go again.

I order calzones almost every visit and every time AMAZING. Best I ever had. If you prefer less ricotta and cheese perhaps order Stromboli. Homemade spiedies are also amazing. Pizza is SOOO good! Great business and great customer service. Never disappointed. Keep up the great work!

We stopped on our way to Delhi and were pleasantly surprised. Our lunch was very good but even better was how polite the staff was. Side note the pickles on my sub were bomb.

Last night me and my friends was looking for some food to eat we drove around and i suggest Dominic's pizza since there only store i knew that have pizza, I know there might be more but I'm not from local. Anyway I end up did not have pizza but I got one of the sub instead still don't remember the name but is was like chicken something. Any way is excess my expectations alot I very very inpress with the food, now I have to stop there often now. I highly recommend it. Staff is super friendly, except one of the old man customers sitting by the TV there yelling at us for being too loud.

Stopped in today because we've never tried their food and we wanted to try it, great staff they were very patient and the pizza was very very good, the garlic knots were a bit undercooked in my opinion but still good. I definitely will come back.

They are back from vacation and never disappointed with anything there. Always busy but have time for great customer service! . The ham and Swiss roll is my favorite.

Young men who work there were very respectful and pleasant. The pizza was flavorful. I'm glad I ordered 2 slices.

Literally my favorite pizza! We drop in for a few slices or to bring a pie home whenever we're up that way. They make a phenomenal pickle pizza!

I am from Enfield Connecticut and deliver in Ithaca and Lansing new York for work and have seen this place from the road for years. I finally stopped in for a bite tonight .. best decision Eva!! Fast friendly courteous.. q0 stars from me ! Thanks guys for being, so friendly and polite

My husband and I stopped in on a Sunday night after seeing the good reviews.We were visting from Northern Virginia.We were greeted and introduced to all of the delicious pizzas by a very nice and professional young man.Ended up choosing the spiede roll,spiede pizza slice and wings.By no means of exaggerations THIS IS THE BEST PIZZA and ROLL we have EVER had!!!The crust,flavor,texture was on point!We took extra home and the friendly young man recommended we warm it up in the air fryer.All for the employees seemed happy and worked well together.Food came out quickly.Superb customer service and delicious food!

Great pizza! My uncle who did not like pizza that much was wowed by how tasty it is. Great service and very reasonable price!

The food has always been excellent. The workers are always very polite and friendly. My orders have been completed in a reasonable time frame.

To put it simply, the pizza here is on par or better with pizza across the country. If your travels take you through Whitney Point, NY, then you would do well to eat in town. Dominic's is a wonderful example of an eatery in a town hiding some amazing food.

We just bought property in the area, planning to build our dream home and we stopped at Dominic's to get dinner on two separate occasions. The first time we had pizza, the second, I had lasagna while my wife had "fish and chips" - not on the menu, we just had them take the fish out of the fish sandwich and give it to us as fish and chips. ALL of the food was really, really good! Service was great as well. They managed our "special requests" with a quick "no problem" and gave us what we wanted, even if it wasn't on the menu. We will most definitely be back!

Dominic's makes the best Stromboli in the area. We've tried them at different pizza shops in the area including Binghamton and Norwich and nobody compares to Dominic's. The only thing that would make them better is if they offered the sauce in jars.

Great people and great food. I eat here often and I highly recommend them.

The customer service alone is enough to come into this place. Looks like a dive and kinda is however, the food was good (even the brownies!) and the owner make the trip in worth it. We were just passing through while traveling but would definitely stop in again if I’m the area (even though I’m not the biggest fan of thin crispy pizza 🤪). Kudos!

We LOVE Dominic’s!! The best pizza in Broome county. We have frequently called last minute (15-20 minutes before closing) for a pie, always able to accommodate us without any drama!! The nicest and most polite employees. It’s always clean, no matter how busy they are. Everything we have ever eaten from Dominic’s has been awesome!! Definitely worth the trip if you’re not in Whitney Point or driving by!

Dominic's has been our go-to fast food and pizza place for over 2 years now. They have amazing specialty pizza and a variety of other items, so you can find something for everyone. They are the type of family owned restaurant that greets regulars by their first name when you walk in. Highly recommend!!!

Recently have tried Dominic's again after several disappointing pizza and wing episodes, however, there has been a recent change here!! For the last 4 times we have purchased pizza and wings, they have been phenomenal! Pizza was great with good amount of sauce ( we order extra), and the wings had plenty of sauce too and were a larger size than usual, was very pleased and we are back as a regular customers now! Great Job !! PLEASE keep this up!! :)

Needed something good and quick but not fast food as we headed down 81 south. Spiedie log was delicious and salad was cold and crunchy. The staff greeted every by name as they walked in so it was obvious everyone was a "regular". Also appreciated that customers were greeted as Mr or Mrs. Worth the detour if you are passing through on 81.

