great as always. really yummy burger

Great food and staff is very professional

Very good food, good service, vibes, decor

Staff's really good to get long with :D

Tasty food!! Kudos to the Chèf. Staff is friendly. Prices are very reasonable. Negra Modelo was ice cold - proper to the meal :).

What a great little place. If you go you have to try their breakfast. I forget the name but its essentially a breakfast soup and it was fantastic.

One of the best diner in Brooklyn

I LOVEEEEEEE THE FOOOD AMAZING I WOULD EAT THERE EVERY SINGLE DAYYY LIKE THE PEOPLE THERE AARE SO NICE KIND AND WELCOMING.

Jeez the food was sooo GOOD! they prepared the food with Love & Skill. Staff is so friendly & welcoming 😉 this place is GREAT! 💯✔

The owner Victor and his staff will know how to treat you. Very cool, good and cheap place in Columbia Waterfront. We recommend!

Excellent food and drinks. Great location. Friendly staff. Super clean Bathroom:) Loved it!!!

Great breakfast selection, delicious food and, very important now, great terrace with table service. Will return for dinner soon.

Great breakfast food. Excellent service with a friendly atmosphere

The menu is so diverse at Mex Carroll's Diner. I recommend the food from the Mexican corner. Delicious. Staff very friendly.

Always nice service good food and good drinks..I go often cause their service food drinks and hospitality is worth it period.

Best breakfast in all of Brooklyn!

This is the BEST diner in Cobble Hill/ Carroll Gardens. Excellent food and friendly service.

Great food. Extensive menu. Will satisfy any palate.

The food was very good and good portions. And very friendly. Will go again.

If it wasn't for Covid . I would HAVE LOVED TO SIT IN. Fantastic burgers n bar!

I called in an order for delivery. The girl on the phone was super pleasant. Our order came fast. My flatuas were thick and crunchy. My friends torta was huge and chicken was tender. All and all, great experience and I will order when in this neighborhood.

Great selection on the menu. Food was delicious. Service was excellent and the garden at the rear is a little oasis! Don't be out off by the exterior this place is definitely worth a visit and a revisit.

I really can't say enough about the food and service, I have eaten in, taken out, and had delivered and every time the food and service has been excellent. My only warning is to check the prices because the prices online have not been updated and it is more expensive than the online menu indicates.

A neighborhood favorite that goes beyond. They kept us all fed during Covid and we have not forgotten. Thanks for being the diner we can count on.

We are happy to have such a great neighbor. This Mexican American diner is good and the staff is very friendly. They have a very nice backyard, so enjoyable during the summer time!

Excellent food and friendly staff. Wide selection of Mexican and American food. The chicken and waffles were fantastic. Most of my friends like the breakfast sandwiches and burritos.

We love the nachos here--chorizo, chicken tinga, or veggie--they're all excellent! The chicken pozole soup is so great on a cold day. When the weather is beautiful nothing beats sitting in their gorgeous back garden. My 6 yr old daughter says their grilled cheese is extra delicious too--super buttery!

Found the place by accident looking for a place to have breakfast . What a delicious and pleasant surprise for me and my family just looking to get a bite to eat. Food , service , ambiance were fantastic . Highly recommended .

My morning go to place for breakfast. Fast delivery , service is good when dining in. Lovely back yard seating. Very cozy

Great local place to chill and have diner or Mexican food. I took a star away because some of the things are expensive such as a tradition 2 eggs, potatoes, toast, and bacon dish can run $15

Classic Diner menu with Mexican specialties, everything delicious and reasonably priced. Fast and friendly service. Great addition to the neighborhood. Best breakfasts in the area.

Nice place to get American food. But also a great variety of Mexican dishes like Enchiladas, Tacos, Nachos.... So much choice. If you like meat, get the steak mexican style: with onions, tomatos and jalapeño, served with rice, beans, guacamole and tortillas. Pretty generous!

I just love this place amazing food from this little hidden gem, great service with a smile and the food is worth the price. They have an extensive menu with great options.

The menu is HUGE. So many great choices. The staff is professional, accommodating and family friendly. I recommend coming to dine as opposed to ordering for delivery.

