Bill R

Fantastic spot for casual dining. The food is excellent and the service was great. We were there on a very busy Saturday evening and expected a long wait. Our server took our orders quickly and our food arrived fast, hot, and it was delicious. There is a nice selection of beers including some local brewery selections. We will go back whenever in Baldwinsville.

Lauren Varno

This is not your ordinary pizza shop. They've got live music in a bar setting with high top tables and booth seating. And on the other side of the wall is the pizza and food. Pretty cool atmosphere and unlike any pizza place I've been to before. I can't comment on the food as we just stopped in on a whim and ordered a margarita. The margarita was delicious though!Recommend checking it out!

donna lord

We have never been here before and had a great experience! 🤩 We had the appetizer platter, everything was superb!! Then 2 orders of wings, 😋. We saw another table with pizza which also looked phenomenal.

J C

Small bar vibe, but the wings were great and the pizza was delicious.

James Licata

Absolutely loved the hot pineapple pizza, along with Hot BBQ wings. Our first time at pizza man since moving to B'Ville. Highly recommend it! Best pizza we've tried out of 3 other places to date.

Devin Swilling

Truly enjoyed this place. The atmosphere was great and the staff was extremely friendly. I travel all over the country for work and this is probably now in my top 5 places. I also have a very picky 6 year old who gives it 5 stars and 10 thumbs up. As soon as we got to our hotel he asked for more of his pizza. The wings were also perfectly sauced and cooked to perfection! Hope we have a chance to go again before we leave the area!

Mick Kel

I have been here twice. The first time i had the sheet pizza and it literally was one of the best ive had in a long time...the second time i went i got a large cheese and 10 hot wings. This time the pizza was good but the bottom could have been cooked a bit more. I think the sheet pizza was the better choice. The pizza sauce is great and the cheese/sauce ratio is good. The hot wings were cooked good but needed more sauce Overall its a good place and i will go back.

Tried 2 things here to compare to other pizza shops in town. Sauce was watery and cheese had weird taste on plain cheese pizza. Mushrooms on cheeseburger tasted like out of a can.

Willis Billis

Great people, but the style of pizza just isn’t our thing. Thicker crust, was a bit moist and crust soggy in center of pie. Couldn’t really taste the roasted red peppers, olives, sauce, onions, etc. Personally, I would have used higher quality ingredients and more of them, but that’s me. Giving 3 stars due to their being really nice.

John Doe

Has a nice old school, small town Irish pub feel. Food is usual sports bar fare. Perfectly ok. Nothing special. Limited beer list is biggest disappointment. Maybe 10 draft choices - all predictable and uninteresting.

Sam Wagner

Pizza wasn't great. Not awful but it tasted only slightly better than your typical frozen pizza. The Golden Garlic wing sauce was excellent and it's the reason I'm giving the review 3 stars. 5 for the boneless wings and sauce, 1 for the pizza.

Pizza was barely cooked, we could tell from the raw dough taste on the first bite and the visible uncooked dough beneath the cheese. We tried to salvage it in the oven on a pizza stone, but couldn’t get anything worth the effort.