New York Pizza

I love their deep dish combo pizza. The toppings and ingredients are high quality. The owner is very friendly and makes excellent pizza.

Consistently good pizza at a good price. We've only done carry out from here but you can't beat 2 large 2 topping pizzas for $25.

Been going there for years and great pizza and great prices with the best customer service

Ordered the pepperoni pizza slice it was fantastic. Sauce was on point and crust was great. Will cam.back again to enjoy.

Been eating here since they opened. Great little place! Good food and fast delivery! Lower than average prices too!

DOUBLE CHEESE!!! When ever we have friends out of town, first request is double cheese from New York. It's the best pizza you'll ever have.

I stopped in to order a pizza and some wings to go. I ordered a thin crust 2 toppings (pepperoni and sausage) with white garlic sauce and the BBQ wings. I also asked for a side of classic red sauce to dip- it tasted great! The service was extremely friendly and helpful. You wont trust me until you try yourself, but I think they sell the best pizza in town. Definitely will come back!!

This is so good now this is my comfort food and i love how they add good amount of veggies on pizza . Taste wise I would definitely rate 10/10

I've been going here every Wednesday to get a Pizza and they never disappoint. They are always on top of it and whenever I get there, it is always ready for me. These people are incredible and I hope they read my review

My first time having this pizza and it was so good 😊. Nice and cheesy goodness that will keep you coming back 🤗💕

My family and I have been coming to this place for the past 7 years! The food is great and the staff are so friendly. The crust is made of the best dough and comes out a delicious, fluffy taste. A unique taste. The best!

Michael Gavia

I've been going here every Wednesday to get a Pizza and they never disappoint. They are always on top of it and whenever I get there, it is always ready for me. These people are incredible and I hope they read my review

Manpreet Kaur

This is so good now this is my comfort food and i love how they add good amount of veggies on pizza . Taste wise I would definitely rate 10/10

Delvita Rollins

My first time having this pizza and it was so good 😊. Nice and cheesy goodness that will keep you coming back 🤗💕

Ghazal Amiri

My family and I have been coming to this place for the past 7 years! The food is great and the staff are so friendly. The crust is made of the best dough and comes out a delicious, fluffy taste. A unique taste. The best!

That pizza was great . Had to write this review ASAP . My gf and I were craving a slice and usually only buy per slice this place was awesome .2$ slices the dough was awesome and cooked perfectly. Everything is fresh as well . The worker brought our slices out-we were waiting in front of the store in our car and was really nice . This is a great smalll business and I highly advise supporting them 100 percent worth stopping by and getting a hot slice of pizza !!!!

Great experience everytime. My daughter who is autistic absolutely loves their pizza. We get it literally almost everyday. They are a really nice and personable family operation. They aren't shy about letting you know about the most affordable way you can buy one of their pizzas. They are already a very generous price but they still have sweet deals. I love how they are inclusive as well with their staffing. I encourage everyone to give them a try.

I ordered pizza here on Thanksgiving as everything else was closed. Let me tell you they were amazing. They are on the same level as Bjs Brewhouse and Lampost Pizza and a lot better than Pizza guys and Pizza Hut. There chicken strips were amazing and get this they have cheese cake. Thank you New York Pizza will go back soon.

New York pizza is a great place to get some good fresh made pizza if you in Elk Grove the atmosphere there is pretty good the staff is friendly I enjoy it here

Thank you NY Pizza! The pizza here is so good I came in for a few slices and am now hooked Come buy your pizza here. Great tasting flavorful and juicy, not dry, not bland Making NY proud

Have ordered delivery here a few times and never disappointed. Much more tasty than other competitors! Always fresh!

I eaten pizza in alot of places their pizza tastes the best better than other New York pizza places

What a pleasant surprise this place was! I didn’t even know it was there, but my husband placed an order for lunch and I went to grab it. It was really inexpensive and also very very delicious! We’ll definitely be back.

Cornelius Wilkins

Great experience everytime. My daughter who is autistic absolutely loves their pizza. We get it literally almost everyday. They are a really nice and personable family operation. They aren't shy about letting you know about the most affordable way you can buy one of their pizzas. They are already a very generous price but they still have sweet deals. I love how they are inclusive as well with their staffing. I encourage everyone to give them a try.

NYPD 911

I ordered pizza here on Thanksgiving as everything else was closed. Let me tell you they were amazing. They are on the same level as Bjs Brewhouse and Lampost Pizza and a lot better than Pizza guys and Pizza Hut. There chicken strips were amazing and get this they have cheese cake. Thank you New York Pizza will go back soon.

