The Review Critique

I recently visited this gem in Grand Island, NY and I must say the pizza was OUTSTANDING! Pizza was cooked to perfection and the taste was phenomenal. Perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni. You can tell the ingredients used are respectable! This restaurant should have more notoriety in the area. A must recommend and I will back when I crave pizza again!

Stephanie Proulx

Ordered the Nashville Hot Chicken Pizza and it was great! I called about 15 minutes before they closed and wasn't sure if I'd have time to stop in but the woman was super nice on the phone and I was able to get my order in! Once I got in there the woman who cashed me out was super friendly and I was happy to hear they would bring my pizza out to my car so I didn't have to wait inside! The pizza was great and I'm so glad I could try out a new local place (NT location)! Can't wait to try more of their delicious looking combos/creations!

Chris Petros

We were pleasantly surprised with an incredible menu, friendly staff and very clean restaurant. This is done it the absolute best pizza I've ever had and we definitely plan on coming back. The Italian stallion, barbeque chicken, and 716 were perfectly cooked and left us wishing we had more. I cant wait to eat here again. Edit: 2 years later and we finally made it back here on a family trip. Same great quality of food. We weren't disappointed in the least! This pizza is amazing, you won't regret it. Try the s'more log. It is as delicious as it is messy, the kids loved it!

Maldivian American Whitmore

The pizza was delicious! Cinnamon knots were ok, I would have loved it if it was baked a little bit more.

James Riley

Good food. Takeout order should be reviewed before you leave as it has most often been wrong or incomplete. It's located in a petrol station so atmosphere is non-existent. The photo is from a recent order where the normal menu salad had half a pound, or more, of feta on it. I thought maybe I was being pranked when I saw all the cheese on a normal Greek salad.

Dine In Buffalo

Good quality pizza, I would recommend to a friend. Ask to get the pie well done. Garlic knots are amazing.

Jordan Alves

I frequent this place at the fair, local events, and when I am in grand island. This place is a different take on the traditional Buffalo style pizza which is refreshing as something different from time to time. It is a rather thin with a charred crust. They took a bold approach to the sauce which is among the more spicy I have had which appeals to me but may not for those who prefer a sweeter variety. The cheese is high quality and not overpowering like some places. The pepperoni while tasty and name brand could be improved by fresh slicing it. The wait times often can be lengthy for mobile stand personal pizzas. While I appreciate the bake to order freshness and would not change that, perhaps simplifying the menu a bit could improve times. The workers are always very friendly and attentive. Prices are very fair.

Be sure to give them a buffer as the food is never ready when they say it will be. The food itself was good though!

Tannon Montea

My wife and I have been wondering about this place for awhile. Hearing better reviews than not; tonight we tried their Detroit Pizza and their award winning Galbani Amore'. Overall the pizza taste itself was good. Friendly service, neat and tidy establishment. However, The Galbani Amore' was burnt to a char half way around the pizza. Picking the burnt parts off, seeing if it was edible underneath didn't result in success. So, I gave the number of stars that I did because, being a business owner myself, I don't and would never serve a finished product to my clients that I myself wouldn't want. I also think that I too should have taken a look at the pizza prior to assuming we'd be getting a product we'd actually want. Also, navigating through their website to order isn't all that flexible. Options are restricted to a firm guideline of what they will create and make. This is another reason why "tipping" these days has lost the value of why a service is granted gratuity in the first place. It shouldn't be an option prior to the service being completed. So, because of these things I have rated Pizza Amore' a below average rating because I think most everything from this experience could have been better. Mildly disappointed and probably won't go back.

Engine62

Like what is this last time I got something from you guys !! Bottom of my pizza is black !!

Kaylin Peterson

worst meal ever. my chicken tenders were soggy, pizza was burnt and garlic knots were not seasoned. will never buy from this establishment again