We always have a great experience when we order pizza from Dominic's. Our pizza products are prepared exactly like we order them. We made the switch from Aiello's Ristorante for pizza several years ago.

Just happened to stop in at this place on the way to Jersey and it was the best decision we made, the pizza is FANTASTIC! You have to try some of there specialties (pickle, blt, etc) from bottom to top the pizza cannot be beat, hard for me to say because I've been hooked on my hometown pizzeria. But not we're always looking for an excuse to drive down! Best pizza I've ever had!

I love ordering Dominic’s I do it about once a week. My favorite is the Philly cheese steak pizza and mild wings. The staff are very fun and friendly. Great service all around! 🤩

Great food. Best customer service. The food is great, but the real reason this is the only place I get my pizza and italian takeout in WP is the friendliness and politeness of all the staff. So kind and courteous, even on the phone. The food is also the best Italian food in WP and surrounding areas, by far.

Dominic’s Pizza is one of the best places in town. They have excellent pizza, wings and fries. But those are all classic items that you would find in a pizza place. They also have amazing subs and some lasagna. And a pizza place that also serves lasagna is pretty rare. And it’s pretty good lasagna at that. They also have calzones and some soups at certain points of the year. If you want desert, they got you covered with their fried dough. This place is so good, that trying to order dinner around 5-6 is going to be a mistake, since they will be packed with orders. My favorite thing there is obviously their pizza, but I definitely recommend you try their subs if you’ve already tried their pizza!

Easily one of Broome county's best NY style slices

I live about 30 minutes away and it is still hands down the best pizza around my area. The staff is friendly and will get you to laugh and they sell these giant cookies that are so good. If I'm ever craving pizza....ima drive down here. Every. Time.

Debbie Darrow

This is by far the best pizza we have had. We drive over 30 minutes one way to get it! Chicken Bacon Ranch!!!!!!!

Thomas

This place is my favorite place to stop and eat everytime I come to Whitney point great food great people great place .

James Kodak

This is the pizza I have been waiting for ! Saw this sign coming off off I81 this pizza does not flop over when picked up. Every bite is crispy with excellent flavor. Service matches the quality! These guys love what they do and it shows through in many ways ! I paired up two slices with some fresh pizza rolls and God dang! Why does this place have to be 14 hours from my house 😅

Pam Collins

We love Dominic's spiedie rolls, pizza and wings. So good! The guys always provide excellent service. Cost is reasonable and you get a great meal, whether doing take out or eating in.

Larry Valder

Stopped in on way home from Atlantic City and got some food for the ride home, great place to eat, food was amazing, customer service was great too, fish was very good and the coselaw was amazing, pizza was very good and the price of everything was very good too. Thanks plan on stopping again and again.

Carlo Bernabe

It was 830pm Sunday Aug31st and We were passing through to get gas on our way back home to Canada. We saw Dominic’s and decided to get a slice. The hospitality as soon as we walked in there was warm. All the employees were great, friendly and attentive. On top of all that, the Pies were second to none !!! We also grabbed wings , my son devoured them on the ride home. I’m soo glad we found this Gem. I will keep this restaurant pinned in my address book for when we are passing through again !!!. Keep up the great work!! Also I’m confident to say this Pizza would rank up there on DAVE PORTNOYS list

Dillon Pallman

This place has some of the best pizza I have ever ate. Caden at the counter is a STUD buddy had us cracking up the whole night. 10/10 would recommend.

John Borovicka

Best wings in town in my opinion. They never make them wrong. The staff is great and the pizza is fantastic. The place is a little small but you can sit a large family there to eat and watch your favorite tv program.

Lee's Reviews

Absolutely the best pizza in the point. Every single week we get our cheese pie once got a cheese fries and took that also and becomes a joke when I call. They even know its me 😆 🤣 😂. Great service they are great with the community. They sponsored my sons soccer ⚽️ homecoming senior night for 2025 seniors and the team. To bad its Monday and they are closed cause now I want some.

Holly

This place is great! We get consistently good food and everyone there is friendly and knows what they're doing so it's always done fast and done right 👍

Sonny Coy (Ares)

My God the Tangy Gold are UNREAL! Best wings by far! A must try!! Employees are awesome! Super clean establishment! Fast production time too!! The pizzas and calzones are top tier!!

