Best Italian Restaurants in Buffalo

4.4 avg. rating 24 restaurants 24,003 reviews
Looking for the best Italian restaurants in Buffalo? Browse our curated list of 24 top-rated Italian spots. The average rating is 4.4/5 based on 24,003 real Google reviews. From casual eateries to fine dining, find the perfect Italian restaurant for any occasion.

What people say

Daryl

This was my first time eating at this restaurant. The ambiance, service and our wonderful server David, who explained certain aspects of the menu very well, and answered any questions we had. The portions of each dish were perfect. The food was properly seasoned, especially the sauces. The wild boar...

About San Marco Ristorante

Alison Potter

A new favorite! Dave, our server was knowledgeable and helpful. Food was beyond- scallops and tiger shrimp over angel hair pasta was delicious. We had gnocchi and ravioli filled with banana peppers for appetizers. Would highly recommend the ravioli. Looking forward to going back!

About San Marco Ristorante

road warrior

The food is excellent. The venison special was the best venison I have ever tasted. Veal saltimbocca was excellent. Not one bad thing to say about any of the food at our table. The owner personally greets everyone. The staff was very friendly. We will be back.

About San Marco Ristorante

Xiao Li

Personally, under a strict rating criteria, I will give 9.0 out of 10 to San Marco. The service here first class and food is amazing. Only shortcoming is the desert tiramisu here might not use coffee liquor when they making it, so the taste is lacking that specific level. Passion fruit sorbet is the...

About San Marco Ristorante

Bill Knitter

Amazing classic Italian place, intimate, with some awesome tasty dishes. This is the best Italian food I've had in Buffalo.

About San Marco Ristorante