Bakari Powell

New York pizza is a great place to get some good fresh made pizza if you in Elk Grove the atmosphere there is pretty good the staff is friendly I enjoy it here

John Johni

I eaten pizza in alot of places their pizza tastes the best better than other New York pizza places

Maxwell Simmons

Thank you NY Pizza! The pizza here is so good I came in for a few slices and am now hooked Come buy your pizza here. Great tasting flavorful and juicy, not dry, not bland Making NY proud

Rodolfo Garza

Have ordered delivery here a few times and never disappointed. Much more tasty than other competitors! Always fresh!

Kate Amar

What a pleasant surprise this place was! I didn’t even know it was there, but my husband placed an order for lunch and I went to grab it. It was really inexpensive and also very very delicious! We’ll definitely be back.

bp s

That pizza was great . Had to write this review ASAP . My gf and I were craving a slice and usually only buy per slice this place was awesome .2$ slices the dough was awesome and cooked perfectly. Everything is fresh as well . The worker brought our slices out-we were waiting in front of the store in our car and was really nice . This is a great smalll business and I highly advise supporting them 100 percent worth stopping by and getting a hot slice of pizza !!!!

Picked up pizza - it was ready right on time. Ordered a pepperoni thin crust - TONS of pepperoni! Good stuff! Wings were good but definitely not spicy.

Delicious, quick, and cheap! The guys at NYP create awesome pizzas that taste more authentic than chain restaurants. The pizzas only take about 12-15 minutes to bake, and there are plenty of special mail offers.

For the majority of the time it's a great experience! My family absolutely loves the pizza, we have yet to try anything other then pizza. But every time we order it's delicious! I am taking away 1 star because of my experience with customer service. Every time I go in it's the same person so to me it seems as though this is his families business so I won't give him too much trouble,. I just wish he was a little kinder, we all have bad day's... But we're not in New York, we're in Elk Grove California. A small town with the kindest people, we care about our people and want the respect we give, in return... Looking forward to my next visit because this is the best pizza in town!

My food was done very fast. I made a call in order and everything was correct. Not the best ranch I’ve had, it tasted very mid. They were calling me and rushing me to get my food. Aside from the onions the pizza was pretty sweet, which threw me off a bit. The person pizza was very affordable and comes with 2 toppings. Next time I want to try the calzone.

Love NY Pizza! Delicious pizza at a reasonable price. I called the order in and it was ready when I arrived to pick it up! Just look at that Pepperoni and olive hot pie!

Rielle Powell

My food was done very fast. I made a call in order and everything was correct. Not the best ranch I’ve had, it tasted very mid. They were calling me and rushing me to get my food. Aside from the onions the pizza was pretty sweet, which threw me off a bit. The person pizza was very affordable and comes with 2 toppings. Next time I want to try the calzone.

Joshua Williams

Love NY Pizza! Delicious pizza at a reasonable price. I called the order in and it was ready when I arrived to pick it up! Just look at that Pepperoni and olive hot pie!

Haven't been here in 2 years. White sauce was extremely salty! Dough, pepperoni and sausage great. Had 1 slice & couldn't eat anymore.

DO NOT ORDER ONLINE.. if they do not accept your order right away they will still charge you and then you have to order again. So I was charged 2 times for over $100 order and said I will be refunded in a few days. Most of the food was really good but adding a charge for deep dish and it was just regular crust was disappointing. Make sure you ask for condiments, I asked if they gave me ranch and they said yes but there was none.

Dough is very thick and not cooked long enough and doesn't resemble new work pizza. Too much sauce. Pepperoni is great.

Shannon Spencer

Dough is very thick and not cooked long enough and doesn't resemble new work pizza. Too much sauce. Pepperoni is great.

Megan Staley

DO NOT ORDER ONLINE.. if they do not accept your order right away they will still charge you and then you have to order again. So I was charged 2 times for over $100 order and said I will be refunded in a few days. Most of the food was really good but adding a charge for deep dish and it was just regular crust was disappointing. Make sure you ask for condiments, I asked if they gave me ranch and they said yes but there was none.

Really pushy you first walk in there and they want you to decide right away didn't like that. I've been to New York pizza before but in the Bay Area which was really great. This specific location in Elk Grove I will never go back really terrible Pizza get better pizza at Costco and cheaper.

DO NOT WASTE Y OUR TIME!! They mess up your order...and because they dont really want to fix it; they tell you because their busy...it will take 2 or more hours to send a corrected pizza. Just bad business. Also, I'm from NY...this is NOT NY pizza. And who serves antipasto salad and only has ranch dressing...hello...antipasto in NY usually comes with Italian dressing, unless you ask for something else. We now have food no-one will eat.