This is our go to place, excellent food and drinks. Me and my family have been going here since day 1 that they have opened.

Skip the diner section and get some amazing Mexican food here. Love this place as my go-to taco joint. Still love this place

Decent breakfast, nice backyard atmosphere

Best Mexican food and drinks in Red Hook.

I'm continually amazed at how good the food is here. For a menu this extensive, it's quite an achievement. Eggs are always perfectly cooked. Toast is perfectly toasted. All the diner mainstays are better than the other diners do them. (Don't believe me? Come on down!) Current fave is the Greenwood Wrap, no sausage. Lunch is yummy. Dinner is filling and satisfying. *Full bar at all hours!* Caveat: we almost always eat in or carry out; don't have much experience with delivery, BUT I watch these guys work hard for every order.

I come in a few times a week for breakfast! I always dine in and the staff are always extremely kind, attentive & thoughtful! Food is always delicious! Have mainly had omelettes & tried the burger. Always get the iced coffee! Can’t recommend this place enough!

Friendly, efficient service, great food and a beautiful, quiet oasis out back. Highly recommended

Nice charming diner! I always get the Mexican Omelet with jalapenos - scrumptious! The service is super outstanding! Great for a quick meeting with a friend or date to have meaningful discussion - very relaxed atmosphere!

Delicious and we love the staff and patio!

So nice and accommodating and the food tastes great. Massive portions and very fast service. An ideal diner in all respects with every possible thing you could want on the menu.

This was our first visit to Mex Carroll, we were visitors to the area and happened upon the restaurant while walking the neighborhood and looking for a lunch spot. We found the food to be incredible and the service was top-notch! Our party of four ordered the Al Pastor Burrito, a Tinga Burrito Bowl, chicken quesadilla, and chips with salsa - we were all very pleased with the food! The menu is not only Mexican, it is an incredible variety of breakfast items, burgers, pasta, and literally something for everyone. I cannot say enough about the incredible service and would make a point of eating here again when in the neighborhood!

Just moved here from out of state, and can’t say enough good things about this place!!! It’s authentic and I feel right at home! 12/10 baby!!

The food was excellent. I had the turkey sausage, scrambled eggs and pancakes. The pancakes were cooked to perfection and a bit crunchy at the bottom just the way I like it. The prices are reasonable. Found this place by just driving through the neighborhood. Also the variety of Mexican food is amazing. Gives you the option of American and Mexican food.

Reviews are all over the place on Mex Carroll's Diner. Can tell you this though, our meals were definitely 5 stars. Didn't look at the reviews before going here and glad we didn't as we might have passed it up. We were meeting with an attorney nearby and when we left we asked her about it. She noted she has eaten there many times and it was very good. She also mentioned it was a "Mexican Diner". Didn't quite grasped what was meant by this, but when we got the menu we understood. Whoa, tremendous menu. Over 20 different types of omelettes, 7 different eggs benedict variations, at least twenty different burger styles, pasta dishes, etc. Something for everyone. Never knew something like a "Mexican Diner" existed. Nice concept. As mentioned previously our meals were 5 star. The same could be said for the service and dining atmosphere. We ate outside in their backyard courtyard. Pleasantly decorated and comfortable. Surrounded by greenery and most of the tables had large umbrellas to keep the sun from beaming down on you. No issues with the service provide by the wait staff. On our way out we were wished a good a good day. We had brunch which was an order of Huevos Rancheros and Eggs Benedict. Had a choice of red or green salsa to go with the Huevos Rancheros. Went with the green which was perfect. Not too spicy, but not bland either. It came with refried beans and yellow rice. Both were a delight. Ordered a fresh squeezed orange juice that was as fresh squeezed should be...in other words really good. Mexican Diner with tons of Mexican breakfast choices and what does my wife order...Eggs Benedict! Well, I guess that's the point of a diner. Lots of choices. Verdict on the Eggs Benedict was a thumbs up. Very good with no complaints. BTW...Might have to put some of the one star reviews in context. One person left a one star because they wouldn't let him use the bathroom. Just came in off the street and wasn't going to order anything. Really? Also there are complaints about the prices. We thought they were reasonable especially considering the portion size. Check out the menu and you decide.