Brian

We were staying in town and looking for a place to eat. Dominic’s had a lot of choices the kids liked. They had a huge full sheet pie and wings, garlic knots. Everything was great, couldn’t finish the pizza. But the people working here are just fantastic! As we were waiting for our order, the rain came down hard, by the time we got the order it was still raining hard. Guy at the counter suggested covering the pizza box with a bag, good thing we did. We were soaked but our food was dry when we got back to where we were staying. Kudos to the people running this place!

Andrew Corson

Great place to grab some quick slices while driving through! The Pickle and Spiedie options are really good!

svteam95

Best pizza I had since I lived in Philadelphia. That was 1984! This is the real deal with extremely polite staff. At just over 18" Xtra cheese, sausage and mushrooms weighing in at just under 4.3, 4.5. Yup! Keep up the good work you guys rock! Joe

Raymond R.

Stopped by for a quick bite on the way back to Maryland. Places like this can be hit or miss. This one was a hit. Pizza was fresh and it hit the spot. Also first time I've ever had pickles on my pizza and it was a great choice.

+2

I love the option of ordering and paying online for takeout orders. My orders have always been ready on time, and the food has always been awesome!

The pizza is good. The workers are a little much but there nice

Friendly staff. Overall, the table area looks decent until you look closer. The table was kinda sticky, the tall chairs were wobbly, and the tile flooring was pretty beat up. Pictures of somebody's kid taken at school each year. It seemed we were waiting rather long for our pizza, but there were a couple of call ins ahead of us. The pizza was meh. It wasn't great, it wasn't bad. The sauce was kinda thin, and it was only cooked enough to bake the crust and melt the cheese, nothing more. It's the only pizza place for miles, so it does a good business. If I am in the area again, I'd probably eat there again.

Mary Naughton

Not a bad spot to grab a couple slices or some of their other items. We had a plain and a pepperoni slice. They were alright. The guy working the register was wonderful, very nice and pleasant to speak with. The heroes or stuffed bread roll items look pretty interesting as well, I may try one of those next time. This is more of a takeout/takeaway spot but there are some tables and chairs to eat inside too, just no table service. A regular pizzeria, they take card and cash. There aren’t many options for water or much of what was there in stock, except a couple Life Waters. There was every kind of juice, gatorade, soda, iced tea, flavored seltzer, even Starbucks.

+5

Christopher Graham

Where to start let me begin with the service of the young gentlemen at counter, very nice and attentive on his customers. Now to the pizza. Ordered 2 cheese slices that freshly made and from oven to the box. Give them 7.1 on them. Great crisp on the dough little flop, sauce was solid cause and fresh mozzarella just tad greasier then I like but great overall worth the stop. Got homemade chocolate chip cookie and that's only negative I have 4.3 on cookie for me no stand out taste and texture wasn't what I like from homemade chocolate chip cookie, little dry and flaky to me but that's my opinion..

+3

Have never eaten here. Was there to perform the semi-annual maintenance on the fire suppression system. (refused service ...🙁.)

Casual, down to earth setting. No ice for drinks, which wouldn't be a huge deal except my child likes sucking on them when we eat out. Pizza was good, wings were okay. Was pretty average overall

I eat here about once a month. Usually excellent pizza and service. Today the "fresh out of the oven" pizza was just warm, not hot as I had requested, and the soda I usually get wasn't in the refrigerator, so the only option was warm which I rejected. The pizza itself was as good as usual, but I prefer it hot. Hopefully it's just not my day here. So I'll give it another try.

I got your spaghetti 2 times now you give 4 to 5 times of spaghetti and only 1 small soft of sauce im not sure about anyone else but I don't like to eat dry spaghetti put some sauce on it and then I get charged for extra sauce im it's kind of a rip off to get more money

Decent food but rude phone contacts. If I was able to access their menu online, I wouldn't have to ask them a price of their pizza. Rather than appreciate my business, the phone clerk brushed me off, telling me "Go online and look at the menu- I'm too busy." Ok. Np. I'm too busy to mess with that. I'll go to Aiello's Pizza from now on. At least Aiello's is friendly and appreciative of their customers.