Server was fast and efficient. The pizza was very dry and not much In the way of toppings. A full star is actually generous.

Visit first time and very rude store person 👎🏻

Rude. Walked in picked up the pizza and the dude asked for a tip. Like wth? They have no respect and the pizza was full of grease. Not a place to spend your money. Low quality.

The people who serve you are rude and don't treat you well.

The dude that was going to get my pizza was not wearing gloves and his hands were dirty. It looked like he was playing in dirt. He was going to grab my pizza with those dirty hands. Immediately no. That’s sick.

I always feel a bit of excitement, hearing "New York Pizza" in a new town. Pizza is my passion and a great New York style pie is the pinnacle of pizza pleasure. Unfortunately, this pizza was a spectacular disappointment. Maybe this is upstate New York Pizza? New York City style pizza, it is not. It's barely passable as pizza. As I sat savoring this sad-looking slice, I found myself reminded of a roadside struggle pizza I had in a gas station once, the kind that sits out looking miserable but possibly edible under those heat lamps. Dried-out, overcooked, and sat in the open air all day. The pepperoni was dry and lacking flavor, the chopped garlic was burnt to a deep brown. We had a thick and thin crust, both were equally meh. Poor texture, no taste. The sauce is a cooked tomato - almost no tomato flavor, heavy on the herbs. The cheese is rubbery and unpleasant, as well. I wish I had something positive to say about this pie, but there wasn't anything to be said.

I have been coming to New York Pizza on elk Grove florin Road for years i’ve always thought they’ve had a great product for a great price until this business sold the new owners that have been there for a couple of years so I have continued to do business here until now they Have no idea how to run a business. I understand businesses have expenses what I don’t understand is how The owner of this business tries to hustle you over the phone and charge you a higher price than what he advertises also also tries to charge you for condiments after you’ve spent $80 or more I would encourage anybody that wants good customer service and quality product for what they spend their money on to not go here this owner is a jerk

Not exactly sure why they say New York pizza sorry but this is not New York style pizza. Very small for buying by the slice. Looks more like buying the slice from a perosnal size pizza. Been in here twice and the service is never friendly very always look like they hate their jobs.

A

Not exactly sure why they say New York pizza sorry but this is not New York style pizza. Very small for buying by the slice. Looks more like buying the slice from a perosnal size pizza. Been in here twice and the service is never friendly very always look like they hate their jobs.

Dear owner. You’re unprofessional. I deal with many restaurants and most are polite and have manners. We can talk like men face to face. Let me know.

Been coming here for years and I’ve had enough bad experiences to where I’m never coming back. Today I ordered my pizza and they forgot to add one of the toppings before they cook the pizza. Instead of remaking the entire pizza, she crumples up some extra salami and throws it on after the pizza was already cooked. I ordered another pizza done correctly but paid for both without making an issue. The second pizza I got was rushed through the oven and super skimpy on the toppings. All in all I ended up paying $40 for two pizzas that are absolutely not what I wanted… this place is a letdown constantly, and there’s never any acknowledgment from the staff when something is wrong. They love to take your money and treat you like you don’t exist. I used to really stick up for this business and now I am definitely a hater of New York Pizza on Elk Grove florin road. Your customer service is terrible and you treat your customers like garbage.

The girl in the front with the glasses really needs to be better at customer service. Ordered 2 large pizzas and gave me 2 packets of cheese and 2 plates i asked for me gave me attitude and made it a issue. Was talking about me to her co worker very rude.

Sunday Venom

Dear owner. You’re unprofessional. I deal with many restaurants and most are polite and have manners. We can talk like men face to face. Let me know.

Julia Gonzales

The girl in the front with the glasses really needs to be better at customer service. Ordered 2 large pizzas and gave me 2 packets of cheese and 2 plates i asked for me gave me attitude and made it a issue. Was talking about me to her co worker very rude.

J J

Been coming here for years and I’ve had enough bad experiences to where I’m never coming back. Today I ordered my pizza and they forgot to add one of the toppings before they cook the pizza. Instead of remaking the entire pizza, she crumples up some extra salami and throws it on after the pizza was already cooked. I ordered another pizza done correctly but paid for both without making an issue. The second pizza I got was rushed through the oven and super skimpy on the toppings. All in all I ended up paying $40 for two pizzas that are absolutely not what I wanted… this place is a letdown constantly, and there’s never any acknowledgment from the staff when something is wrong. They love to take your money and treat you like you don’t exist. I used to really stick up for this business and now I am definitely a hater of New York Pizza on Elk Grove florin road. Your customer service is terrible and you treat your customers like garbage.