Chicken Quesadillas On Spinach Wrap & Cheese Fries 🔥 🔥 Fresh & Always Good.

Breakfast was great.I ordered Crab Benedict and was brought out Salmon Benedict with home fries.I was hungry and ate it anyways.It was fabulous!

Kerry B

This was our first visit to Mex Carroll, we were visitors to the area and happened upon the restaurant while walking the neighborhood and looking for a lunch spot. We found the food to be incredible and the service was top-notch! Our party of four ordered the Al Pastor Burrito, a Tinga Burrito Bowl, chicken quesadilla, and chips with salsa - we were all very pleased with the food! The menu is not only Mexican, it is an incredible variety of breakfast items, burgers, pasta, and literally something for everyone. I cannot say enough about the incredible service and would make a point of eating here again when in the neighborhood!

Riaz Mohammed

The food was excellent. I had the turkey sausage, scrambled eggs and pancakes. The pancakes were cooked to perfection and a bit crunchy at the bottom just the way I like it. The prices are reasonable. Found this place by just driving through the neighborhood. Also the variety of Mexican food is amazing. Gives you the option of American and Mexican food.

mimi tann

Reviews are all over the place on Mex Carroll's Diner. Can tell you this though, our meals were definitely 5 stars. Didn't look at the reviews before going here and glad we didn't as we might have passed it up. We were meeting with an attorney nearby and when we left we asked her about it. She noted she has eaten there many times and it was very good. She also mentioned it was a "Mexican Diner". Didn't quite grasped what was meant by this, but when we got the menu we understood. Whoa, tremendous menu. Over 20 different types of omelettes, 7 different eggs benedict variations, at least twenty different burger styles, pasta dishes, etc. Something for everyone. Never knew something like a "Mexican Diner" existed. Nice concept. As mentioned previously our meals were 5 star. The same could be said for the service and dining atmosphere. We ate outside in their backyard courtyard. Pleasantly decorated and comfortable. Surrounded by greenery and most of the tables had large umbrellas to keep the sun from beaming down on you. No issues with the service provide by the wait staff. On our way out we were wished a good a good day. We had brunch which was an order of Huevos Rancheros and Eggs Benedict. Had a choice of red or green salsa to go with the Huevos Rancheros. Went with the green which was perfect. Not too spicy, but not bland either. It came with refried beans and yellow rice. Both were a delight. Ordered a fresh squeezed orange juice that was as fresh squeezed should be...in other words really good. Mexican Diner with tons of Mexican breakfast choices and what does my wife order...Eggs Benedict! Well, I guess that's the point of a diner. Lots of choices. Verdict on the Eggs Benedict was a thumbs up. Very good with no complaints. BTW...Might have to put some of the one star reviews in context. One person left a one star because they wouldn't let him use the bathroom. Just came in off the street and wasn't going to order anything. Really? Also there are complaints about the prices. We thought they were reasonable especially considering the portion size. Check out the menu and you decide.

Diamond Phoenix

Chicken Quesadillas On Spinach Wrap & Cheese Fries 🔥 🔥 Fresh & Always Good.

Tony Zambino

Breakfast was great.I ordered Crab Benedict and was brought out Salmon Benedict with home fries.I was hungry and ate it anyways.It was fabulous!

What a hidden gem on the waterfront. I’ve lived here for years and never came in until recently and now we are regulars !! The food is TOP NOTCH. Nothing fresher in the neighborhood here for Mexican. Absolutely love the sweet staff!!

It's like a Greek diner, but Mexican instead. The same friendly folks have run this place for years. Super neighborhoody joint. In nice weather there's a great backyard garden.

This pleasant place showed up in my yelp search. Group dining creates financial synergy here. They give generous amounts at standard prices. Personnel were willing to adjust while providing excellent attention. I'm completely taken with this spot.

This place has the best Breakfast Burritos! They use quality ingredients and service is amazing—friendly and efficient!