The guys were very nice. I was driving back to the city and stopped for a quick bite. Worse than frozen pizza. I'm sorry I need to be honest

Pizza was great as always, but the wings were kind of gummy and needed to be put back in the oven upon returning home (didn’t really help). We also ordered an italian sub for pickup, that was very disappointing. After listing and re confirming what was wanted on the sub, we were missing half the toppings requested and to be honest, it was a Subway quality sub. The raw onions were really thick cut and there was so much it was over powering everything and any lettuce that was found in the sun was white and rusty. We had to use what we had at home to add to the sandwich as it was lacking toppings we requested and flavor. Wouldn’t go for the subs again, also DONT get celery with the wings. Ours were nearly white and rusty on the bottom.

Not sure how you mess up chix tenders and a chix parm sandwich but both were not good.cooked so much the meat was dried up inside the breading. Soggy and burned chick parm made from over cooked chicken tenders. Wrapped so tight the cheese etc was just a mess after sitting on top of the oven it burned too boo boo 👎 only good thing was the cookie. I wish I could post a photo.

Pizza and service is great!! It’s the best pizza around. But they don’t deliver so I can only give 2 stars and thats me being generous. It’s 2023?!? Why you’r REStaurant isn’t on any delivery apps? But then again it’s a pizza shop in a generally weird area full of generally weird people hence the reason that 9.5/10 pizza shops in this area are awful. How do you mess up pizza? But here they do, and the .5 decent pizza shop doesn’t deliver, proudly displaying their native weirdness.

Roxanne Gilbert

The last 2 times we got chicken wings they were very over cooked the outsides were hard like they may have been cooked more then once. The stromboli had more cheese than anything else. I have always been happy but the last few times I have been very disappointed. May be the lack of pride in their work. Just saying not happy.

Lou Davis

Large sausage pie, uneven crust, thin and thick randomly throughout the dough. Dough was oddly floury and had lots of crust delamination. Parts of the pie had no sauce, others, no cheese. Crust ends were 2-3" wide. Change your sausage style too. Weird. Bottom line, these guys need to go back to dough school. I have to assume every positive review is a local. Might be the best pizza around but look where you are. Do yourself a favor, skip the pie, get a spiedie. At least they have that down. They looked solid. Place seems clean and cool though. I'll be back in two years. Hopefully the pie is better.

Charles B

Usually food has been very good. The food yesterday was horrible. We ordered wings which were small and 2 were just pieces of wing. Only get 10 and to have 2 like that. Then the calzone was raw dough in the middle. Called told by staff that when they cook they can’t get the dough cooked all the way and sorry. Offered to make new one but seriously if you can’t cook it properly then don’t make it. The offer to make new one was nice but they said it may not be cooked all way or to make sure it is they would burn outside. Why would I want either.

Very disappointed. Over half of my large pizza dough was raw. This is the 3rd time it has happened. Definitely not getting anything from here again.

Hot spedies on a cold salad, hair deliberately put in my fries. Food is good but the employees tarnish the experience . I won’t be spending any more money there any time soon.

This place has certainly gone down hill since the last time I ordered from there, the only plus is the portion size. Unfortunately if the food isn't very good the portion size doesn't really matter. *Update* So I decided to give this place another try, what a mistake! The pizza was over cooked & had absolutely no sauce. Dry over cooked pizza dough with overcooked cheese but plenty of grease from the over cooked pepperoni...very disappointing to say the least!!

The pizza was only half decent, not as good as an NYC pizzeria. And the garlic knots were partially uncooked. But one guy working the oven, who I think is the owner, was quite rude. My family was bringing my handicapped grandfather in through the front door in a wheelchair and this guy yelled at us because we were holding the door, letting in hot air and making his poor AC unit work more. Apparently this dude cares more for his utilities bill than his customers. Bathroom was clean and the other employees were pleasant though.

Very disappointed and will not ever be ordering from here again. Ordered a large pizza with boneless wings for my son's birthday, I'm aware that pepperoni can cause excess grease on a pizza but the amount on ours was shocking. The pizza was SOAKED and dripping. The entire bottom of the pizza box was soaked so much so that when I took the box out to the bin, it easily ripped. The boneless wings were these 3 odd chicken patties of mainly breading and grizzle. The order came out so badly that it felt like someone was intentionally messing around with us, as I honestly can't believe any restaurant still in business could be that horrible. I cannot in good faith recommend this place to anyone

There prices are all wrong online and on their website. It says $18 for a chicken bacon ranch $15 for a pepperoni pizza and $13 for boneless wings. I order one cbr pizza, a pepperoni pizza and 2 orders of wings which would come out to about 60 dollars I got charge $75 for that order talk to the owner and he said all of his prices are right online. I said to the owner I can send you a screenshot of your prices online. He didn’t want the screen shot says he monitors his prices online which he obviously does not. I have talked my my bank and have gotten a refund for the price difference.