Best Italian Restaurants in Buffalo

4.4 avg. rating 24 restaurants 24,003 reviews
Looking for the best Italian restaurants in Buffalo? Browse our curated list of 24 top-rated Italian spots. The average rating is 4.4/5 based on 24,003 real Google reviews. From casual eateries to fine dining, find the perfect Italian restaurant for any occasion.

What people say

Adam Gier

From the moment we walked into San Marco we had a warm, welcoming and wonderful experience! Service was attentive, friendly and fast, and the food was exceptional. A vast wine selection complemented our meals, and all of this for a very fair price. I would certainly recommend stopping in to San Marc...

About San Marco Ristorante

JOHN Riccione

I have not lived in Buffalo for 30+ years, but had the pleasure of visiting for a Bills’ game with a friend and client to whom I wanted to showcase the food here. We dined at San Marco and were greeted warmly by Frank. The welcome was rivaled only by the food and outstanding service. Everything from...

About San Marco Ristorante

Nicholas Capozzi

Excellent evening out with friends. My wife and I along with another couple enjoyed a Friday evening dinner. The food was really good. Taste and nice portion sizes. The team of wait staff really knew their stuff and helped us make a few decisions. For apps we tried two different kinds of raviolis, t...

About San Marco Ristorante

Noah Safraniec

If I could give more stars for atmosphere I would… this is a very comfortable space and it accommodates a lot of tables without feeling crowded. There are multiple dining rooms and the one we were in was magnificent. We loved the floor to ceiling shelves that were used to store the wine and the ston...

About San Marco Ristorante

Erson “Dr. E” Religioso III

Great ambience! Love the family owned business! Great service and very friendly! Every room that I saw had only 4-5 tables so even when busy it wouldn't be loud. Amazing menu and the portions are perfect. Actually much smaller than typical more for your eyes than stomach Italian Fare. But you don't...

About San Marco Ristorante