Laura Hughes

Just had my son’s first birthday party in the private room. Denny and the staff were so attentive and friendly. The food and drinks were wonderful and everyone had such a great time. I highly recommend!

Melissa S

I’ve only used Gino’s of Seaford for catering, but after several experiences, I can confidently say they’re absolutely outstanding. Every event I’ve ordered from them for has been a huge hit, and the food never disappoints. Everything is fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection — truly delicious from start to finish. I always end up ordering more than I need, and it still all gets eaten because it’s just that good! One of the things I appreciate most about Gino’s is how easy and seamless they make the catering process. They deliver everything on time and even set it all up beautifully (for an additional cost, which is totally worth it). It takes all the stress out of hosting, so I can actually enjoy the event. Their party packages are fantastic — they include everything you could possibly need, from entrees and sides to salads and bread, and they make planning for groups of any size effortless. The food quality is consistently excellent — the chicken dishes are tender and flavorful, the pasta is always cooked perfectly, and the sauces taste homemade. Guests always ask where the food is from, which says it all. Whether it’s a family celebration, work gathering, or holiday event, Gino’s of Seaford has become my go-to caterer. They’re reliable, professional, and their food is always a crowd-pleaser. I can’t recommend them enough if you’re looking for delicious Italian catering that everyone will love — they truly make entertaining easy and enjoyable! 🍝🎉

Michael Pontisakos

I had the margarita deep dish slice, probably the best pizza I ever had , i liked it more than deep dish in Chicago. If the slice wasn’t so big I would have tried the other specialty slices too but portion was so big i was full .

jessica eisenbarth

Beyond impressed with my first meal here. Everyone was so lovely and welcoming. It’s super clean and beautiful. The food prices and portions are awesome!! We loved everything and couldn’t stop saying how good it was. The espresso martini on their specialty cocktail list is hands down one of the best ones I have ever had. My spicy penne vodka was fantastic- hot just how I like it. The tiramisu was also wonderful. My family all enjoyed their veal and chicken dishes. I can’t wait to come back!

Deborah K

My husband and I wanted to try the new menu at Gino’s and eat in their expanded dining room. The dining room is now a beautifully decorated restaurant, with a full bar and craft cocktails that were delicious! The Hugo Spritz was especially tasty, and my husband had an Old Fashioned whisky drink with one jumbo ice cube. It was delicious as well, and my husband enjoyed his drink and commented on the big ice cube! Dinner was incredible! I wish I could give more than five stars! Our server Victoria was attentive and friendly, and took our order noting some of the requests we made for the main dishes. We started with the Vespa salad that had artichoke hearts and roasted red peppers throughout (the salad was big enough for two) and the dressing was perfectly seasoned and not too salty. We also had the little beggar purses as an appetizer, that was phyllo dough stuffed with fig and marscapone cheese that were super yummy. For main meals I ordered the pumpkin ravioli special in a Marsala sauce that was out of this world! My husband ordered the tortellini cotto that had the most delicious creamy pesto sauce that was the best I’ve ever had!! I was super impressed with the food, the service and the wine selection. This will easily become one of my favorites and I’m looking forward to going back with other couples for a fantastic night out enjoying wonderfully prepared dishes! This one is not to be missed!!

Loralee

I was referred here, and it did not disappoint. The food was delicious. My husband had the veal parmigiana, and I had the cauliflower pizza, which is to die for. Our new go-to place even though we're in Massapequa.

Andrea C

Staff is great. The entrance to pick up is a little tight, but the store is immaculate. The food is good, they could use more sauce. The cost is not too high, but it could be better.

Rachel Pellot

We ordered a round pie and rice balls. We paid for and received a square pie and rice balls. Didn't know until we got home. They kindly offered to fix it, but we assured them they didn't have to. The square was smaller and thinner than what you would expect to get for the price. The rice balls were small and ok. Not worth the price.

