Rebecca Leigh

Food, staff, comfort of atmosphere all great! Ribeye, angel hair w/Aristocrat sauce, rolls, even the lemonade - all excellent. Definitely worth the wander in with great surprise. Every staff member that was on the floor, came to check to make sure everything was OK throughout dinner but not in an overbearing way. That hasn’t happen anywhere else I’ve ever been and I’m in my 50s & a foodie. Genuinely impressed.

Gretchen Counts

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We absolutely love Nick’s Italian Restaurant in Pilot Point! The food is always fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked — you can truly taste the homemade touch in every dish. 🍝 The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the cozy atmosphere makes it the perfect spot for date night or dinner with family. Highly recommend the baked ziti — it’s amazing every single time! 🙌

Daniel Cunningham

This place is fantastic! Not only is the food excellent, but the restaurant staff works together seamlessly—everyone’s consistently on their game, from the kitchen to the tables. The pizza is incredible. The crust has amazing flavor—crisp on the outside, tender inside, and so good you could eat it on its own. Combined with fresh toppings and a perfectly balanced sauce, it’s some of the best pizza I’ve had in North Texas. The complimentary garlic bread is phenomenal—warm, buttery, and packed with flavor. Our whole family loves it. The pastas are delicious, and the warm New York Salad is a must-try. If you go with the house salad instead, their dressing is outstanding. This isn’t just good Italian food for Pilot Point—it’s truly exceptional Italian food, period. And that’s coming from a former food writer.

Keith D Bartlett

The Chicken Murphy is excellent. My wife said he lobster ravioli was also excellent. It is a popular local restaurant. We went on a Friday evening during football season and it was a little loud due to high school football families getting a good meal before going to watch their kids play ball.

Andrew Claeys

Great fresh Italian food! Pasta tastes homemade and their sauces are incredible! Good service and prices. Meats are all great quality as well! And don't forget the garlic rolls!

Glen Gonthier

Went for lunch. I had the pizza special, small pizza two toppings, salad and garlic rolls. (which we split) and she ordered a single manicotti. The food was great and the bill even better, under $20. Wish they weren’t 30 miles away, but we’ll be back.

J D

I came here from out of town and this place was recommended. The service was excellent and we really enjoyed the main course. The owner came by to check on us and he was very kind. It’s BYOB. I look forward to coming back next time we’re in town!

Conner Belt

Don’t be fooled by this being a small town Italian restaurant in rural Texas. This place is legit and some of the best Italian food around. The people are super nice and it’s a great place to either dine in or take out. It does get busy but that’s only proof for how good it is.

Cee Gee

Wonderful dining experience. Positive, friendly and welcoming atmosphere, with plenty of space and two dining areas. Delicious food with generous portions. Very attentive staff. Baskets of warm rolls with garlic infused butter for all tables. Booths, plus round and square tables. Nice restrooms, disabled accessible. Plenty of parking, and accessible parking. Old fashioned gumball machines. The restaurant is closed on Sundays & Mondays; additionally closed for an hour from 2:30 PM- 3:30 PM, Tuesday - Saturday.

Kelsea Knight

Nick’s is a fantastic Italian restaurant with the best garlic knots! The staff is friendly and we had the best service on a Saturday night for a table of 9. 10/10 would highly recommend! The pizza is very tasty.

S

The manicotti, lasagna, lobster ravioli, and rolls were great! Wasn’t the biggest fan of the cheese sticks and I should have went with my gut and gotten calamari. Everyone was attentive and manager or owner came out and greeted all the tables.

Adam Shadows

What a great gem for an Italian restaurant in Pilot Point! Nick's had great pasta dishes, fast friendly service, and a clean, wholesome establishment.

diasya

The atmosphere is so friendly and welcoming! The food is unbelievably tasty and there are lots of dishes in the menu to choose from. Just awesome experience! I was so happy to visit this place. Love it!

Gwendlyn m

Great friendly service drinks never got empty food was delish. Very large portions didn’t skimp out ill have leftovers for days. Very generous amount of chicken and the shrimp I added to my chicken Murphy dish.

Delaina Stone

It is very busy here but it’s because the food is good. We tried pizza lasagna, salad and f course the garlic bread. Everything was good. The service was good and Nick the owner is great.

+1

vanessa ramirez

Today was my second time going to this restaurant. It was just as good as the first time. It wasn't very busy when we went. To start they give you about four bread rolls with butter, its so good! My husband and two kids shared a large pizza and still had some leftover. The pizza was very flavorful, my favorite was the crust. It had nice bite to it. I got the chicken florentine. Its was so amazing, I highly recommended that. My favorite part about it was the lemon butter noodles and spinach. Online it says no dine-in but you can dine-in, I called to make sure. Great food and nice workers

Dj Williams

Nick and his family are extremely fun to be around and the food is amazing. Enjoyed lobster ravioli, it was incredibly delicious, fresh and great flavor. Go here first if you want great service, amazing food & good peeps.