I really like most of the slices I’ve had here, cheese was great, grandma was great, margherita was great. Good size, sauce is flavorful, crust has a great texture. I prefer this place to the fancier one across the street. HOWEVER the spinach slice here was really bad, way too much spinach on it. I love vegetables usually but it’s a ridiculous amount. The seating area is a little dingy but nothing terrible. This isn’t fine dining, get over it. Prices are reasonable if a bit high. Hours are fantastic, they’re always open when you need a quick bite. Solid neighborhood staple.

Realist Fakes

Real good pizza, but often served lukewarm. Gotta ask for it extra hot and even then they often don’t oblige. Still gets 4 stars for really good pizza

Andrew Walker

Not the best pizza in the city. Not even the best pizza in the UWS. HOWEVER, they have a very good pepperoni slice. I can't speak to the other varieties they offer, but the pepperoni is almost always a solid bet that rivals some of the best in the city. I'm also a huge fan of how they have an extensive condiment station, one of the best in the city.

Awini Ambuj Shanker

Some pizzas are better than the others, overall pretty decent pizzas, slices could be a little bigger, that said, it's fair value for money for NYC. As a tourist if you take a little longer to gather your bearings and order, the staff can be a little curt, especially the fellow at the till. They have a fair variety of pizzas, that's why it can take a little longer to decide what you want if you are new to the place!

+1

Angeliki Traveler

Two regular slices and soda special for $6.50 a rare gem for Manhattan! Good pizza and good staff. Will be coming back here.

Ion Craciun

Twice I order from these guys via Slice app and they screw up the order. First, I order a $10.00 Caesar salad and receive just a bowl of chopped Romaine lettuce—no croutons, Parmesan cheese, tomatoes. Second, I order 3 slices and a $2.50 bottle of Dasani water to make the order minimum. The delivery guy shows up with no water. In short, the pizza is good, but the takeout is dubious. They might screw up your order and steal your money.

A Cervantes G

I don’t know if this pizza place was having a rough night but the restaurant didn’t look really clean. I am writing this review the day after and I didn’t get sick after this pizza. Here are some pictures. The pizza was good tho.

Stopped in last night. Out of about 40 tables 37 of them were covered in dirt & crumbs, another table had empty beer bottles. The floor was covered in dirt, crumbs, used napkins, pepperoni, you name it. 2 guys behind the counter, 1 was in charge of the pizza & working. The register guy just stood there switching between staring at the TV & his phone. Only 4 other customers inside. You're gonna tell me there was no time to wipe down the tables & sweep? Filthy, lazy, unacceptable. And don't blame the storm, simple cleaning does not take that much time. If that's the front of house, imagine the back. Never again.

I really should have read the reviews because this is the worst pizza I've ever had since moving to New York City a few years ago. Absolutely awful. The White Slice tasted like a grilled cheese sandwich

Aaron Judell

This place is upcharging customers, and hoping they don’t notice. The menu literally says $4.99 for a jalapeño pepperoni slice, but they tried to charge me $6.23, and they said it was because of "tax". That's 25% tax. When I complained and pointed out the clearly displayed price on their sign, the cashier said he's just "doing what the owner said". Then he pointed to a sign on the register that said "5% surcharge for credit cards", but when I said I was paying with cash, he said it's the same price either way. They said if I didn’t like the price(their incorrect price) I could leave. This place is straight up scamming customers. Do not go here! Other Little Italy pizza places in the city are actually good, so I can only assume that this specific franchise on the Upper West Side is owned by someone else.

Kate

This is the last time I will ever eat here. It was 37 degrees, windy, and sleeting, and the front door was left wide open while people were trying to eat. I politely asked the guy at the register to close it. He said yes — and then just stood there and didn’t do it. When I finally closed it myself, he got in my face and kept asking if I “didn’t understand him.” That kind of aggressive and disrespectful behavior toward a customer is unacceptable. Instead of making sure people inside were comfortable and their food wasn’t getting cold, he chose to argue and intimidate me. Expanding a dining area means nothing if customers are freezing while eating. Terrible service and zero professionalism. I won’t be back.

steven castro

I was extremely disappointed with this place. The food was terrible—pizza was cold, soggy, and completely lacking flavor. The crust tasted stale and the toppings felt cheap and poorly prepared. On top of that, the deals they advertise are misleading. The so-called “specials” weren’t honored in-store, and when I asked about them, staff acted like they had no idea what I was talking about. It honestly felt like false advertising just to get customers in the door. For the price, this place is absolutely not worth it. I won’t be coming back and wouldn’t recommend it to anyone.

cal hirschel

I used to come here all the time and was treated very well I would even get left off the hook if I was a couple bucks short but after coming here these later days I’ve noticed some new employees are extremely rude 1st incident was when I got my pizza and he dident give the full amount of change so I asked again and he visually got angry and grunted something I don’t know what he said it was in Spanish. Incident 2 I was with my friends and they got some pizza at the time I really had to use the restroom so I asked very politely if I could use the restroom after they just ordered to which he told me once that I couldn’t and then just ignored me. Incident 3 I was with my friend at the time he had a broken ankle so I was helping him walk round after I bought the pizza he told my friend to hurry up cause he was distracted and said oh I hope your card doesn’t decline I just think this was a bit inappropriate especially the fact I’m only a sophomore in high school this behavior is COMPLETELY UNACCEPTABLE

Dylans

Don’t usually write bad reviews, but this place is not good. Workers are terrible and treat their job like a joke, their bathroom says “customers only” and they let in a guy who didn’t buy anything before me, when I bought 2 slices and a bottle water. I’ve been here a couple years back, pizza was great, now the cheese tastes watery and honestly very poor pizza for 4 bucks. If you’re around the area, walk the couple of blocks and spend your money elsewhere because this pizza is not good at all. Dominos Pizza has better flavor. Its a disgrace.