Quick and attentive service, we had the #4 burrito and the red hook sandwich, both were delicious. Kids loved the pancakes. Wifey also had the #1 juice, which was crisp and refreshing. Best diner in the neighborhood by far.

This is a very good Mexican restaurant, food amazing and prices low.

Honestly I'm ashamed I haven't left a review sooner. We've had breakfast and lunch here but for the first time had dinner delivered tonight. I got the ribeye, seasoned and cooked perfectly, my gf got the meatloaf both were absolutely delicious. The sauteed broccoli was seasoned and cooked perfectly and the mashed potatoes were creamy. I've never had bad food here only delicious food. The service is always 10/10!

Matt Scott

It's like a Greek diner, but Mexican instead. The same friendly folks have run this place for years. Super neighborhoody joint. In nice weather there's a great backyard garden.

Lucas Darmayan

This is a very good Mexican restaurant, food amazing and prices low.

Marie Patanio

This place has the best Breakfast Burritos! They use quality ingredients and service is amazing—friendly and efficient!

Ana Butler

This pleasant place showed up in my yelp search. Group dining creates financial synergy here. They give generous amounts at standard prices. Personnel were willing to adjust while providing excellent attention. I'm completely taken with this spot.

Aaron Messing

Quick and attentive service, we had the #4 burrito and the red hook sandwich, both were delicious. Kids loved the pancakes. Wifey also had the #1 juice, which was crisp and refreshing. Best diner in the neighborhood by far.

Dan Siraco

Honestly I'm ashamed I haven't left a review sooner. We've had breakfast and lunch here but for the first time had dinner delivered tonight. I got the ribeye, seasoned and cooked perfectly, my gf got the meatloaf both were absolutely delicious. The sauteed broccoli was seasoned and cooked perfectly and the mashed potatoes were creamy. I've never had bad food here only delicious food. The service is always 10/10!

charlotte rose Sheils

I come in a few times a week for breakfast! I always dine in and the staff are always extremely kind, attentive & thoughtful! Food is always delicious! Have mainly had omelettes & tried the burger. Always get the iced coffee! Can’t recommend this place enough!

Jeffrey Allen

I'm continually amazed at how good the food is here. For a menu this extensive, it's quite an achievement. Eggs are always perfectly cooked. Toast is perfectly toasted. All the diner mainstays are better than the other diners do them. (Don't believe me? Come on down!) Current fave is the Greenwood Wrap, no sausage. Lunch is yummy. Dinner is filling and satisfying. *Full bar at all hours!* Caveat: we almost always eat in or carry out; don't have much experience with delivery, BUT I watch these guys work hard for every order.

Amazing place and tasty food. Great staff and service.

Good food, quiet garden, good service

Nice. A bit expensive. Lovely patio.

nice people, decent fresh food

My Mexican eggs were tasty, filling, and reasonably priced, and the food came out quickly.

All day dining with Mexican specialties, along with American diner classics. Friendly, thoughtful service.

I like the food, Mexican. Clean and nice interiors and bathroom. Price a bit on the high end.

Nice and cozy restuarant. Was a good landing spot after a fun morning and for the FIFA World Cup...TV ON

I am an aficionado of Chili con Carne, no rice, no cheese, just chopped onion sprinkling on top. Delicious.

The food tasted good, but it was a little too pricey.

I had there protein omelet w home fries very good size came quick w my 3 other family members. Never been in that part of Brooklyn but it was recommended some one street to check it out.

Very good food and good service. Easy to get a table at 11:00 am on a Sunday, the jalapeño omelette was solid, and the home fries were pretty good. Very laid-back atmosphere and the decor was on point. Bonus points for having a liquor license (full bar) at a place that is relatively out of the way near the Columbia St. Waterfront. I'll definitely be back for dinner and margaritas.