Michael Gendron

Gino's always has great pizza, whether you go to Ronkonkoma or Seaford. Great staff that is always friendly, attentive and helpful. They have so many choices in specialty pizza. Buffalo chicken, chicken marsala, bacon chicken cheddar. Great white pizza. Great crust on the pizza. Stop by for a slice!

Dana car

Went here for the first time. Pizza was good however I got a small ceasar salad that was extremely small for $15.00. Its one thing if its an antipasto salad being all the meats etc but a ceasar salad? And when I tell you small, its was 12 oz if that. When I told the front guy thats a little crazy he told me thats what everywhere charges, when thats not the truth and if they do charge its a bigger portion. Then I guess the manager came over and looked annoyed that I didnt want it, oh well, its 15.00 shouldn't make or break you. He then told me he will refund me and I can leave lol Fast forward 2 weeks later no refund. They probably need it more than me so leaving it alone and not calling to follow up. Just know better next time.

Mike Feran

We had several family members meet for dinner in the rear dining room. The room was nice looking but right away we realized it was very loud and echo sounding even with only a few diners eating. Our group could hardly hear the server going over specials. The biggest problem was our family group could barely hear each other talking at our own table. The service was ok, and the server was friendly but did not seem very experienced. The food came out at a good time and was well prepared for the most part, but it was nothing very special that would make it stand out. The server did come back once towards the end to check on us after we got our food, but one annoyance was they seemed to be in a rush to constantly come and take away dishes even before we were finished eating. Overall, it would be a nice place, but until they get some remodeling of the dining room to remove the echoing noise of the harsh hard walls we won't be back.

Rich Castillo

Currently eating chicken parm so mediocre I had to leave a review. There is barely enough mozzarella for one of the two pieces of “chicken parm” in the tray. The sauce is bland. Next time my parents ask if I want food from this place I am definitely saying no.

Hannah Ibrahim

Sorry but if I can mold my pizza dough into any shape I please after it’s been “cooked” and delivered to me that is not ok. And no this is not a photo of the cheese. Two stars only because the manager or owner whoever I spoke to on the phone sent a new one and a comp dessert (which honestly is the least he can do on a $70 order of 2 pies) but if he is reading this, try not to be so defensive to the ones letting you know of YOUR mistake! Even if you’ve “only heard this twice in 10 years” that is twice too many nor should I as a paying customer be made to feel accused of lying. Sent this one back with the driver just to prove my point. And by the way this is not even the first time I’ve had this problem at Gino’s Seaford. Not coming back here again thanks to his arrogant attitude. Humility goes a long way in business

Steven Damiano

Got a buffalo chicken pizza and half dozen garlic knots. Was really looking forward to trying this place but unfortunately I was catfished by instagram and Dave portnoy. Its a shame because the pie did have potential, however it was dry as all hell. Buffalo chicken itself was tasty, but again dry. Pizza had no kind of sauce on it whatsoever. It was just bread, cheese and chicken. No ranch drizzle, no sauce base. One and done for me. Not worth the $38 price tag, I’d rather spend my hard earned money at Umberto’s.

Angel Alvarado

This place is an absolute joke lol charging extreme prices for kids size serving. Definitely would not recommend. Just for reference lunch size spaghetti & meatballs $15 for one meatball and a handful of spaghetti that can barely feed toddler. Picture: actual size

Scott Hunter

THEY TAKE YOUR PHONE NUMBER YOU GIVE WHEN YOU MAKE AN ORDER AND TEXT YOU ADS. HEY I GAVE MY PHONE NUMBER FOR AN ORDER, NOT TO GET ADS. EVERY1 STAY AWAY FROM THIS MONEY GRUBBING GARBAGE PLACE!!!!!!!! IT OK, I MADE A COMPLAINT ABOUT THIS WITH THE FCC. GOOD LUCK WITH THEM

Anthony M

Family ordered several pies for an occasion. There is literally no sauce on the pizzas. Dried dough with cheese.. Will never patronize, how do they stay in business. The employees must be writing the good reviews.