Coming in to this place one can't help but notice and feel the very friendly staff. As soon as I walked in I was greeted with a big smile and hello, perhaps for some that's not very important but for someone like me, it just adds more to the experience. The inside is very nice with nice seating and spacious. One also has the option to sit out in the patio, which is something I didn't think could be nice, but as I stepped outside I was left mesmerized as they have a very nice space and a garden. Now on to the food, the food was really good, they always have breakfast anytime which is great as I like to get my breakfast around late in the afternoon. They have a Mexican corner in the menu, and quite frankly it was very good! I tried the steak tacos, and they were tasty, they come in three, and the best part is they are authentic Mexican tacos, just the more better. All in all, this place is definitely something I would recommend to everyone.

This was our second time here. One of greats of the neighbourhood. The service isn't urgent but they are definitely nice. The food is absolutely great. An order today was slightly messed up with the ingredients but otherwise, it was still great food. The place has the diner atmosphere going for it with the bar that could give off good nightlife vibes. Their fridges also have great selection of their cultured beverages which I think is great. Definitely go to this place.!

Ayana L W S B

This was our second time here. One of greats of the neighbourhood. The service isn't urgent but they are definitely nice. The food is absolutely great. An order today was slightly messed up with the ingredients but otherwise, it was still great food. The place has the diner atmosphere going for it with the bar that could give off good nightlife vibes. Their fridges also have great selection of their cultured beverages which I think is great. Definitely go to this place.!

The food is fine, but entirely overpriced

Ive has good experiences here and less than stellar. The menu on the website is outdated with incorrect prices. The food is usually good, but theyve made mistakes and wont admit to it. If they could be a little more consistent and update their website, would be quite good.

I order food from here regularly food good. Just prices are a bit high for diner . 2.25 for a can soda. Waffle and sausage almost 20dollars. Can eat cheaper at ihop

Nothing special diner, food was as expected, prices decent, place was empty, not another person say down the whole time I was there, but a few to go orders. Why only 3 stars? Staff was too busy looking at their phones to notice me, I sat for a really long time waiting for things. If I asked for stuff, they noticed when I spoke up, but I just got tired of having to raise my voice over the bad disco music to get anything. They also brought my check without asking if I wanted dessert. It was almost as if they would have been happier if I didn't come in and disturb their quiet, peaceful night.

Cool place, service wasn't that great, but doable. Food okay, but not great, like I might have expected. The back dining area was nice looking, but it needed music to set in the moment. Little improvements will go a long way. Price ranges equals the atmosphere. Better atmosphere and more quality service can change that place to a high-end restaurant...

Miguel Pedroza

Cool place, service wasn't that great, but doable. Food okay, but not great, like I might have expected. The back dining area was nice looking, but it needed music to set in the moment. Little improvements will go a long way. Price ranges equals the atmosphere. Better atmosphere and more quality service can change that place to a high-end restaurant...

Good food, bad service. The server was rude and kept rushing my wife to make a decision on what to eat. Then she continually ignored my wife throughout the course of our meal. The food was good but not good enough for us to ignore the poor service. Sadly to say we will not be visiting this establishment again!

The place looks cool, we dined at the backyard, however service was slow, I got the wrong order, and had no refill on my coffee... I didn't complain, and ate the wrong food, it was ok, not flavorful and definitely not Mexican inspired flavor.... I wish the food was like in Mexico, spicy and with powerful flavors. Food is over priced... not worth it!!! I won't go back and cannot recommend this place.... Grilled chicken breast and vegetables... Salt and pepper, green salsa or red salsa would made this one delicious, however it didn't come with sauce or flavors

Eli Brown

The place looks cool, we dined at the backyard, however service was slow, I got the wrong order, and had no refill on my coffee... I didn't complain, and ate the wrong food, it was ok, not flavorful and definitely not Mexican inspired flavor.... I wish the food was like in Mexico, spicy and with powerful flavors. Food is over priced... not worth it!!! I won't go back and cannot recommend this place.... Grilled chicken breast and vegetables... Salt and pepper, green salsa or red salsa would made this one delicious, however it didn't come with sauce or flavors

VERY priced, very slow, and mediocre food at best..$10.45 for a BASIC, run of the mill bacon, egg, and cheese on a roll is just pathetic and ridiculous

The bacon was burnt, the customer service was beyond disgusting, came before and it was great but the morning time it was absolutely terrible. Waste of time and money, absolutely wouldn’t recommend

4$ for a large hot coffee. Really??? You have alot of nerve last time.

My wife and I went here for the first time this morning. We walked in to and empty restaurant. They sat us and handed us the menu. We were looking at the menu for no more than 3-5 minutes before I hear the manager say in Spanish what these people need more than 30 minutes to order? The hostess laughs along with the comment. I'm an Argentine/Ecuadorian that speaks fluent Spanish. I understood this whole exchange and became extremely irritated and told my wife I didn't feel comfortable eating there . So we left . Running a restaurant that seems to be empty you should do everything possible to make your customers feel happy and welcome to repeat business and to spread word of a good restaurant. We regularly eat breakfast and like to find new places but this location is somewhere I definitely will never go back too.

Ordered grilled chicken sandwich, the chicken was not cooked fully and sloppily presented, also ordered a baked potato, which was not baked but boiled! Was served margarine instead of butter! this was the most awful meal I have ever eaten! I just left worked that day extremely hungry and decided to stop at this dinner that was close by.

This the second time I ordered breakfast from them and their was egg shells in my eggs. My avocado was half brown. Definitely not worth the price of food food at all. Disgusted!

These people have forgotten how to be human. The place was empty at 12 pm on a Sunday and they flatly refused to let me use their restroom without a purchase. Well within their rights, of course.

I will NEVER order from here again after finding what appeared to be a dirty string of dental floss IN MY GRILLED CHEESE! I had just taken a bite…there was no missing it. I had to have been purposely put there. Dental floss doesn’t just magically appear in melted cheese. Absolutely disgusting and sickening. I will never order from these guys again. They’re scummy, shady, petty, and clearly can’t be trusted making food for people.

The food was terrible it honestly made me and my girlfriend sick. The shrimp wasn’t seasoned and was not cooked correctly while the rice also tasted bland and the beans lacked flavor! I ordered a burger and asked for medium and ended up receiving rare which wasn’t a big deal but the cooks need to learn how to correctly cook the meat. The servers on the other hand were very friendly and welcoming

I am consuming one of the worst breakfasts I’ve eaten in years. The English muffin on my Benedict is so stale and hard I can’t cut through it with a steak knife. My side of sausage is so dry and over cooked I decided to throw it out. The order took 20 minutes past the time the website stated it would. That would not have been an issue if the food had been edible but it wasn’t so I’m including it. They did follow our requests for items being on the side and extra sauces. The delivery person was friendly. I will never eat here again though.

2 eggs sandwiches nothing on it $14.95 is diabolical im going to assume its the main reason there always empty , fix your prices owner ! dont just say thank you !

Beautiful place, wonderful staff, but their food is unseasoned and their menu prices are off (expect everything to be $2-4 more expensive than it is on the menu). The chicken we got was horribly overcooked (to the point of being hard) as well.

Sum Body

2 eggs sandwiches nothing on it $14.95 is diabolical im going to assume its the main reason there always empty , fix your prices owner ! dont just say thank you !

Jonathan Raybaud

Beautiful place, wonderful staff, but their food is unseasoned and their menu prices are off (expect everything to be $2-4 more expensive than it is on the menu). The chicken we got was horribly overcooked (to the point of being hard) as well.

Garth Rathkey

I am consuming one of the worst breakfasts I’ve eaten in years. The English muffin on my Benedict is so stale and hard I can’t cut through it with a steak knife. My side of sausage is so dry and over cooked I decided to throw it out. The order took 20 minutes past the time the website stated it would. That would not have been an issue if the food had been edible but it wasn’t so I’m including it. They did follow our requests for items being on the side and extra sauces. The delivery person was friendly. I will never eat here again though.

Jonathan Flores

The food was terrible it honestly made me and my girlfriend sick. The shrimp wasn’t seasoned and was not cooked correctly while the rice also tasted bland and the beans lacked flavor! I ordered a burger and asked for medium and ended up receiving rare which wasn’t a big deal but the cooks need to learn how to correctly cook the meat. The servers on the other hand were very friendly and welcoming